WEBVTT

1
00:02:04.020 --> 00:02:05.250
jim robb: Yes, they did.

2
00:02:42.300 --> 00:02:43.290
james murez: we're getting closer.

3
00:02:57.720 --> 00:03:00.540
Daffodil Tyminski: To me, you may have to make me a Co host to run the zoom.

4
00:03:00.810 --> 00:03:02.370
james murez: yeah I haven't found you yet.

5
00:03:03.210 --> 00:03:04.110
james murez: or Oh, there you are.

6
00:03:06.540 --> 00:03:09.120
james murez: You know it's the thing doesn't always.

7
00:03:12.150 --> 00:03:16.080
james murez: click the first time, when you promote somebody sometimes you have to do it, two or three times.

8
00:03:19.650 --> 00:03:21.570
Daffodil Tyminski: You got it and Melissa is on as well.

9
00:03:22.740 --> 00:03:23.670
james murez: I saw that.

10
00:03:24.690 --> 00:03:25.470
james murez: i'm.

11
00:03:31.740 --> 00:03:33.150
james murez: Your co host by now.

12
00:03:33.930 --> 00:03:36.630
james murez: yeah and everybody can share screens.

13
00:03:40.530 --> 00:03:43.530
james murez: They tried the go once trying to again.

14
00:03:44.280 --> 00:03:45.480
Daffodil Tyminski: We have a quorum.

15
00:03:50.130 --> 00:03:53.220
james murez: And we see dwp and lapd are both here already.

16
00:03:54.510 --> 00:03:56.910
james murez: Melissa diner is still in the audience.

17
00:03:59.400 --> 00:04:01.260
james murez: i've tried three times to promote her.

18
00:04:02.340 --> 00:04:02.850
Daffodil Tyminski: Let me try.

19
00:04:03.300 --> 00:04:05.100
james murez: Now I just try it again let's see there, she is.

20
00:04:07.290 --> 00:04:08.370
james murez: In there see ma.

21
00:04:25.710 --> 00:04:26.580
james murez: The gym Robin yeah.

22
00:04:28.530 --> 00:04:29.820
james murez: there's another gym there.

23
00:04:48.390 --> 00:04:53.940
james murez: Committee members that are in the audience, please raise your hand now.

24
00:04:59.760 --> 00:05:07.320
james murez: Seeing no raised hands, I think, what do we have we have 17 yeah we have 17 board members that's enough to get started.

25
00:05:08.130 --> 00:05:08.520
yeah.

26
00:05:09.540 --> 00:05:11.850
james murez: i'm okay.

27
00:05:13.170 --> 00:05:13.830
james murez: Melissa.

28
00:05:15.180 --> 00:05:15.870
james murez: Are you there.

29
00:05:20.430 --> 00:05:22.650
james murez: So everybody knows, she contacted me she might not mad.

30
00:05:23.010 --> 00:05:26.010
james murez: yeah Okay, can you do roll call or do you want me to start off doing.

31
00:05:26.040 --> 00:05:27.690
melissadiner: I can take me a second.

32
00:05:27.840 --> 00:05:31.470
james murez: Okay, so we're opening this meeting at 602.

33
00:05:33.180 --> 00:05:34.650
james murez: Melissa please take the role.

34
00:05:46.470 --> 00:05:46.830
james murez: here.

35
00:05:47.130 --> 00:05:47.790
melissadiner: Stop it oh.

36
00:05:48.090 --> 00:05:49.950
melissadiner: yeah i'm President leaks.

37
00:05:51.450 --> 00:05:51.780
Alix: here.

38
00:05:52.050 --> 00:05:53.400
Vicki Halliday: vicki here.

39
00:05:56.550 --> 00:05:57.090
Sima Kostovetsky: here.

40
00:05:57.390 --> 00:05:58.980
Alley Bean: Ali here.

41
00:05:59.100 --> 00:06:00.420
Chie Lunn: hi here.

42
00:06:00.600 --> 00:06:01.440
melissadiner: Mike brava.

43
00:06:02.160 --> 00:06:02.520
Mike Bravo: yeah.

44
00:06:03.150 --> 00:06:03.900
melissadiner: How does this play.

45
00:06:04.410 --> 00:06:05.700
melissadiner: Here pull it up.

46
00:06:06.030 --> 00:06:11.310
melissadiner: Here oliver's not feeling well he's not coming James rob.

47
00:06:13.590 --> 00:06:13.980
melissadiner: He go.

48
00:06:14.940 --> 00:06:16.260
melissadiner: Here Scott Brown.

49
00:06:19.980 --> 00:06:20.250
melissadiner: Bad.

50
00:06:20.430 --> 00:06:22.650
james murez: I didn't see him, nor did I promote him so.

51
00:06:22.770 --> 00:06:26.100
Daffodil Tyminski: US Clark Brown and scan the homeowner both here, I will promote them now.

52
00:06:26.370 --> 00:06:27.180
james murez: Oh great Thank you.

53
00:06:27.870 --> 00:06:28.590
melissadiner: Alright, to video.

54
00:06:28.860 --> 00:06:30.240
melissadiner: Here, for now.

55
00:06:30.840 --> 00:06:31.170
here.

56
00:06:33.300 --> 00:06:34.410
melissadiner: Jason sugars.

57
00:06:39.330 --> 00:06:40.230
melissadiner: it's Jason here.

58
00:06:41.580 --> 00:06:42.300
james murez: didn't see him.

59
00:06:45.360 --> 00:06:47.640
Daffodil Tyminski: Do not see him.

60
00:06:47.700 --> 00:06:48.930
melissadiner: And dre about quality.

61
00:06:50.490 --> 00:06:50.970
melissadiner: DJ.

62
00:06:55.020 --> 00:06:55.560
melissadiner: DJ.

63
00:06:59.010 --> 00:07:00.420
james murez: cj you have to unmute yourself.

64
00:07:02.190 --> 00:07:02.700
CJ Cole: here.

65
00:07:03.540 --> 00:07:04.380
melissadiner: Stand Muhammad.

66
00:07:13.980 --> 00:07:19.710
melissadiner: 19 people are present to people are absent.

67
00:07:21.000 --> 00:07:22.140
james murez: Great okay.

68
00:07:23.760 --> 00:07:25.290
james murez: Let me start by.

69
00:07:26.370 --> 00:07:28.710
james murez: sharing my screen of the agenda.

70
00:07:30.720 --> 00:07:33.600
james murez: and moving right along.

71
00:07:38.160 --> 00:07:54.180
james murez: let's dedicate this meeting to honoring the indigenous people that we didn't celebrate their day and accident and error, no, you know, it was a I guess perhaps my fault but it wasn't on the calendar, it was on the calendar is.

72
00:07:55.050 --> 00:08:06.960
james murez: Columbus day and that's not something that typically was something that I realized was celebrated holiday and, since they changed it this year let's dedicate this meeting to the indigenous peoples day.

73
00:08:08.160 --> 00:08:10.770
james murez: i'm moving forward.

74
00:08:12.360 --> 00:08:16.200
james murez: We need a motion to approve the August 17.

75
00:08:17.520 --> 00:08:18.420
james murez: board minutes.

76
00:08:18.570 --> 00:08:20.280
Alix: i'll make the motion Jim it's a leaks.

77
00:08:20.910 --> 00:08:21.840
Vicki Halliday: vicki will second.

78
00:08:22.680 --> 00:08:26.670
james murez: Thank you vicki um any comment.

79
00:08:27.930 --> 00:08:29.040
james murez: Let me.

80
00:08:30.420 --> 00:08:31.950
james murez: bring up the list.

81
00:08:32.520 --> 00:08:35.490
Daffodil Tyminski: ready, I have no hands raised in the attendees shampoo.

82
00:08:35.700 --> 00:08:38.970
james murez: Okay, any any any committee members have any.

83
00:08:39.630 --> 00:08:43.920
Daffodil Tyminski: So seeing no hands raised in the public we're going to close public comment and move on to the committee.

84
00:08:44.130 --> 00:08:46.500
Daffodil Tyminski: So we have no hands raised in the committee.

85
00:08:46.950 --> 00:08:50.490
james murez: Clark you just decided to take over sharing the meeting screen.

86
00:08:51.750 --> 00:08:53.340
james murez: that's not a good idea.

87
00:08:54.180 --> 00:08:58.680
james murez: Sorry yeah so so let me go back and.

88
00:09:01.080 --> 00:09:01.920
Daffodil Tyminski: I got a Clark.

89
00:09:02.610 --> 00:09:03.060
yeah.

90
00:09:04.830 --> 00:09:07.020
james murez: So let me go back to sharing our agenda.

91
00:09:07.560 --> 00:09:09.240
melissadiner: Oh, can I take roll call now.

92
00:09:09.690 --> 00:09:10.590
james murez: Yes, please.

93
00:09:11.760 --> 00:09:13.170
melissadiner: Are not real called the boat.

94
00:09:13.680 --> 00:09:14.550
james murez: The boat for the.

95
00:09:14.730 --> 00:09:15.600
james murez: August 17.

96
00:09:16.650 --> 00:09:18.000
james murez: Yes, Jim yes.

97
00:09:18.660 --> 00:09:20.070
Daffodil Tyminski: daffodil yes.

98
00:09:20.190 --> 00:09:21.450
melissadiner: I vote yes, the leaks.

99
00:09:22.770 --> 00:09:24.150
Alix: Yes, biggie.

100
00:09:24.450 --> 00:09:25.500
Vicki Halliday: Yes, see.

101
00:09:26.820 --> 00:09:27.180
Sima Kostovetsky: ya.

102
00:09:27.720 --> 00:09:28.980
Alley Bean: Ali yes.

103
00:09:29.100 --> 00:09:31.830
melissadiner: Cry yes my bravo.

104
00:09:32.370 --> 00:09:33.780
melissadiner: Yes, was it clay.

105
00:09:34.200 --> 00:09:35.850
melissadiner: Yes, full dad.

106
00:09:35.970 --> 00:09:37.560
melissadiner: Yes, James Brown.

107
00:09:37.980 --> 00:09:38.370
Yes.

108
00:09:40.020 --> 00:09:40.470
Nico Ruderman: Yes.

109
00:09:40.680 --> 00:09:41.640
melissadiner: Clark Brown.

110
00:09:41.700 --> 00:09:43.200
melissadiner: Yes, narrative it out.

111
00:09:44.910 --> 00:09:45.660
robertthibodeau: Yes.

112
00:09:45.840 --> 00:09:47.010
melissadiner: For now Hernandez.

113
00:09:47.430 --> 00:09:48.810
melissadiner: Yes, Andrea.

114
00:09:49.170 --> 00:09:50.370
melissadiner: This cj.

115
00:09:50.790 --> 00:09:51.990
melissadiner: Yes, Dan.

116
00:09:52.860 --> 00:10:01.320
james murez: yeah 19 00 did you Melissa did you add Clark, to the roster.

117
00:10:01.770 --> 00:10:02.370
melissadiner: he's on there.

118
00:10:02.700 --> 00:10:04.290
melissadiner: From my doctor said he was.

119
00:10:04.530 --> 00:10:11.430
james murez: Okay, thank you um now I need a motion to approve the September 21 board meeting minutes.

120
00:10:11.700 --> 00:10:12.750
Alley Bean: i'll make the motion.

121
00:10:13.170 --> 00:10:13.740
james murez: Who is a.

122
00:10:14.010 --> 00:10:17.010
james murez: alley second second.

123
00:10:17.370 --> 00:10:19.320
james murez: Robert Thank you Robert.

124
00:10:20.790 --> 00:10:23.670
james murez: Do we have any public comment I see two hands are raised.

125
00:10:25.440 --> 00:10:26.610
james murez: The two hands.

126
00:10:29.370 --> 00:10:31.560
Daffodil Tyminski: It sounds Helen fallon and arrow to say.

127
00:10:32.520 --> 00:10:34.110
james murez: Okay, so.

128
00:10:35.160 --> 00:10:36.750
Daffodil Tyminski: Helen why don't you go first.

129
00:10:38.640 --> 00:10:47.400
Helen Fallon: I just want to point out that it's difficult to promote on both on Minutes that have not been posted either the special meeting or the regular meeting hosted.

130
00:10:49.290 --> 00:10:51.840
Helen Fallon: So the public has had no opportunity to do with movies.

131
00:10:57.900 --> 00:10:59.610
Daffodil Tyminski: um go ahead.

132
00:11:03.360 --> 00:11:21.750
Darryl DuFay: Mine is the same thing the file number 23420 is for an agenda, it is not for the Minutes and the Minutes are not there you can't find the Minutes, because if you click on the file that's supposed to be the Minutes that comes up with an agenda.

133
00:11:23.880 --> 00:11:32.190
james murez: yeah I see the problem and both of you are describing I just clicked on the I just copied and pasted the link into the address line, and although it says.

134
00:11:32.190 --> 00:11:35.520
Darryl DuFay: That that's 20 316 so that's for August.

135
00:11:37.560 --> 00:11:39.090
that's for August.

136
00:11:41.190 --> 00:11:48.930
Darryl DuFay: And when I when I knew I didn't have the Minutes, because when they whenever it came up there's there was no red markings like anything happened.

137
00:11:48.930 --> 00:11:53.100
melissadiner: they're not posted so let's just move on, we don't need to debate it more Jim.

138
00:11:53.280 --> 00:11:54.870
james murez: Well then, we cannot approve them.

139
00:11:55.590 --> 00:11:56.850
melissadiner: yeah no problem.

140
00:12:00.090 --> 00:12:04.740
james murez: There September just the first word right there says agenda instead of minutes.

141
00:12:04.890 --> 00:12:06.660
Darryl DuFay: Yes, and if you.

142
00:12:07.290 --> 00:12:09.240
james murez: The information is there.

143
00:12:10.260 --> 00:12:14.280
Darryl DuFay: Not there is not any red marketing at all at anything to.

144
00:12:14.280 --> 00:12:20.730
james murez: Open the September one you're right I didn't notice that I thought the September one was there okay my bad.

145
00:12:22.140 --> 00:12:23.910
james murez: So we can't approve this September one.

146
00:12:25.320 --> 00:12:29.400
james murez: But we did approve the biggest one, although it says.

147
00:12:31.200 --> 00:12:34.530
james murez: agenda at the top we'll have to get that corrected, but those were the Minutes.

148
00:12:35.970 --> 00:12:40.380
james murez: This, this is the Minutes for August, it has all the information so.

149
00:12:42.000 --> 00:12:43.470
james murez: Okay let's keep moving on.

150
00:12:44.940 --> 00:12:45.630
james murez: um.

151
00:12:50.280 --> 00:12:51.210
james murez: Presidents report.

152
00:12:53.790 --> 00:12:59.610
james murez: So the first thing is, we have a deadline, we need to get.

153
00:13:01.020 --> 00:13:04.380
james murez: Our redistricting plan into the city.

154
00:13:06.240 --> 00:13:19.710
james murez: By next week and they've sort of created a deadline or two and it's sort of unclear that continue to push it around so everybody will have an opportunity to discuss and.

155
00:13:21.120 --> 00:13:23.040
james murez: Take some position on the.

156
00:13:27.150 --> 00:13:38.370
james murez: items that we're going to be presenting to them, we need to have a special meeting and so these were the three dates that I drew out of the hat that seemed like the most convenient times for people.

157
00:13:39.270 --> 00:13:53.670
james murez: It seems as though i've gotten several responses back for the time a and the time be which are Saturday, either at 11 or at one, and what I would like to do is is go through.

158
00:13:56.640 --> 00:14:07.740
james murez: The list of board members right now that are here and see who can make each of the meetings, so we can have some idea of whether or not we can get 11 Members to have a quorum for that meeting so.

159
00:14:07.800 --> 00:14:11.010
Daffodil Tyminski: And Jim Jim rob has his hand raised, he may have a question.

160
00:14:11.400 --> 00:14:18.300
jim robb: Okay, I have my ocean for a walk meeting on the 25th at 6pm with the scooter companies.

161
00:14:19.140 --> 00:14:24.780
james murez: Okay, so that wouldn't work so we're going to do it on Saturday I think it's going to either be the heir to be time okay.

162
00:14:24.870 --> 00:14:26.100
jim robb: That helps Thank you.

163
00:14:26.280 --> 00:14:27.930
james murez: yeah let me see if I can.

164
00:14:29.100 --> 00:14:33.240
james murez: I just need to very quickly i'm going to run a quick tally on this and see.

165
00:14:34.470 --> 00:14:35.340
james murez: see who can.

166
00:14:36.720 --> 00:14:37.500
james murez: Why can't.

167
00:14:41.190 --> 00:14:42.120
james murez: hang on one second.

168
00:14:43.230 --> 00:14:48.750
jim robb: Thanks Robert if you can join or send somebody if you want to for the meeting on the 25th.

169
00:14:50.820 --> 00:14:54.270
robertthibodeau: Okay yeah you mentioned that before and we'll we'll.

170
00:14:56.310 --> 00:14:58.770
robertthibodeau: Okay meet me or john or one of the guys would be there.

171
00:15:00.630 --> 00:15:01.860
james murez: For the time.

172
00:15:03.450 --> 00:15:04.200
james murez: That would be.

173
00:15:05.430 --> 00:15:17.910
james murez: 11 o'clock in the morning i'm just going to quickly run through the the board members names and if I asked your name, please tell me whether or not you can buy yes or no real quickly daffodil.

174
00:15:18.360 --> 00:15:19.770
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm sure Saturday.

175
00:15:20.550 --> 00:15:21.150
Okay.

176
00:15:22.890 --> 00:15:23.460
james murez: Melissa.

177
00:15:25.830 --> 00:15:26.580
james murez: Yes or no.

178
00:15:27.870 --> 00:15:28.710
james murez: With the time.

179
00:15:30.390 --> 00:15:31.350
melissadiner: i'm abstaining.

180
00:15:34.470 --> 00:15:35.070
james murez: Andre.

181
00:15:35.970 --> 00:15:36.390
No.

182
00:15:39.540 --> 00:15:40.110
james murez: lake.

183
00:15:43.440 --> 00:15:43.860
Alix: No.

184
00:15:46.710 --> 00:15:47.190
james murez: vicki.

185
00:15:48.060 --> 00:15:48.570
Yes.

186
00:15:49.740 --> 00:15:50.400
james murez: See ma.

187
00:15:51.750 --> 00:15:53.490
Sima Kostovetsky: I can do, one on Saturday.

188
00:15:54.630 --> 00:15:59.700
james murez: So the time or the be i'm asking about the time right now it's in the morning 11 o'clock.

189
00:16:01.920 --> 00:16:03.240
Sima Kostovetsky: No Jim Thank you.

190
00:16:05.160 --> 00:16:05.670
james murez: Ali.

191
00:16:06.060 --> 00:16:06.660
Yes.

192
00:16:09.000 --> 00:16:09.420
james murez: hi.

193
00:16:09.990 --> 00:16:10.440
Now.

194
00:16:13.110 --> 00:16:13.740
james murez: cj.

195
00:16:14.340 --> 00:16:14.970
Yes.

196
00:16:16.440 --> 00:16:17.010
james murez: Mike.

197
00:16:17.880 --> 00:16:18.450
Yes.

198
00:16:20.370 --> 00:16:21.000
james murez: Elizabeth.

199
00:16:21.690 --> 00:16:22.200
No.

200
00:16:24.600 --> 00:16:25.290
james murez: Solid yeah.

201
00:16:26.370 --> 00:16:29.880
Soledad Ursua: I can do either so should I just abstain i'll do whatever you guys want.

202
00:16:30.450 --> 00:16:34.200
james murez: i'll just put a yes for now okay Jason are you here to Jason show up.

203
00:16:35.340 --> 00:16:38.430
james murez: I don't think so okay oliver's not here, Jim rob.

204
00:16:40.440 --> 00:16:40.920
jim robb: No.

205
00:16:43.080 --> 00:16:43.710
james murez: NICO.

206
00:16:44.640 --> 00:16:46.110
Nico Ruderman: I apologize was that this Saturday.

207
00:16:46.500 --> 00:16:49.410
james murez: yeah this Saturday at 11 o'clock yeah no.

208
00:16:51.120 --> 00:16:53.790
james murez: yeah no that was like a oxymoron okay um.

209
00:16:53.820 --> 00:16:54.570
james murez: No Florida.

210
00:16:55.440 --> 00:16:55.920
know.

211
00:16:58.080 --> 00:16:58.710
james murez: Stan.

212
00:16:59.280 --> 00:16:59.820
know.

213
00:17:01.560 --> 00:17:02.040
james murez: Robert.

214
00:17:03.780 --> 00:17:09.450
robertthibodeau: i'm the same as soledad so i'm either expanding or whatever, whatever I can do either.

215
00:17:10.050 --> 00:17:12.180
james murez: Okay, great Bruno.

216
00:17:13.170 --> 00:17:13.620
Bruno Hernandez: And now.

217
00:17:15.150 --> 00:17:26.040
james murez: Okay let's see if we have 11 1236 and seven, so we only have seven What about the be time.

218
00:17:27.930 --> 00:17:31.290
james murez: Did anybody was anybody able to make to be time it couldn't make the time.

219
00:17:32.730 --> 00:17:35.430
james murez: that'd be one o'clock one o'clock in the afternoon on Saturday.

220
00:17:35.820 --> 00:17:37.320
Alix: I can jam it's a leaks.

221
00:17:38.820 --> 00:17:45.870
james murez: um Okay, let me go through the list again so on yes daffodil yes or no.

222
00:17:46.530 --> 00:17:47.850
Daffodil Tyminski: Probably not uncertain.

223
00:17:48.810 --> 00:17:50.100
james murez: Okay, Melissa.

224
00:17:53.160 --> 00:17:54.810
melissadiner: I have family in town, this weekend.

225
00:17:56.490 --> 00:17:57.150
james murez: Yes or no.

226
00:17:58.200 --> 00:17:58.590
melissadiner: No.

227
00:18:00.210 --> 00:18:00.720
james murez: Andre.

228
00:18:00.990 --> 00:18:02.310
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes or no yes.

229
00:18:04.470 --> 00:18:05.490
james murez: A leak, yes or no.

230
00:18:06.510 --> 00:18:06.960
Alix: Yes.

231
00:18:08.550 --> 00:18:12.570
james murez: vicki yes or no, yes, see my yes or no.

232
00:18:15.240 --> 00:18:15.780
Sima Kostovetsky: Yes.

233
00:18:18.000 --> 00:18:18.720
james murez: Yes or no.

234
00:18:19.050 --> 00:18:19.650
Yes.

235
00:18:21.480 --> 00:18:22.920
james murez: Yes or no yes.

236
00:18:24.150 --> 00:18:25.350
james murez: cj yes or no.

237
00:18:25.650 --> 00:18:26.130
Yes.

238
00:18:27.360 --> 00:18:28.680
james murez: Mike bravo yes or no.

239
00:18:29.070 --> 00:18:29.640
Yes.

240
00:18:30.840 --> 00:18:32.220
james murez: Elizabeth play yes or no.

241
00:18:33.780 --> 00:18:38.550
ElizabethClay: i'm going to change for the morning, I have to say no, for the sun put me back on the morning one.

242
00:18:38.790 --> 00:18:39.300
Okay.

243
00:18:40.980 --> 00:18:46.140
james murez: But we're only going to do one but that's Okay, we just have to get 11 people Sola dad yes or no.

244
00:18:46.710 --> 00:18:47.580
Soledad Ursua: Yes, either.

245
00:18:49.800 --> 00:18:54.090
james murez: Jason yes or no he's not here all of her is not here, Jim rock yes or no.

246
00:18:54.390 --> 00:18:55.560
jim robb: Yes, for the late one.

247
00:18:56.010 --> 00:18:58.860
james murez: Yes, for the way one NICO for one o'clock Saturday.

248
00:18:59.730 --> 00:19:00.120
No.

249
00:19:01.380 --> 00:19:02.070
james murez: Okay.

250
00:19:02.460 --> 00:19:03.480
james murez: Clark, yes or no.

251
00:19:03.510 --> 00:19:04.140
So.

252
00:19:05.700 --> 00:19:06.900
james murez: Stan yes or no.

253
00:19:07.410 --> 00:19:07.950
No.

254
00:19:09.240 --> 00:19:10.620
james murez: Robert tippett oh yes or no.

255
00:19:11.040 --> 00:19:12.240
robertthibodeau: i'm yes i'm coaching.

256
00:19:13.980 --> 00:19:14.880
james murez: Bruno yes or no.

257
00:19:15.750 --> 00:19:16.050
No.

258
00:19:17.550 --> 00:19:19.410
james murez: Okay, let me just quickly.

259
00:19:29.340 --> 00:19:41.730
james murez: So we have 12 people everybody shows up, we can have a meeting so it'll be one o'clock i'll post the agenda or a one item agenda on Saturday at one o'clock.

260
00:19:44.280 --> 00:19:46.800
james murez: Okay, glad we got that like.

261
00:19:47.100 --> 00:19:48.570
james murez: zoo yeah what.

262
00:19:48.930 --> 00:19:49.740
Alley Bean: Is it zoom.

263
00:19:49.770 --> 00:19:50.790
james murez: yeah it will be a zoom me.

264
00:19:51.510 --> 00:19:51.870
Alley Bean: Thank you.

265
00:19:52.260 --> 00:19:54.120
james murez: I have a couple of quick announcements.

266
00:19:56.220 --> 00:20:07.920
james murez: In in, I would like everybody to make a special be particularly aware that next month we're going to change public comment and on our agenda, let me quickly share our screen.

267
00:20:09.480 --> 00:20:11.280
Where it says soon.

268
00:20:13.110 --> 00:20:17.010
While poisons acting with thurston to hold on one second box.

269
00:20:19.200 --> 00:20:20.310
james murez: There soon.

270
00:20:32.670 --> 00:20:35.790
james murez: I just want to point out this note, right here.

271
00:20:37.020 --> 00:20:41.280
james murez: describes how we are going to be changing public comment come next month.

272
00:20:43.320 --> 00:20:50.190
james murez: And I want everybody to be aware of it, no, no surprises or shocks they're going to put all of the public comment at the beginning of the meeting.

273
00:20:50.550 --> 00:21:02.190
james murez: Rather than throughout the entire meeting so it'll be handled more the way the city and coastal Commission handles it um there's next item that I want to make everyone aware of.

274
00:21:03.570 --> 00:21:13.380
james murez: um there is an able training which Freddie sent us all information about he actually sent us a long laundry list of all sorts of things that.

275
00:21:13.770 --> 00:21:23.820
james murez: done is now offering it's on the Item number three on the list if it's a The anti what's it called the the a bolt a ble was anti.

276
00:21:24.510 --> 00:21:33.270
james murez: bias something around there I don't remember what the acronym was but anyway, I wanted to make that everybody pay attention that the end of November, I believe, is the due date for that.

277
00:21:35.190 --> 00:21:36.750
james murez: next item, I wanted to mention.

278
00:21:38.520 --> 00:21:54.030
james murez: The bylaws say that all board members are supposed to participate on at least one committee a bunch of board members are not participating on any committees as of now it's now been three months, and I wanted to remind everybody that that's required.

279
00:21:56.040 --> 00:21:56.880
james murez: Last month.

280
00:21:58.110 --> 00:21:59.820
james murez: NICO made a great suggestion.

281
00:22:00.870 --> 00:22:17.910
james murez: let's have a qr code that talks about events, this is the qr code that now talks about events and this webpage then in cincy forward slash events is a new place where outreach is going to start putting all of our event information, I want to make everybody aware of that.

282
00:22:20.730 --> 00:22:33.990
james murez: I sent out to the entire board, and I only got one or two feedbacks about a list of YouTube addresses that I sent out that referenced all of the items on our agenda today.

283
00:22:34.380 --> 00:22:44.850
james murez: And, before I take the hour hour and a half that it took me to put that together for future meetings, I would like to get some idea from the rest of you can send me an email, whether or not it was helpful to be able to have.

284
00:22:47.460 --> 00:22:58.740
james murez: The YouTube with the agenda item, so you could listen to what happened in the committee meetings and you'd be more informed when you come to the Board and the last thing that I would like to mention.

285
00:23:00.660 --> 00:23:13.080
james murez: I have gotten several complaints from different board members and from stakeholders about the code of conduct of some of our board members attacking them either on social media or verbally.

286
00:23:14.040 --> 00:23:30.840
james murez: that's unacceptable, we have to respect each other, and we have to be nice and, at the end of the day, we all have to work together, and the only way that's going to work in any kind of a positive format is if we are polite so having said that.

287
00:23:32.460 --> 00:23:35.670
james murez: Any ex parte communications or conflict of interest.

288
00:23:35.970 --> 00:23:42.060
Daffodil Tyminski: To you, we have a few hands raised, I don't know if their questions, but also we wanted to talk about motions submitted.

289
00:23:44.010 --> 00:23:53.220
james murez: Why don't you talk about motion submitted, and then the hands that are raised typically during the, I guess, we can do that, and so, why don't I go through the hands real quick.

290
00:23:53.640 --> 00:23:54.150
james murez: And I.

291
00:23:54.450 --> 00:23:56.280
Daffodil Tyminski: And they finally leaks and.

292
00:23:56.280 --> 00:23:57.630
Daffodil Tyminski: cj have a question.

293
00:23:57.720 --> 00:24:00.660
james murez: yeah I stopped sharing, so I could see go ahead tj.

294
00:24:01.710 --> 00:24:04.800
CJ Cole: Okay, my question had to do with.

295
00:24:05.850 --> 00:24:16.260
CJ Cole: The first item, which was putting your public comments to the front, which I have no problems with except that if.

296
00:24:18.360 --> 00:24:26.850
CJ Cole: You have anybody not I mean anybody asks that the arm.

297
00:24:27.990 --> 00:24:34.770
CJ Cole: You know it's the one you know the ones that you know, are the wait a second I had it marked on my agenda.

298
00:24:34.980 --> 00:24:44.850
james murez: Read me cj let me, let me interrupt you, if I may we're going to be publishing exactly how that's going to work I just put it on there as a note so everybody would be aware of it.

299
00:24:44.880 --> 00:24:47.280
james murez: There are some details that we have to still work through.

300
00:24:47.280 --> 00:24:50.460
james murez: And document, for instance, if emotion is.

301
00:24:50.490 --> 00:24:52.620
james murez: is altered during the meeting if somebody wants to.

302
00:24:52.620 --> 00:24:55.770
james murez: create an altar emotion that will reopen public comment on that one item.

303
00:24:57.450 --> 00:25:01.110
CJ Cole: yeah my My concern was ones that were on the.

304
00:25:02.790 --> 00:25:03.930
CJ Cole: The consent.

305
00:25:05.130 --> 00:25:07.380
CJ Cole: Calendar if they get pulled off.

306
00:25:11.130 --> 00:25:11.700
james murez: i'm.

307
00:25:12.840 --> 00:25:16.410
james murez: Working we can get into that more um.

308
00:25:17.910 --> 00:25:20.250
james murez: I don't I don't have an answer for you right now okay.

309
00:25:21.390 --> 00:25:22.170
james murez: Kelly go ahead.

310
00:25:22.710 --> 00:25:28.890
Alley Bean: I am my my only question about this it's the same it's the same a point of question.

311
00:25:29.640 --> 00:25:39.240
Alley Bean: On I just is that something that we're we're as a board going to be able to have a discussion about my feeling is like if it's a big big item.

312
00:25:40.170 --> 00:25:46.410
Alley Bean: That comes towards the end of the meeting that's have specific say land use issue or something with specifics.

313
00:25:46.980 --> 00:25:57.180
Alley Bean: If it's at the very beginning of the meeting, my gut reaction, because I didn't know this was going to be just sort of decided would be that people might not remember.

314
00:25:57.810 --> 00:26:04.830
Alley Bean: You know that somebody thought that X, Y and Z was going to happen, and if the public comment is right before that.

315
00:26:05.340 --> 00:26:16.050
Alley Bean: agenda item I would think it would be more fresh in our mind, so I was wondering what the thinking behind that wasn't do we get to vote on that or is that just a decision because i'm not actually sure that I would.

316
00:26:16.680 --> 00:26:19.710
james murez: So yeah let me, let me, let me stop the discussion about this.

317
00:26:19.980 --> 00:26:22.830
Daffodil Tyminski: And let me just jump in that we do have lapd waiting.

318
00:26:22.830 --> 00:26:23.250
james murez: So.

319
00:26:23.580 --> 00:26:25.770
Daffodil Tyminski: I don't want anything questions, but we need to start.

320
00:26:25.830 --> 00:26:27.450
james murez: Really normally the presidents.

321
00:26:27.450 --> 00:26:37.110
james murez: Report does not get any public comment or any committee comment whatsoever, this is a bad idea and i'm going to stop it at this point, everybody has to put their hands back down we'll get into this stuff.

322
00:26:37.410 --> 00:26:43.590
james murez: We can talk about this kind of thing offline This is all procedural it has nothing to do with the content of the meeting.

323
00:26:44.040 --> 00:26:52.320
james murez: So we're not going to get into the details of it here and i'll be happy to talk to ellie or cj anybody that wants to talk about this, you happy to discuss it with them later.

324
00:26:52.830 --> 00:26:53.370
Alix: yeah I.

325
00:26:53.460 --> 00:26:56.610
Alix: Question that's not on the procedure, can I just ask it quickly.

326
00:26:57.420 --> 00:27:12.540
Alix: Okay, thanks sorry it's really just about the the note that Freddie said I was a little confused as to whether they're these are additional required trainings or they just trainings if we want to is the bias training required I wasn't quite clear on that, so I would just love your.

327
00:27:14.160 --> 00:27:21.450
james murez: The only the only training that is required is that able training, which is to by the end of September it's number three the rest of them.

328
00:27:21.630 --> 00:27:22.140
Alix: got it well.

329
00:27:22.230 --> 00:27:28.890
james murez: it's it's all just training to be able, for people to become more educated I believe they are reopening the.

330
00:27:29.280 --> 00:27:38.610
james murez: loop pack training the 101 loop Pack and i'm going to see if we can get all of it, make it possible for all of our board members also take that to everybody, because if we created, but I don't have an answer on that yet.

331
00:27:39.060 --> 00:27:39.360
Thank you.

332
00:27:40.800 --> 00:27:44.220
james murez: Thank you everyone now let's move on with our agenda.

333
00:27:49.620 --> 00:27:52.830
james murez: Okay, a daffodil do you have something you want to say about motions.

334
00:27:53.610 --> 00:27:57.510
Daffodil Tyminski: We can wait on that i'll, this is a procedural issue, I can send an email on.

335
00:27:57.990 --> 00:27:59.400
james murez: Thank you let's say.

336
00:27:59.460 --> 00:28:00.960
robertthibodeau: I have a question on the agenda.

337
00:28:01.950 --> 00:28:05.730
james murez: i'm is it a is it about the.

338
00:28:05.970 --> 00:28:07.140
james murez: quickie report.

339
00:28:07.560 --> 00:28:07.860
james murez: know.

340
00:28:08.190 --> 00:28:12.960
james murez: Then let's repeat let's wait until after five be and we can get into it.

341
00:28:13.410 --> 00:28:14.640
robertthibodeau: hands going down then.

342
00:28:14.700 --> 00:28:19.170
james murez: Thank you i'm daffodil can you go ahead and promote lapd.

343
00:28:20.130 --> 00:28:21.990
Daffodil Tyminski: Sure um.

344
00:28:24.600 --> 00:28:26.850
Daffodil Tyminski: let's see I just saw you guys here hold on.

345
00:28:26.910 --> 00:28:28.320
james murez: yeah let's see maybe I can find.

346
00:28:28.590 --> 00:28:29.430
activision.

347
00:28:32.220 --> 00:28:35.940
Daffodil Tyminski: Pacific Ocean you're unmuted i'm promoting you as a panelist.

348
00:28:42.810 --> 00:28:43.380
Pacific Division: you hear me.

349
00:28:43.920 --> 00:28:44.190
Daffodil Tyminski: Yes.

350
00:28:44.340 --> 00:28:44.880
Daffodil Tyminski: We got you.

351
00:28:45.330 --> 00:28:46.890
Pacific Division: All right, good, would you like me to start.

352
00:28:47.280 --> 00:28:54.750
Pacific Division: Please okay hey just wanted to say, good evening to all members of the board and as well as the the viewing community at large.

353
00:28:55.020 --> 00:29:01.440
Pacific Division: Anyway, I know Dennis has had a lot of negative crime news from the last couple years so i'm very pleased tonight to be able to come here.

354
00:29:01.920 --> 00:29:16.470
Pacific Division: and give you some good news as far as the incident of crime, so as far as area why I want to give you some put in perspective, so we are going in the right direction, as far as incident crime, especially violent crime so area why.

355
00:29:17.580 --> 00:29:33.420
Pacific Division: Year to date for violent crimes were up 31% compared to the previous year we presently in the mid October sit at up 14.6% in the incidence of violent crime which is very significant so week after week.

356
00:29:34.770 --> 00:29:40.050
Pacific Division: We have experienced a great reduction, especially in also control versus area.

357
00:29:40.560 --> 00:29:51.870
Pacific Division: In the reduction of violent crime so i'm going to break it up into two areas of interests which are relevant to both of you to all of you, which is going to be oceanfront walk and secondly i'm going to talk about a pH, which is a different story.

358
00:29:52.590 --> 00:30:11.700
Pacific Division: So the Venice beach we utilize or we look at our August 7 as a transitional moment, because at that point that was when Venice beach was clearly reopens and we were also provided with overtime from our department to appropriately staff, the beach and the surrounding area Venice community.

359
00:30:12.840 --> 00:30:20.490
Pacific Division: So officers from other divisions, who were load from city wide from other divisions to supplement our deployment of the beach.

360
00:30:20.910 --> 00:30:26.640
Pacific Division: are going back to their home areas of assignment on October 24, so we are going to have a somewhat.

361
00:30:27.480 --> 00:30:40.410
Pacific Division: Reduced deployment and Venice beach as of October 24 However, thanks to the support of my bureau chief chief blake chow he committed to allowing us to retain the boxers from Hollywood wilshere.

362
00:30:41.130 --> 00:30:48.210
Pacific Division: West Los Angeles and Olympic areas so that impact is going to be not quite as big additionally.

363
00:30:48.750 --> 00:31:04.320
Pacific Division: We are we've been provided over time so four days a week i'm allowed to hire one sergeant and four officers, which I deploy on a foot beat four days a week, eight hours a day to maintain public safety and ocean from walk in it's and it's shown great results.

364
00:31:05.490 --> 00:31:17.220
Pacific Division: Additionally, we are monitoring the voyages cleanups we made some recommendations to wrap as far as the posting policy and you should see some changes of far as the oil just clean up starting next Friday.

365
00:31:18.090 --> 00:31:28.770
Pacific Division: And the evening cleanups which I have been asked questions about have stopped because sanitation, has a somewhat limited deployment, they are refocusing much of their efforts to doing.

366
00:31:29.460 --> 00:31:39.300
Pacific Division: Similar and chemists to homes at MacArthur park so they're putting all of the resources there and we're going to try to hold the line and Venice beach and ensure that's open open for public use.

367
00:31:39.540 --> 00:31:50.340
Pacific Division: So some of the mechanisms we use to monitor that is on a daily basis, I have our beach detail go to the ocean front walk they go all the way up to down ocean from walk and give me number one account tense.

368
00:31:50.670 --> 00:31:56.670
Pacific Division: Number to a kind of bulky items, even though we don't enforce bulky items, now we monitor that for situational awareness.

369
00:31:57.060 --> 00:32:06.960
Pacific Division: And the options go back and throughout the rest of your shift they go and address all of those locations conduct outreach they also meet with a personnel from the mayor's circle team, which is on a.

370
00:32:08.280 --> 00:32:12.960
Pacific Division: Which is on a pilot program in our area to engage with these persons experiencing homelessness.

371
00:32:14.640 --> 00:32:25.740
Pacific Division: So let me go over the crime stats for you and, as I said, we use August 7 as a transitional moment, so all of my recent reading estimates are updated from.

372
00:32:26.460 --> 00:32:39.570
Pacific Division: August 8 to the present day and previous similar time period before that and I compare what the crime impact is for the changes that occurred at ocean from walk so number one.

373
00:32:40.320 --> 00:32:59.010
Pacific Division: So 74 day period, including may 27 through August 7 versus August 8 through October 18 homicides are down 100% we had one homicide in the previous period, and the current career, we have zero rates are down 50%.

374
00:33:00.480 --> 00:33:09.120
Pacific Division: aggravated assaults are down 65% which is significant that's 37 aggravated assaults versus only 13 aggravated assaults at Venice beach.

375
00:33:09.570 --> 00:33:15.360
Pacific Division: The last 75 days, which is night and day I don't think we've seen those numbers for probably about four years in Venice.

376
00:33:16.110 --> 00:33:33.930
Pacific Division: robberies unfortunately are up by 11% nine verses 10 overall violent crime at Venice beach is down 51% which is significant you don't see those kind of those kind of drops we usually shoot for 3% crime reduction in this case significant 51%.

377
00:33:35.040 --> 00:33:38.370
Pacific Division: Transit related violent crime is down 56%.

378
00:33:40.590 --> 00:33:59.070
Pacific Division: Property crimes similar story burglaries break broke even further to motor vehicles down 33% steps down 32% overall property crime down 29% so i'm proud to say that cartland crimes at Venice beach or down 42%.

379
00:34:00.630 --> 00:34:10.500
Pacific Division: Okay, so we started or I have my personnel start tracking because we all suspected i've talked to some Members on the board and other other members of the committee.

380
00:34:10.920 --> 00:34:17.490
Pacific Division: That once Venice beach ocean front walk was cleared there, although 211 people were housed.

381
00:34:18.120 --> 00:34:26.670
Pacific Division: There were some persons in the population that did not want to be house and migrated eastward and ended up in the special forsman and cleaning zone, so we are.

382
00:34:26.940 --> 00:34:35.070
Pacific Division: You know we've communicated with St joseph's Center they believe the same thing that some follow on a chemist home effort needs to occur in a special enforcement cleanings, though.

383
00:34:35.910 --> 00:34:50.340
Pacific Division: So what we have done is since i've got this over time allocation every day i've been hired been able to hire two officers who have been assigned exclusively to this special forces and clean zone for eight hours a day additionally.

384
00:34:51.420 --> 00:35:01.440
Pacific Division: We want to thank CD 11 for returning to weekly comprehensive cleanups women, especially of course my cleaning zone, making a huge impact in that Community and we are dedicating our.

385
00:35:02.520 --> 00:35:12.540
Pacific Division: weekly contingent at one supervisor and four officers and I always want our senior lead officers, because they know your neighborhoods the best to be on those details and give them the property to be there.

386
00:35:13.320 --> 00:35:22.950
Pacific Division: So stats for the abh section and that's utilizing the same time period may 27 through August 7 compared to.

387
00:35:23.610 --> 00:35:34.050
Pacific Division: Similar timeframe August 8 through October 18 so we're going to 74 days, no change there are zero homicides in both time periods rates are down 100%.

388
00:35:34.650 --> 00:35:53.460
Pacific Division: aws are up 75% in the special form spring cleaning some numbers are not as big as oceanfront walk we're looking at eight verses 14 robberies are at 50% two verses three so overall violent crime in the special horseman cleaning zone is up 55%.

389
00:35:54.720 --> 00:35:57.810
Pacific Division: Transit related violent crime is up 33%.

390
00:35:58.890 --> 00:36:07.830
Pacific Division: So i'm glad to say that property crimes are still are somewhat down so burglaries and down 25% GTS are down 44%.

391
00:36:08.730 --> 00:36:25.020
Pacific Division: Via from these are down burglary that's burgers for motor vehicles are down 42% faster down 15% overall property crimes that 33% However, we are concerned about the increase in violent crime since people were relocated from ocean front walk.

392
00:36:27.900 --> 00:36:39.210
Pacific Division: Okay, and I will continue to support in overtime detail minimum eight hours a day of two additional officers and they will be tasked with conducting foot beats in multiple areas within that sexy.

393
00:36:39.630 --> 00:36:47.580
Pacific Division: Right now they're concentrating on third and rows and then and their support of sanitation his efforts within the special horseman Queens.

394
00:36:48.630 --> 00:36:55.800
Pacific Division: And finally, what I did want to mention is, I know the communities that we're that we are Pacific officers were involved in another officer involved shooting.

395
00:36:56.250 --> 00:37:02.880
Pacific Division: That occurred last Wednesday and I got the news when I was just about to step on a plane for Washington DC on October 13.

396
00:37:03.840 --> 00:37:16.170
Pacific Division: So, although we cannot discuss the circumstances of this category, the use of force a thorough investigation is being conducted that the department will release a video and discuss the preliminary findings of that investigation.

397
00:37:16.590 --> 00:37:27.570
Pacific Division: No later than 45 days from the incident and like I have done in the past and full transparency, I will notify the community wants that video is available online, so you can view it.

398
00:37:28.170 --> 00:37:36.180
Pacific Division: And if anybody has any questions or concerns related to that shooting please contact me directly i'm you know i'm always.

399
00:37:38.040 --> 00:37:44.730
Pacific Division: I believe in transparency with the Community and and will be able to discuss as much as I can.

400
00:37:45.960 --> 00:37:54.540
Pacific Division: With you I can't talk about the specific details, because this thorough investigation typically takes between six and eight months when we make our.

401
00:37:55.230 --> 00:38:07.800
Pacific Division: When our force investigation division completes the investigation makes a presentation to us and we make recommendations as to where the officers in policy and where their tactics sound.

402
00:38:12.600 --> 00:38:24.510
Pacific Division: Okay, so, although I can't talk about the circumstances of this one thing that I did want to mention was that the police department has no desire and should not be the primary.

403
00:38:25.560 --> 00:38:28.950
Pacific Division: response to mental illness, as a community, we are missing.

404
00:38:29.550 --> 00:38:36.690
Pacific Division: tremendous opportunities in interacting people were experiencing mental illness and providing them treatment before they get to this level of crisis.

405
00:38:37.110 --> 00:38:46.620
Pacific Division: And what I will, the only thing I will say it is that this shooting that occurred last week in my mind was preventable and we need to do better, as a community and addressing those concerns.

406
00:38:47.040 --> 00:38:56.370
Pacific Division: circumstances were very similar to the officer involved shooting that occurred, about two months ago, in which mental illness was a factor, and I think we as a Community.

407
00:38:56.790 --> 00:39:09.600
Pacific Division: missed several opportunities when they could have been entered when department mental health or other agencies could have intervened and prevented something like this happening so pending any questions from the board.

408
00:39:10.650 --> 00:39:11.910
Pacific Division: or also contrast.

409
00:39:11.940 --> 00:39:20.100
james murez: Though so did was was it was there, another this is James mirrors i'm president of the neighborhood Council normally we don't take questions on.

410
00:39:20.100 --> 00:39:23.400
james murez: presentations and yours was a presentation we don't want to open the floor for that.

411
00:39:24.480 --> 00:39:30.060
james murez: I just have one very quick question i'm going to break that rule I didn't get your name when we started your presentation.

412
00:39:31.590 --> 00:39:43.290
Pacific Division: Oh i'm sorry I apologize yeah so and I don't see us up on video either Captain Steve Eric on the area commanding officer Pacific area, and I am joined by your senior lead officer movie control this.

413
00:39:43.620 --> 00:39:48.000
james murez: And did she also want to give any sort of reporter, where we focused on.

414
00:39:51.750 --> 00:39:53.430
Pacific Division: I know she has she has good sir.

415
00:39:53.940 --> 00:39:59.190
james murez: Okay, and thank you very much for coming, and if the Board has questions.

416
00:39:59.700 --> 00:40:08.850
james murez: In the future let's let's send those in so we can get them to them by email ahead of the meeting, and they can respond to whatever kinds of Community questions we have.

417
00:40:09.390 --> 00:40:23.760
james murez: We don't want to do it open in the meeting during the meeting because it just it it ends up taking up a whole lot of time and it's not really efficient if anybody's they may not have the answers for us and all sorts of other issues, so thank you, having said that.

418
00:40:25.350 --> 00:40:26.910
jim robb: Thank you for your help on ocean front.

419
00:40:27.990 --> 00:40:28.410
Pacific Division: Okay.

420
00:40:30.570 --> 00:40:32.550
james murez: let's move on now you.

421
00:40:33.150 --> 00:40:39.420
Daffodil Tyminski: Do normally we'd go reading the government ports, but we also have led wp waiting on five see.

422
00:40:40.440 --> 00:40:42.060
Daffodil Tyminski: And it might be.

423
00:40:42.570 --> 00:40:43.620
james murez: Okay, we also.

424
00:40:44.220 --> 00:40:52.440
james murez: Turn ya know we can do that, we have a couple of government reports i'm going to be giving government reports for a few of them because they sent us information and couldn't make the meeting tonight.

425
00:40:52.650 --> 00:41:02.880
james murez: So why don't we go ahead and do that devil, I think that that would be a nice thing let's take five see out of order and and we'll come back to government reports in a minute government and committee reports in just one minute.

426
00:41:03.840 --> 00:41:06.180
james murez: Okay, you want to go ahead and figure out who to promote.

427
00:41:06.210 --> 00:41:09.090
Daffodil Tyminski: And yes, and I i'm trying to do it here.

428
00:41:09.150 --> 00:41:10.020
james murez: They may also have.

429
00:41:10.740 --> 00:41:15.570
james murez: Here, let me see if I can help, but I know.

430
00:41:15.810 --> 00:41:16.740
That works.

431
00:41:17.880 --> 00:41:18.780
james murez: So somebody here.

432
00:41:19.110 --> 00:41:21.720
Daffodil Tyminski: Yes, at your mercado and company.

433
00:41:26.070 --> 00:41:28.710
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Good afternoon to everybody can you guys hear me clearly.

434
00:41:29.010 --> 00:41:30.690
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Yes, awesome.

435
00:41:31.170 --> 00:41:34.110
james murez: I mean, if you want to share, if you want to share your screen, you know how to do that.

436
00:41:34.470 --> 00:41:35.190
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: I will.

437
00:41:36.540 --> 00:41:47.670
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: like to share that and I think share screen i'm going to keep it as a just a regular presentation, because sometimes he gives an error, so let me know if you can see it hopefully he's been enough.

438
00:41:48.570 --> 00:41:49.440
james murez: Yes, that's great.

439
00:41:49.890 --> 00:42:01.980
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: awesome alright well i'll just started I think Deborah Han from our Community affairs team is on the phone, so I would like to introduce her and she would be open to questions and I understand you may not.

440
00:42:02.070 --> 00:42:08.850
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: want to take them, but will be free, if needed, to stay behind we are more than welcome to stay behind and answer any questions.

441
00:42:09.540 --> 00:42:19.380
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: But without any further ado, my name is Edgar medical I am the Western district engineer responsible for all the area West or Western in South omaha and all the way to the beach areas.

442
00:42:19.980 --> 00:42:26.910
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: And i'm here to present to you guys are speedway or Christmas and ductile aren't water main or waterpipe replacement project.

443
00:42:30.330 --> 00:42:33.090
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: The project is looking in your or your phone and walk and.

444
00:42:34.500 --> 00:42:43.920
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Pacific, and this is the approximate location within city 11 now want to talk a little bit about the agenda what i'm going to cover, which is the history of this project.

445
00:42:44.340 --> 00:42:56.190
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Some of the scope of what we're going to be doing some scheduling facing so considerations that we're going to keep in mind as we interact with the Community and plan to be us this intrusive and.

446
00:42:57.210 --> 00:43:06.540
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: disruptive to your constituents and the Community overall and again we'll open up to any other kind of questions and answers.

447
00:43:08.340 --> 00:43:13.770
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: With that in mind, the project is limits are from.

448
00:43:16.830 --> 00:43:27.630
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: i'm sorry 17th avenue on the South to navy on the North, we are also doing a few of the side streets, not all of them some of the pipe is actually very new without.

449
00:43:28.920 --> 00:43:39.840
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Without leaks, so we taking it on based on the age, the leads and the reading level factor which we have a program that calculates the highly likelihood of failure.

450
00:43:40.800 --> 00:43:56.550
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Most of our pipes last between 100 to 120 years and knowing that most of the pipes in this area are already well over 100 years as you guys can see I put in the age of the of Mosul pies 1081 3122 and also the price that we're targeting and replacing.

451
00:43:59.280 --> 00:44:05.460
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Now, as I mentioned the prayer will be go actually all the way to burn are at the very end of speedway.

452
00:44:06.630 --> 00:44:15.090
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: The pro would also cover the streets, such as rose Dudley paloma and they're more like walkways then streets but they're considered street says destination by the city.

453
00:44:16.230 --> 00:44:19.830
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: We will replace a total of 10,500 linear feudal pipe.

454
00:44:21.150 --> 00:44:32.970
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: ranging have to six and eight inch with your materials, including cover cast iron and are resistant to iron pipe This project was actually selected about two years ago, three years ago to be.

455
00:44:33.780 --> 00:44:45.930
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Implementing the new earth resistant to arm pipe that has been used in Japan, for many, many years and we're trying to use it on areas that are subjected to liquefaction or earthquake so near earthquake zones.

456
00:44:47.460 --> 00:44:55.710
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: In this probably was selected for that pilot project, this is actually the very last of the projects that will be installing as part of the pilot project and we're now.

457
00:44:56.070 --> 00:45:05.790
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Moving to the face to where we're going to implement this type of pipe material throughout the city and will be issuing a contract, so it was pretty wide successful implementation.

458
00:45:08.160 --> 00:45:13.950
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: How do we plan to this project, and now that we're here hot what What have we done so over the last year.

459
00:45:14.340 --> 00:45:26.130
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: I actually have been meeting with the console office to notify them about this project, and we had several meetings with them to try to target and find out what are the main things that the Community will be impacted and how we can resolve them.

460
00:45:27.480 --> 00:45:30.900
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: And we also were asked by the consultant office.

461
00:45:32.370 --> 00:45:36.660
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Jove Thompson to look into partnering with other agencies to see, we can.

462
00:45:37.770 --> 00:45:47.130
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: do better for the Community in in doing so far, the part we met with the fire department, the fire department brought concerns as far as having accessibility to put out fires with.

463
00:45:47.610 --> 00:45:55.140
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: With lot of homeless and comments and having their hands go up and fire and they have requested to add an additional fire fire hydrants.

464
00:45:55.440 --> 00:46:05.130
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: For fire hydrants to the era that will be placed on ocean from was not on as you guys may be aware of all the fire hydrants are on speedway as our main line only.

465
00:46:05.970 --> 00:46:14.370
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: traverses speedway doesn't go into ocean from walk only a four locations and those are the four keys will fire department will like those fire hydrants.

466
00:46:15.090 --> 00:46:24.180
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: we're cleaning with the console office in the fire department to facilitate the cost for fire hydrants in the group he has volunteer ready to upgrade the pipe a no cost to add those.

467
00:46:25.650 --> 00:46:26.610
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Those fire hydrants.

468
00:46:27.840 --> 00:46:35.760
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: In addition, we also partner with the Bureau of engineering in relocating some of the fire hydrants there in the middle of some of the walkways or street meaning to ocean from walk.

469
00:46:36.090 --> 00:46:43.320
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: And we have redesigned some of the findings to be relocated out of the way of those ballers and and possible access for the fire department.

470
00:46:44.130 --> 00:47:01.620
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: i'm In addition we brought this project to bureau of street services and we try to plan it and coordinate D paving on speedway also have an understanding that may be paving on their five year plan, some of the other additional streets, the timing is not.

471
00:47:02.970 --> 00:47:09.390
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Specific to me and I don't control that plant, but I know that we are timeless so that we could come in first and they come in, after us.

472
00:47:10.020 --> 00:47:17.850
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: My understanding is they are within two fiscal years of our project and knowing that a project is approximately a year and a half long more or less.

473
00:47:18.360 --> 00:47:26.940
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: They will be kind of time, I would like to say perfectly, but hopefully right after us and that's some of the planning and coordination, we did with.

474
00:47:27.480 --> 00:47:41.460
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: With some of the other agencies in the console office so talking about the project, and this is different than what you guys may have seen, and this is a new news as of this morning we had a meeting with our construction Supervisor to discuss the phasing.

475
00:47:42.600 --> 00:47:46.200
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: In some of the flyers that you may have seen us of yesterday.

476
00:47:47.760 --> 00:47:59.340
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Put in the blue area as a phase one well, we recently discuss it with a superintendent would like to tackle phase one as they believe that may be able to expedite a move faster through those phases.

477
00:48:00.690 --> 00:48:08.550
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: They they are concerned, obviously with the walkway restrictions are being narrow and having accommodations from the console office and requested we add.

478
00:48:08.940 --> 00:48:17.700
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: You know about half a month, more to the timetable, so you might have seen previously as one year and three months, or when you're in two months I don't remember exactly.

479
00:48:18.420 --> 00:48:20.220
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: But that will be kind of the duration of that.

480
00:48:20.790 --> 00:48:28.410
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Our proposed construction work hours are eight to four but we're more than willing to partner with a Community if they will allow us to have extended hours to get out of the way.

481
00:48:28.800 --> 00:48:37.050
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: As soon as possible, which you know, will reduce the amount of time that were out there in any one of the given streets as a scenario and talking to.

482
00:48:37.470 --> 00:48:48.300
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: The event has been business improvement Eleni and in the console office, we had a very successful project with sunset Plaza which has one way in one way out.

483
00:48:48.900 --> 00:48:56.850
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: To me that's even more difficult, as does their only way to enter and the only way to exit the console office was very happy and supportive.

484
00:48:57.420 --> 00:49:01.860
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: We did something that we typically don't do we kept the console office Community grassroots.

485
00:49:02.610 --> 00:49:09.450
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: On a mailing list, where we met them every every other week of the status of our projects, so if we're doing construction that week and rose.

486
00:49:09.870 --> 00:49:21.270
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: And we're planning to be in two weeks and barely are melling to the to the email group will be the starting on two weeks from today Dolly will be in construction so make a wrench.

487
00:49:21.840 --> 00:49:29.460
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: arrangements to communicate with our superintendent and construction supervisor if there's any kind of accommodations that we might we might need to do.

488
00:49:30.000 --> 00:49:46.020
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: accommodations that we're looking forward to our maybe resins with disabilities, they may need to have access, especially going to and from doctor appointments in or deliveries of special specialized equipment let's just say you have a piano needs to use a crane and.

489
00:49:46.800 --> 00:49:48.510
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: You need to have access to it, and maybe.

490
00:49:48.570 --> 00:50:02.850
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: coordinate something like that, with us um any other kind of arrangement is we'll take it on consideration and we'll try to again be as is less disruptive as possible The other thing that was brought up by the console off is and the Venice beach improvement.

491
00:50:04.350 --> 00:50:17.160
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: district was work on Saturdays and summers, how do we address that in we pretty much told the told him that we will not work on Saturdays to disrupt any businesses or access to the beach.

492
00:50:18.060 --> 00:50:29.520
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Unless there's an emergency, as you guys know the puppies very old and I cannot promise that it will or will not break if he does break, we will need to be there, or whatever hours of the night evenings or weekends, or even holidays if needed.

493
00:50:30.600 --> 00:50:37.800
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: The other thing is, we cannot leave a place on safe, so if we are at 430 in the pipe breaks as we're trying to make a connection.

494
00:50:38.130 --> 00:50:46.710
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: We need to stay there until all the residents have water and remain with access to to the natural resource or very essential resource.

495
00:50:47.250 --> 00:50:57.210
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: So, again that's so some of the small caveat that I cannot promise you as as we deal with this pipe, as I said, it's very old and sometimes Friday when we make connections.

496
00:50:58.680 --> 00:51:00.090
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Close coordination will be.

497
00:51:01.440 --> 00:51:11.730
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Coordinated also for parking and I think I have let me move on my slides yep and it's like, for example, the roast parking the six or five speedway.

498
00:51:12.390 --> 00:51:19.710
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: blue sky parking Venice and 116 one parking has Those are some of the bigger parkin's where they have access to.

499
00:51:20.580 --> 00:51:32.490
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Nothing all the residents don't have essential needs to access in and out of their parking and driveways will try to have localized access and i'll go over this a couple of scenarios of traffic control plants and setups.

500
00:51:33.750 --> 00:51:37.830
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: And we'll do our best to allow ingress and egress to to those locations so.

501
00:51:38.340 --> 00:51:44.970
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: As an example, and I do have a full set of plans traffic control plans if you were approved by la do TV you guys would like to see him.

502
00:51:45.450 --> 00:51:59.640
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: But as an example which is nice little color coding if we are working on rose avenue in the zone that is red and typically we we Cone off about half of the block to allow access for our vehicles are back.

503
00:52:00.930 --> 00:52:10.050
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Excuse me i've been talking all day are back home in our and our workers to save to work in there, we will allow traffic to enter into.

504
00:52:11.580 --> 00:52:30.360
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: into the parking lot of rows and I were coming out do have to take speedway and we'll we'll have floggers and we we assess the traffic impacts as needed, we do have green Russian ship with led ot and maybe will deploy if needed within a week or so.

505
00:52:31.500 --> 00:52:49.320
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: To get them out of there and we're trying to coordinate that in events, just to have it as attempt to tentative options, if needed, to direct traffic typically their own flag traffic, the only direct that if is falling behind so, for example, if if there's a backup on on.

506
00:52:51.270 --> 00:52:59.490
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: On Pacific on two rows they made direct attracted to continue straight they don't they don't flag, this is just a misconception.

507
00:53:00.240 --> 00:53:09.390
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: How about when we're working on actually speedway and we're constructing across the way well here's One example will take half will take a block on speedway.

508
00:53:10.110 --> 00:53:18.180
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: For example, ozone two rows and will go up to approximately half of the street do a construction and then flip it on a later time.

509
00:53:18.570 --> 00:53:26.790
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: thereby allowing traffic with floggers to go in and out of the parking lot and when they get out continue through rose or exit and.

510
00:53:27.390 --> 00:53:34.290
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Through speedway going southbound arm and again we'll try to utilize the progress to safely died, they were the traffic.

511
00:53:35.220 --> 00:53:45.480
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Some of the other things that community's concern, obviously, especially dealing with tight areas like say the way we handle sunset is well, what about the biggest concerns emergency fire axes.

512
00:53:47.790 --> 00:53:50.430
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: lapd in emergency services.

513
00:53:52.080 --> 00:53:58.470
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: As I mentioned earlier, we are coordinating this project with the fire department they're well aware of it, but one of our protocols, as we.

514
00:53:58.890 --> 00:54:04.380
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: initiate our construction is to notify the local fire department of our presence and construction activities.

515
00:54:05.220 --> 00:54:08.280
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: We typically give them the phasing and we'll we'll let them know.

516
00:54:09.090 --> 00:54:20.850
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: same thing with the fire department to biggie i'm sorry the police department usually do a Community meeting like this there'll be also notify but we we send them a notification to be working on there and typically were there during the day.

517
00:54:22.140 --> 00:54:35.040
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: The emt sometimes were actually the first ones to know and as an example and sunset Plaza there was a fire in the nearby home and when we saw smoke we start plating and getting ready for the part of departments is shocked.

518
00:54:36.120 --> 00:54:37.590
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: If is something else, like.

519
00:54:38.700 --> 00:54:50.190
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: another type of emergency will be able to play with 10 minutes and have it ready, but like I said the beautiful thing about your area is you have access to multiple sites if we're blocking one block.

520
00:54:50.580 --> 00:55:06.030
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Half of the block should be open and be able to go around and, if need be, will stop everything we're doing to plate and accommodate the emergency axes when it comes down to mail and delivery of Amazon or any kind of ups deliveries.

521
00:55:07.140 --> 00:55:14.820
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: We typically again you guys have multiple ways of having them deliver the mail, my understanding is the mail comes in, typically in the afternoons.

522
00:55:15.210 --> 00:55:24.300
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: And so, as we coin it with the Postmaster usually to the console office they get a notification that we have work on side, and they are able to accommodate to either.

523
00:55:25.740 --> 00:55:32.760
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Come on the afternoon hours or in the very morning hours before we start construction same thing with trash pickups.

524
00:55:33.240 --> 00:55:43.170
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: They are usually notify and the trash will be either pick up in the morning or afternoon and either your story service your sanitation will notify you guys or just allows the time to coordinate that.

525
00:55:44.400 --> 00:55:55.560
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: I have received calls the my trash was not pick up we usually tend to Where would you guys contact the local supervisor for for the trash pickup and we'll remind them about the.

526
00:55:56.640 --> 00:55:58.830
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: about the missing trash pickup.

527
00:55:59.880 --> 00:56:00.480
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: um.

528
00:56:01.530 --> 00:56:09.840
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: One of the biggest thing obviously that I mentioned earlier, is a band notifications usually with projects, they are this disrupted and this large.

529
00:56:10.500 --> 00:56:20.130
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: I like I prison like to set up with my stuff more advanced warning notifications, not just give you one flyer that says i'm going to be working out here for a year.

530
00:56:20.580 --> 00:56:29.460
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: and good luck for your now what street i'm working on, but maybe on a bike weekly basis or monthly basis, depending on how how fast or slow we moved this this beach.

531
00:56:30.180 --> 00:56:40.800
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: areas are typically a challenge to to really identify how fast or how slow, we can move depending on traffic, the type of soil typically is very sending in the worst one is, what do you mean comfortable groundwater.

532
00:56:42.240 --> 00:56:54.450
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: So we have a rough idea of what it will take, but as we deal with those challenges will try to figure out how we're moving with our schedule and, obviously, last but not least is.

533
00:56:55.590 --> 00:56:59.940
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: partnering with the Community, you know we like to hear from you guys any kind of.

534
00:57:01.620 --> 00:57:11.430
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Any kind of needs for coordinating maybe even an event, and you know if there's there's some kind of event in the beach and we may need to point out for a date will be.

535
00:57:12.210 --> 00:57:21.210
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Highly considerable or i'm able to take in those items into consideration and, last but not least, this presentation will be sent to you guys.

536
00:57:22.170 --> 00:57:30.390
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: By Deborah on and like I said it was revised about five minutes ago, he has our contact information, I am in charge of the area.

537
00:57:30.810 --> 00:57:37.710
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Jana Chavez is my engineering charge of our mainline program and Oscar Rodriguez is our field engineer in charge of.

538
00:57:38.100 --> 00:57:46.950
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: overseeing the permit application, which we have the traffic control planet program and and ensuring that our staff has equipment materials on hand.

539
00:57:47.550 --> 00:58:03.960
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: The construction supervisor usually we we divulge that information on the notification that it gets passed to the residents on on a two week notice, as we may have that may be a high likelihood that you may be swap we're going through a a.

540
00:58:05.340 --> 00:58:08.280
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: A time where a lot of people are getting promoted transfer retiring that.

541
00:58:09.480 --> 00:58:14.280
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: i've been able to incomparably give you that information within the next two weeks, but I will also be.

542
00:58:14.670 --> 00:58:24.330
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: a pretty good resource to make those some kind of those kinds of arrangements and then you guys know Deborah Han our public relationship and Kareem mccargo who is our intergovernmental affairs.

543
00:58:24.720 --> 00:58:40.800
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: liaison with the console office, and with that pretty much my next light is questions if there's any or feel free to send me an email and i'll be reaching i'll be reaching to you guys in the shore matter um or shortly thereafter.

544
00:58:41.400 --> 00:58:48.480
james murez: Thank you Eckert because it's a presentation we're on a fairly tight schedule, tonight we have a lot of items on our agenda, why don't we.

545
00:58:49.350 --> 00:58:58.950
james murez: Have you take questions at some point in time in the future, perhaps by email and and would you be open to coming back if we had follow up questions at some point in time for a brief.

546
00:59:00.300 --> 00:59:06.000
james murez: brief questions and answers, perhaps in a committee, like in our ocean part walk committee where there you know people are very involved in that.

547
00:59:06.300 --> 00:59:14.940
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: So absolutely if you do have I heard you guys have different committees that deal with different items so i'll be more than happy to join you you guys just committee.

548
00:59:15.360 --> 00:59:24.210
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: And partner to keep you guys up to speed on what we are working on and how how to better partner again our biggest interest if we can partner with the Community to extend ours.

549
00:59:24.540 --> 00:59:37.440
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: We have a set hours on the permit, but like I said in sunset Plaza we met with the Community and we said, if you guys allow us to keep going and the console office in the Community is they agreed to extend hours, we were able to complete that project ahead of schedule.

550
00:59:37.800 --> 00:59:50.340
james murez: That sounds great alright, so we have several committees and what we'll do is we'll we'll hook them up with you, if you could send over your your PowerPoint to us, so we can have that posted along with our minutes of the meeting that would be great.

551
00:59:51.600 --> 00:59:54.210
jim robb: Can I tell him that my ocean frets on the next day.

552
00:59:54.660 --> 00:59:56.640
james murez: Jim we're not taking we're not taking questions.

553
00:59:56.640 --> 00:59:58.290
jim robb: Jeff was a question, I just wanted to see.

554
00:59:58.830 --> 01:00:00.840
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: him Jim cemetery the appointment.

555
01:00:01.230 --> 01:00:03.060
james murez: we're not going there Jim Thank you.

556
01:00:04.500 --> 01:00:09.150
james murez: I opened it up for you, I got open up for everybody, all right let's go back to thank you you're very much.

557
01:00:09.330 --> 01:00:10.650
LADWP - Edgar Mercado - Moderator: Welcome guys.

558
01:00:10.920 --> 01:00:11.910
Andrea Boccaletti: Thank you very much, sir.

559
01:00:13.170 --> 01:00:13.650
Andrea Boccaletti: i'm.

560
01:00:13.890 --> 01:00:14.340
james murez: Okay.

561
01:00:14.370 --> 01:00:19.740
james murez: Do we have a representative here tonight from councilman bonbons office.

562
01:00:20.970 --> 01:00:21.930
james murez: daffodil are you there.

563
01:00:22.590 --> 01:00:26.850
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm here, and I believe they emailed us just before the meeting, saying they would not be able.

564
01:00:26.850 --> 01:00:31.380
james murez: To correct actually let's see i'm sharing and I believe.

565
01:00:32.520 --> 01:00:33.660
james murez: Let me see where.

566
01:00:33.870 --> 01:00:36.120
Daffodil Tyminski: We can either share or read the email they sent.

567
01:00:36.210 --> 01:00:38.250
james murez: Oh, I have, I have several of this.

568
01:00:39.720 --> 01:00:44.790
melissadiner: i'm already emailed it to the board to and see if I can post it if you want to.

569
01:00:44.850 --> 01:00:49.890
james murez: Just yeah Thank you here's her report i'm not going to read it.

570
01:00:49.980 --> 01:00:51.630
james murez: i'm just going to quickly scroll through it.

571
01:00:51.660 --> 01:00:53.220
james murez: Anybody that wants to see it it's a.

572
01:00:54.480 --> 01:01:05.310
james murez: Is the time on the video, and there is her entire report it's also been posted to the dnc website under tonight's meeting as a supporting document it says CD 11.

573
01:01:06.750 --> 01:01:17.820
james murez: update the URL is up here so having gone through hers who's the next one on the list hed Lu that was another one did Ted lose opposite end up showing up.

574
01:01:18.990 --> 01:01:22.590
Daffodil Tyminski: um I do not see them on here okay.

575
01:01:22.650 --> 01:01:25.350
Daffodil Tyminski: So what else is here, raise your hand but I don't see.

576
01:01:25.710 --> 01:01:36.930
james murez: Your here was the the email I got this evening at that I guess about four o'clock from Ted lose office everybody's invited to meet with Congressman Lou on at this meeting.

577
01:01:37.620 --> 01:01:46.500
james murez: That will be a looks like a Facebook meeting if anybody wants to copies information again it's it at 659 on the video.

578
01:01:49.080 --> 01:01:58.260
james murez: that'll be available let's move on Senator Ben Alan I believe the first time in a long time, there is a person here.

579
01:01:58.830 --> 01:02:05.790
Daffodil Tyminski: So Senator Allen has a new representative it's RAD new ruthie and he is I think that's correct right.

580
01:02:06.000 --> 01:02:08.970
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah he is here, I will promote him yeah.

581
01:02:09.240 --> 01:02:09.990
james murez: yeah great.

582
01:02:15.480 --> 01:02:17.190
Daffodil Tyminski: In red, you should be okay to go.

583
01:02:21.840 --> 01:02:23.130
Rad Nowroozi: All right, hi everyone.

584
01:02:24.090 --> 01:02:25.290
james murez: hi good evening.

585
01:02:25.590 --> 01:02:27.870
Rad Nowroozi: Perfect all right yeah hi my name is RAD.

586
01:02:27.930 --> 01:02:31.320
Rad Nowroozi: I am the newest addition to Center been alan's team.

587
01:02:31.680 --> 01:02:41.610
Rad Nowroozi: I represent the West side region of La county of his district which, which includes a bunch of the upper coast, not including the south bay.

588
01:02:42.300 --> 01:02:50.250
Rad Nowroozi: So i'm happy to be here, I realized that lily is still part of the team and she's you know more than happy to help out.

589
01:02:50.670 --> 01:03:02.760
Rad Nowroozi: But we also have Davis Han so there's there's a few people few field REPS who are going to be working on Venice issues and representing all of you so i'm here, I thought I changed my name of my.

590
01:03:03.960 --> 01:03:10.140
Rad Nowroozi: i'm trying to that, right now, or maybe I can't I was going to put my email in my name, so you could easily.

591
01:03:10.410 --> 01:03:19.290
Rad Nowroozi: email me if you would like, but I don't have a report i'm just here to say hi and I was just listening to the meeting and i'm going to continue listening, just so I have an idea of who know who all.

592
01:03:19.650 --> 01:03:30.930
Rad Nowroozi: of you are and and and i'm looking forward to speaking to a lot of you in the future, so my email is ra di.so by my first name dot last name it's it's.

593
01:03:31.350 --> 01:03:41.490
Rad Nowroozi: You know rin on the screen at St n.ca dot govt so SEM for senate CA for California God and.

594
01:03:42.150 --> 01:03:52.260
Rad Nowroozi: I can you know I can share my email, I think, James has my email because we just corresponded and he'll be able to share my email with the rest of you in the near future, but i'm you know i'm happy to be here i'm.

595
01:03:52.710 --> 01:04:07.530
Rad Nowroozi: happy to be here as a resource, I know, James you asked for Center Allen to to join us in the future and I already sent that to our scheduler and we're going to make that happen, so thank you for that I guess yeah i'm just here to say hi and and and.

596
01:04:07.560 --> 01:04:08.700
Rad Nowroozi: Thank you for working with you.

597
01:04:09.000 --> 01:04:11.130
james murez: Thank you very much welcome to the Community.

598
01:04:12.210 --> 01:04:15.000
james murez: um let me go back to our agenda.

599
01:04:16.320 --> 01:04:18.390
james murez: yeah and who else do we have.

600
01:04:19.980 --> 01:04:21.810
james murez: Is anybody here from autumn burke's office.

601
01:04:23.340 --> 01:04:25.080
Daffodil Tyminski: I don't think so.

602
01:04:25.740 --> 01:04:28.320
Daffodil Tyminski: I think they also email, saying they weren't attending but if.

603
01:04:28.320 --> 01:04:29.910
Daffodil Tyminski: Someone is here, raise your hand.

604
01:04:30.090 --> 01:04:32.220
james murez: I didn't see that email, but it could have come in late.

605
01:04:33.960 --> 01:04:48.840
james murez: let's go to our supervisor and here was her report it has also been posted on the website for anybody that wants to see it i'm going to scroll through it slowly, so people can see it in the video.

606
01:04:50.910 --> 01:04:53.250
Daffodil Tyminski: And we're not expecting anyone from our office.

607
01:04:53.370 --> 01:04:57.480
james murez: No, not at all, he said he couldn't make in sent this over in place.

608
01:05:02.070 --> 01:05:03.720
And I believe that was the end of it.

609
01:05:06.240 --> 01:05:16.530
james murez: Okay let's go back to our agenda, who else did we have um anybody here from the mayor's office I don't believe we have anybody from the mayor's office.

610
01:05:16.800 --> 01:05:17.400
Daffodil Tyminski: We do not.

611
01:05:18.210 --> 01:05:19.650
james murez: Is Freddie here this evening.

612
01:05:20.100 --> 01:05:21.120
Daffodil Tyminski: fatty is not here.

613
01:05:21.780 --> 01:05:23.820
james murez: Okay um.

614
01:05:24.930 --> 01:05:30.360
james murez: Well, everybody saw that already I already mentioned that there's that able training that needs to be done.

615
01:05:31.740 --> 01:05:41.550
james murez: By side regional out loud Councils, so the regional alliance Councils is me and I have no particular presentation we have several rack items on the agenda and.

616
01:05:42.660 --> 01:05:45.960
james murez: I believe it was December.

617
01:05:48.810 --> 01:05:54.870
james murez: guess scone is coming to rack is has been scheduled, so if anybody's interested in hearing him speak.

618
01:05:55.320 --> 01:06:07.230
james murez: That would be an interesting meeting it usually falls on the Monday before the dnc board me I think it's the third Monday of the month i'm haven, is not here now let's go to committee reports.

619
01:06:09.330 --> 01:06:13.020
james murez: Andre do you have anything from the budget advocate I suspect not.

620
01:06:14.430 --> 01:06:15.540
Andrea Boccaletti: i'll save it for the report.

621
01:06:16.860 --> 01:06:19.920
james murez: Okay, see my you got two minutes go.

622
01:06:29.010 --> 01:06:30.090
james murez: see my are you with us.

623
01:06:32.490 --> 01:06:33.120
james murez: she's still here.

624
01:06:36.690 --> 01:06:37.680
Sima Kostovetsky: Can you hear me now.

625
01:06:37.740 --> 01:06:39.090
james murez: yeah now we can hear you Thank you.

626
01:06:40.290 --> 01:06:44.430
Sima Kostovetsky: Okay um TIM Would you mind coming back to me because I want to share my screen.

627
01:06:45.360 --> 01:06:45.810
james murez: Okay well.

628
01:06:45.930 --> 01:06:47.040
Sima Kostovetsky: That you went to community.

629
01:06:47.100 --> 01:06:47.580
Sima Kostovetsky: we're going to.

630
01:06:47.610 --> 01:06:55.560
james murez: Go back to you anybody can share their screen, just when you're ready to share to share it will stop my share i'm Isabelle we want to promote you.

631
01:06:57.480 --> 01:06:58.200
Daffodil Tyminski: can do that.

632
01:06:58.410 --> 01:07:06.000
james murez: Okay, thank you, while we're promoting her public safety, we don't have at this point, Jim rob why don't you give you a report you got two minutes.

633
01:07:09.660 --> 01:07:11.820
james murez: Jim do you have anything you want to report about oceanfront walk.

634
01:07:12.180 --> 01:07:26.550
jim robb: Yes, we're having a meeting on Monday, the 25th of this month, with all the scooter companies la do T is going to be bone in his office is going to be on the meeting we're going to discuss and they sent an email out.

635
01:07:27.750 --> 01:07:40.230
jim robb: Regarding regulating the scooters that are being rented on the boardwalk that go 40 to 60 miles an hour and Porsche theaters and six Cedars and everything else down there.

636
01:07:41.580 --> 01:07:54.000
jim robb: I don't know how we're going to enforce it, but basically the email, saying that the vendors have to release the scooter 500 feet from the boardwalk which would be almost two Pacific.

637
01:07:55.860 --> 01:08:05.070
jim robb: And so, basically we're reaching out, I have the Santa Monica transportation coordinator for their scooters is going to be on the call.

638
01:08:05.730 --> 01:08:15.930
jim robb: We have a new scooter company called Vo which you guys have probably seen they are technically not allowed in Venice at the moment they are going to be on the call.

639
01:08:16.950 --> 01:08:19.590
jim robb: la do T the pilot programs over.

640
01:08:20.910 --> 01:08:29.580
jim robb: Now we have two new scooter companies that are authorized basically they're only allowed 100 150 per scooter company.

641
01:08:31.080 --> 01:08:42.360
jim robb: Trying to coordinate with Robert thibodeau and any other committees that want to be involved because it's bigger than the ocean front walk where they're going, but the main problem is.

642
01:08:43.200 --> 01:08:53.070
jim robb: The bike path in ocean front walk with the unregulated and all of that so big meeting on Monday, hopefully, all the scooter companies are going to.

643
01:08:53.730 --> 01:09:14.010
jim robb: be there and I would like to get as many people also East Venice neighborhood committee is going to attend to talk about the scooters over in their area and that's our main meeting there's no motions on it it's just basically for the La do T and bonus office to talk to us.

644
01:09:14.280 --> 01:09:14.970
james murez: Thank you, Jim.

645
01:09:16.920 --> 01:09:18.300
james murez: Okay, Sam are you ready to go.

646
01:09:21.420 --> 01:09:24.810
james murez: Okay let's come back to see my arbor committee Isabel you ready to go.

647
01:09:25.440 --> 01:09:37.260
Isabelle Duvivier: hi I didn't expect to be promoted i'm so glad i'm not in my pajamas Thank you Jim for promoting me, my name is Isabel GVA i'm a longtime resident and business owner here in Venice.

648
01:09:37.770 --> 01:09:47.490
Isabelle Duvivier: i'm co Chair of the Venice arbor committee in the last two years we've planted over 250 trees in Venice and we do regular tree care in the community.

649
01:09:47.910 --> 01:10:00.420
Isabelle Duvivier: I have a few quick announcements to make in collaboration with our sister organization Vernon Venice, we are doing a tree bird walk on October 30 on the walk street south of poems.

650
01:10:00.780 --> 01:10:19.290
Isabelle Duvivier: We will be meeting at the supernova circle at 9am on Saturday October 30 at the last fancy meeting I requested help with our social media and i'm so happy to report that, thanks to the dnc we found a terrific person to help us, we now have a Facebook page and an instagram account.

651
01:10:20.520 --> 01:10:31.710
Isabelle Duvivier: or a presence and i'm here today to ask for a couple of volunteers, we need a writer we've been asked to do, several publications on our tree planting.

652
01:10:32.100 --> 01:10:40.770
Isabelle Duvivier: and on other tree related items, so if anybody in this zoom would like to volunteer for that that would be terrific.

653
01:10:41.280 --> 01:10:53.010
Isabelle Duvivier: we're also looking for someone to help us with a tree inventory to help us inventory trees that desperately need pruning in the last couple months we've seen some terrible pruning jobs.

654
01:10:53.700 --> 01:11:03.540
Isabelle Duvivier: The tire store on Lincoln boulevard to some destroyed their tree and a new business on Main Street it destroyed five of their beautiful trees.

655
01:11:04.200 --> 01:11:16.920
Isabelle Duvivier: So urban forestry at the street services has asked us to produce an inventory of trees that need pruning so we can avoid this tree abuse and, lastly, I want to mention that.

656
01:11:17.820 --> 01:11:34.530
Isabelle Duvivier: The Pan mar golf course running track is being redesigned by the city of La and it's a terrible design bb board member Barry campion will be presenting our design alternative.

657
01:11:35.610 --> 01:11:53.550
Isabelle Duvivier: For rose avenue at Edna on Thursday, you should come to that meeting to see her illustrative alternatives, I can be reached at 310-291-0871 or instagram is verdant Venice group, thank you.

658
01:11:54.150 --> 01:12:00.000
james murez: Thank you very good report as well appreciate it um okay outreach are you ready yes.

659
01:12:00.750 --> 01:12:02.100
james murez: yeah Thank you.

660
01:12:02.340 --> 01:12:03.150
james murez: share your screen.

661
01:12:05.040 --> 01:12:06.660
james murez: The first up short tried giving.

662
01:12:07.740 --> 01:12:08.580
Sima Kostovetsky: Thanks Jim.

663
01:12:08.700 --> 01:12:20.040
Sima Kostovetsky: Okay um when you figure out how to share my screen I don't know why it's not working for me today there with me i'm sorry guys, I thought I was more prepared.

664
01:12:20.610 --> 01:12:21.870
james murez: Here, why don't I.

665
01:12:22.350 --> 01:12:25.980
james murez: Do and you can start sharing when you're ready and you'll just capture the screen, when the time comes.

666
01:12:26.220 --> 01:12:29.070
james murez: parking and Robert are you have anything to share.

667
01:12:30.870 --> 01:12:33.540
robertthibodeau: Yes, not on the screen but.

668
01:12:34.860 --> 01:12:42.300
robertthibodeau: The la triathlon is coming this weekend so Sunday morning, there will be the La triathlon.

669
01:12:42.810 --> 01:12:55.620
robertthibodeau: That means that there will be street closures so yourself will be very difficult, you will likely, if you are living in the Marina strand, and you need to jump over to North Venice, you will be taking the 10 freeway.

670
01:12:57.660 --> 01:13:11.520
robertthibodeau: And the closures are I was originally told between six and 930 when I looked on the website, it was saying, between five and 930 so Pacific will be closed Lincoln will be closed anything north, south will be closed.

671
01:13:12.780 --> 01:13:14.850
robertthibodeau: The race will run from the beach.

672
01:13:15.930 --> 01:13:25.020
robertthibodeau: Where Venice boulevard parking lot hits the beach up East Venice only on East Venice, so you can still use selfishness or excuse me yeah.

673
01:13:26.940 --> 01:13:29.520
robertthibodeau: Whatever the other side of fantasies i'm.

674
01:13:31.320 --> 01:13:35.280
robertthibodeau: northbound minute said yes, so that doesn't make sense um.

675
01:13:37.020 --> 01:13:50.190
robertthibodeau: And so that's from five till 949 939 40 they said, and then also there could be some parking restriction, so if you mark on Venice boulevard on.

676
01:13:50.970 --> 01:14:04.350
robertthibodeau: i'm going to call it self dentists, they were calling each business could do you park on self Venice, you know you might want to check those signs on Saturday and make sure you don't get towed on Saturday night late Sunday morning really.

677
01:14:05.490 --> 01:14:10.290
robertthibodeau: And that's good for parking and transportation for this week, thank you all.

678
01:14:11.130 --> 01:14:17.730
Sima Kostovetsky: Thank you, Robert i'm i'm actually sharing the road closures per Robert report, can you guys see that.

679
01:14:17.820 --> 01:14:23.130
james murez: Yes, thank you, you want to go now and and give you a report we've already heard about the triathlon so you can.

680
01:14:23.220 --> 01:14:30.090
Sima Kostovetsky: write, so I will be posting the street closures on our website after tonight's meeting so that will be up.

681
01:14:31.290 --> 01:14:41.160
Sima Kostovetsky: So thank you, Robert for talking about this, we also posted about this in our e blast so here the street closers for the time being, so that is on Sunday.

682
01:14:41.610 --> 01:14:54.240
Sima Kostovetsky: I was actually told you guys because I spoke with the people directly, who are putting this on just to be safe it's closer to like 10 1030 but it's possible that the road closures can go on.

683
01:14:54.810 --> 01:15:04.860
Sima Kostovetsky: So, but it's mainly East heading out on Venice, so thank you for that, and the other big thing that's going on this weekend is afterburn.

684
01:15:06.330 --> 01:15:26.970
Sima Kostovetsky: And it they're back and it's actually a burning man event that is going on for two days in Venice this weekend at Windward Plaza so in terms of traffic and in terms of more people it is from noon to 10 both days so.

685
01:15:28.890 --> 01:15:39.390
Sima Kostovetsky: Just something to be aware of in terms of when we're Plaza I also wanted to post something up because it's important.

686
01:15:42.120 --> 01:15:43.830
Sima Kostovetsky: Let me go back.

687
01:15:53.910 --> 01:16:06.840
Sima Kostovetsky: My toes and it is put on by our very own Bruno Hernandez, it is a wonderful event taking place on the 31st we will be posting that as well.

688
01:16:07.650 --> 01:16:26.100
Sima Kostovetsky: Mike bonds offices participating, they are sponsoring it, as well as REX Venice beach recreation Center, it is an incredible event, you guys and we're so happy to be a part of it and we're so happy to be a part of bruno's vision, so I just wanted to put that out there.

689
01:16:27.210 --> 01:16:39.030
Sima Kostovetsky: So come come come there's stuff happening all over Venice you guys get involved, be a part of this and we'll talk about the Halloween party at the Pier when the motion comes up, so thank you.

690
01:16:41.340 --> 01:16:54.090
Sima Kostovetsky: i'm sorry one last thing sorry one last thing movies at the Pier this week starts at 7pm movies at the newly refurbished Venice Pier 7pm and this.

691
01:16:54.930 --> 01:17:10.650
Sima Kostovetsky: On Thursday, it is grief and they shot grease in Venice high school for those of you who didn't know that so it's free starts at seven it's a great event and just bring blankets and chairs and bring your family great sing along.

692
01:17:10.680 --> 01:17:11.010
james murez: Thank you.

693
01:17:11.820 --> 01:17:12.720
james murez: Thank you very much.

694
01:17:13.860 --> 01:17:17.400
james murez: Bruno arts Committee, you want to did she steal your thunder it's your turn.

695
01:17:22.320 --> 01:17:23.190
james murez: Bruno are you there.

696
01:17:26.070 --> 01:17:26.730
Sima Kostovetsky: I think I still.

697
01:17:27.090 --> 01:17:31.950
Daffodil Tyminski: hold on Bruno he keeps for some reason, and let me just allow we're going to talk cyber no I.

698
01:17:32.160 --> 01:17:33.840
Daffodil Tyminski: Keep promoting you and you keep getting.

699
01:17:39.570 --> 01:17:39.930
james murez: Okay, look.

700
01:17:40.440 --> 01:17:53.520
james murez: Let me come back to Bruno in a minute a leak, you had something that I forgot to put a couple of the other committees, the neighborhood committee is not listed here, nor is Luke pack leak, do you want to give a quick update on things that are going on and loop back.

701
01:17:56.370 --> 01:17:59.550
Alix: So i'm not me i'm muted sorry about that, let me start again, I just want to give a couple of.

702
01:17:59.550 --> 01:18:16.500
Alix: Things like greater land specially coming from a from Rack for those of you who aren't aware Council file 21 dash 1071 is the coastal equity and environmental justice file from Boston so.

703
01:18:17.580 --> 01:18:18.600
Alix: I urge everyone to to.

704
01:18:18.900 --> 01:18:24.000
james murez: Use pig leak, excuse me, are you going to bring up items that are going to come up on a future agenda.

705
01:18:25.410 --> 01:18:34.440
Alix: um no i'm just bringing up general I mean they could come up on a future agenda people want them to do but i'm sort of bringing sort of general counsel files and land use issues up.

706
01:18:35.670 --> 01:18:36.240
Alix: To.

707
01:18:36.480 --> 01:18:38.550
james murez: To okay i'm just concerned that if it's.

708
01:18:38.550 --> 01:18:46.890
james murez: an item that we may have to hear in the future, we have to be very sensitive about putting anything like that out there, without it being properly posted on the agenda.

709
01:18:48.360 --> 01:18:51.870
Alix: Okay well i'm not editorializing on this i'm just i'm just staying right.

710
01:18:53.190 --> 01:18:56.910
Alix: But i'm assuming that's okay i'm just listening to counsel files there's no.

711
01:18:57.720 --> 01:19:00.120
james murez: No comments on them sorry to interrupt go ahead, please.

712
01:19:00.540 --> 01:19:11.970
Alix: No all good and there's Council file C F 21 dash triple 02 dash 7174, which is about streamlined permitting or housing projects.

713
01:19:13.740 --> 01:19:35.340
Alix: addition additional files that are out there is Council file 14 dash 1635 dash as 10 which is delisting of non compliant properties use the short term Rentals Council file 21 dash oh eight nine o, which is an equitable infrastructure placement Council file 21 002 dash.

714
01:19:37.290 --> 01:19:41.160
Alix: legislation to achieve 100% zero emission vehicle.

715
01:19:42.600 --> 01:19:58.080
Alix: goal in California by 2030 cf 21 0928 water conservation for small businesses and see if 20 1095 vote climate change mitigation state funding for climate change initiative.

716
01:19:59.220 --> 01:20:11.880
Alix: and also to talk about sb nine and sb 10 past sb 10 has to be adopted by each city and is currently supposedly undergoing legal challenges.

717
01:20:12.960 --> 01:20:16.560
Alix: Housing element which some of you may or may not have heard about.

718
01:20:18.480 --> 01:20:32.850
Alix: The website for that if you're interested there can still be comments submitted and there's a three month grace period now it's planning la city.org backslash plans dash policies backslash housing dash element dash update.

719
01:20:33.870 --> 01:20:42.090
Alix: So that's that and what else can I tell you I think that's everything from land use for me.

720
01:20:42.990 --> 01:20:43.770
james murez: Okay, thank you.

721
01:20:44.460 --> 01:20:58.290
Alix: Sorry sorry Jim one more thing yeah also and neighborhood Council sustainability alliance ncs a la and I think i've sent out the resources document on sustainable.

722
01:20:59.040 --> 01:21:14.700
Alix: Guidelines for developers anyone that's interested in, you know moving towards more sustainable policies in Los Angeles, I urge you to take a look over there and to get involved, the document is a working document it's it's quite interesting and quite informative and that's me.

723
01:21:15.180 --> 01:21:25.920
james murez: Thank you in the future, if you could, I think it would make it easier for people to be able to see the links or the items that you're referring to as you give you a report on the screen as a screen share.

724
01:21:26.130 --> 01:21:26.910
james murez: And then we could also.

725
01:21:27.180 --> 01:21:29.490
james murez: Post it, I think that just be helpful for everybody.

726
01:21:29.640 --> 01:21:33.660
Alix: Jim i'll prepare that document that can go into the minutes or the agenda.

727
01:21:34.380 --> 01:21:38.460
james murez: yeah okay great we'll post it as a supplemental as a supporting document that'd be.

728
01:21:38.460 --> 01:21:39.180
Alix: Wonderful yeah.

729
01:21:39.420 --> 01:21:43.320
james murez: Thank you very much um arts Bruno are you online.

730
01:21:44.130 --> 01:21:48.990
Bruno Hernandez: yeah i'm actually online, but uh i'm actually at work, right now, so I just had my hand so so.

731
01:21:50.670 --> 01:21:58.230
Bruno Hernandez: I just did not really prepared to go through all that but uh but I will share something I guess i'll put something up on our website.

732
01:21:58.890 --> 01:22:07.950
Bruno Hernandez: The are the events that we're doing they're not necessarily it would be nc related crusade, and obviously you know we invited and.

733
01:22:08.460 --> 01:22:17.490
Bruno Hernandez: What we'd love to have you know you guys participate and everything like that or us participate, but um but they're just things that I guess we've been planning for a minute with with record park.

734
01:22:17.880 --> 01:22:28.410
Bruno Hernandez: As far as you know, just bringing Community free Community events to to the Venice Ottawa So if you kind of you know, if you want to keep up with the Venice our walls and we are scheduling an arts committee.

735
01:22:29.160 --> 01:22:39.510
Bruno Hernandez: Meeting to get I guess to just have more announcements we just been out so so far back that that we just haven't been able to to get our ducks in order, yet, but, but we will we will real soon it.

736
01:22:39.840 --> 01:22:49.560
Bruno Hernandez: Again, will be promoting and obviously everybody if the Community is invited to the free event it's a you know we have a pumpkin patch face painting free food free to.

737
01:22:51.000 --> 01:22:53.250
Bruno Hernandez: Just a bunch of cool stuff again for the Community.

738
01:22:53.700 --> 01:22:56.880
james murez: That sounds great Thank you Bruno and have a have a good evening there at work.

739
01:22:57.330 --> 01:22:58.920
Bruno Hernandez: yeah appreciate it Thank you yeah.

740
01:22:59.310 --> 01:23:09.210
james murez: Okay um let's see who do we oliver's not here so we're not doing rules and selections and I guess the last one, then, will be daffodil definitely do you want to give a neighborhood committee update.

741
01:23:10.230 --> 01:23:21.750
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah and two things one while we were going through government reports Freddie send an email to the board with freddie's update I see it's rather lengthy it's an email, I suggest we just post it.

742
01:23:22.230 --> 01:23:27.240
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay i'm in the Minutes, with the agenda and folks can go back and see it.

743
01:23:27.450 --> 01:23:33.960
james murez: Would you like to share the screen with that email, and then we just scroll through it, so that we would be included into the recorded video.

744
01:23:34.170 --> 01:23:37.950
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm sure hold on a second.

745
01:23:45.030 --> 01:23:47.370
Daffodil Tyminski: Just kind of make sure I got the right one here okay.

746
01:23:47.400 --> 01:23:48.000
james murez: Take your time.

747
01:23:56.370 --> 01:23:58.740
james murez: Do you have any kind of a report today on your committee Alec.

748
01:23:59.100 --> 01:24:08.640
Daffodil Tyminski: Just just very quickly before it goes The other thing with the board committee is we're going to i'm going to try to stick to the same schedule that the committee had before there's a lot of the same old committee members on it.

749
01:24:09.300 --> 01:24:12.930
Daffodil Tyminski: And I believe that's the last Thursday of the month in the morning.

750
01:24:13.980 --> 01:24:23.940
Daffodil Tyminski: i'll be reaching out to everyone to discuss what we're doing but we've got a couple of important projects coming up, particularly with respect to fema.

751
01:24:24.660 --> 01:24:36.420
Daffodil Tyminski: And the redistricting of much of Venice is a flood zone which will impact, how we ensure ourselves how we build and a lot going on in our Community, but can you see this email.

752
01:24:36.600 --> 01:24:41.010
james murez: No, not yet and and would use were you saying the last Thursday with that going to be this month.

753
01:24:41.490 --> 01:24:43.020
james murez: Yes, okay great Thank you.

754
01:24:43.950 --> 01:24:45.030
Daffodil Tyminski: And can you see this.

755
01:24:45.060 --> 01:24:47.430
james murez: yeah if you can enlarge it can you zoom in on.

756
01:24:47.520 --> 01:24:48.570
Daffodil Tyminski: That so saying is.

757
01:24:48.570 --> 01:24:50.940
Daffodil Tyminski: kind of a lengthy email try to.

758
01:24:52.230 --> 01:24:53.190
Daffodil Tyminski: And if you can like.

759
01:24:53.550 --> 01:24:55.380
james murez: Make it full screen, or is it full.

760
01:24:55.380 --> 01:24:57.270
Daffodil Tyminski: screen, this is full screen actually.

761
01:24:57.570 --> 01:24:58.080
james murez: Oh well.

762
01:24:58.200 --> 01:25:03.810
Daffodil Tyminski: he's a real small fine trust me i'm challenged myself, but I can I can lead you through it a little bit um.

763
01:25:03.840 --> 01:25:09.540
james murez: that's all right let's let's let's do this let's just post it on the dnc site and let it go with that.

764
01:25:09.840 --> 01:25:13.620
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay i'm scrolling through someone with a zoom can.

765
01:25:16.410 --> 01:25:19.800
Daffodil Tyminski: can see it, but I think we did touch on much of these topics.

766
01:25:20.190 --> 01:25:22.740
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay um when we were talking.

767
01:25:23.160 --> 01:25:24.690
james murez: All right, great Thank you bill.

768
01:25:24.870 --> 01:25:25.470
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you.

769
01:25:27.480 --> 01:25:33.690
james murez: um, so I think we've gotten through alley I didn't hear your answer, did you have anything on your committee that you wanted to report back.

770
01:25:33.900 --> 01:25:43.560
Alley Bean: Well, I could just report, so that people know I had been in touch with the principal at Venice high and several people that are going to speak.

771
01:25:44.430 --> 01:25:56.670
Alley Bean: The DEA and a couple of people who are who have who have knowledge of fentanyl awareness fentanyl related awareness other there's going to be several speakers.

772
01:25:57.660 --> 01:26:05.910
Alley Bean: It coming up in the future with teenagers at Venice i'm going to be talking to two other principles that we just haven't connected only by email so far.

773
01:26:06.720 --> 01:26:12.510
james murez: So that's where you are you planning, are you planning a meeting with with that you'll be posting for other people to attend anytime.

774
01:26:12.720 --> 01:26:17.970
Alley Bean: I absolutely Am I have board now to board so we're gonna have our first meeting.

775
01:26:18.120 --> 01:26:22.800
Alley Bean: But I just wanted to get all those ducks in a row, before I did all before I have made it committee meeting.

776
01:26:23.940 --> 01:26:24.540
Alley Bean: Sorry hey.

777
01:26:24.600 --> 01:26:35.820
james murez: Thank you very much okay um I think that concludes a vicki did you have anything you wanted to report you're not really a committee, but you certainly do a lot of work for us as communications officer.

778
01:26:40.170 --> 01:26:43.140
james murez: vicki have to unmute if you want to say something.

779
01:26:44.700 --> 01:26:45.510
Vicki Halliday: I have nothing.

780
01:26:48.480 --> 01:26:49.830
james murez: that's the best report of all.

781
01:26:51.390 --> 01:26:54.870
james murez: Okay let's keep going we're not doing too bad on time.

782
01:26:56.910 --> 01:27:05.550
james murez: We have a long agenda Okay, so we did the water Okay, so a treasurer's report i'm Andre you go ahead you've got the.

783
01:27:05.580 --> 01:27:09.930
Andrea Boccaletti: Florida again thank you i'm going to keep a really nice and short and sweet.

784
01:27:12.090 --> 01:27:14.400
Andrea Boccaletti: So let me share my screen.

785
01:27:16.050 --> 01:27:17.370
james murez: You want to you want me to bring it up.

786
01:27:18.210 --> 01:27:19.410
Andrea Boccaletti: i'm going to bring it up.

787
01:27:19.680 --> 01:27:20.040
Okay.

788
01:27:22.200 --> 01:27:22.860
Andrea Boccaletti: Okay.

789
01:27:29.850 --> 01:27:31.890
Andrea Boccaletti: you'll see that yep okay.

790
01:27:33.090 --> 01:27:34.860
Andrea Boccaletti: i'm sorry.

791
01:27:34.950 --> 01:27:36.420
james murez: We need a motion first.

792
01:27:37.710 --> 01:27:39.630
Andrea Boccaletti: Welcome, can I just talk about it first and then we can.

793
01:27:39.630 --> 01:27:42.240
james murez: know we talked we talked about it after we have a motion and a second.

794
01:27:42.390 --> 01:27:42.750
Daffodil Tyminski: So.

795
01:27:42.810 --> 01:27:45.420
Daffodil Tyminski: i'll make a motion to approve the monthly expenditure report.

796
01:27:47.550 --> 01:27:48.780
Andrea Boccaletti: Thank you very good.

797
01:27:48.930 --> 01:27:53.100
james murez: Now you can meet Now you can give your you can make your presentation.

798
01:27:54.180 --> 01:27:56.130
Andrea Boccaletti: Okay pretty straightforward here.

799
01:27:58.560 --> 01:28:05.520
Andrea Boccaletti: Still, because this was August we were still working out all the issues with the credit card and everything.

800
01:28:06.990 --> 01:28:17.580
Andrea Boccaletti: So there were a couple of things that were spent paid here just things that were administrative this far as constant contact with tent which handles all of our email.

801
01:28:21.150 --> 01:28:26.280
Andrea Boccaletti: The what else was some a couple of Facebook ads from the outreach committee.

802
01:28:27.300 --> 01:28:37.380
Andrea Boccaletti: And we have here if you see there's commitments of 1100 dollars and 80 cents, from the very top there before the net available.

803
01:28:38.160 --> 01:28:55.170
Andrea Boccaletti: Those are the are some outstanding bills, that we have from apple one which we are no longer using which I don't know the full scope of what it did it's all before I was elected treasurer So these are just some bills that were.

804
01:28:57.570 --> 01:29:05.940
Andrea Boccaletti: They weren't overlooked by the previous treasurer it just they weren't handled by the city when they should have been by check so.

805
01:29:06.630 --> 01:29:17.100
Andrea Boccaletti: There there's commitments i've now put in some orders for those checks to be written, we should be paid up we haven't incurred any late fees for from anybody so that's a good thing.

806
01:29:19.230 --> 01:29:19.800
Andrea Boccaletti: and

807
01:29:21.780 --> 01:29:22.950
Andrea Boccaletti: that's it there's any.

808
01:29:24.000 --> 01:29:24.690
Andrea Boccaletti: discussion.

809
01:29:25.800 --> 01:29:32.550
james murez: Okay, thank you um definitely do we have anybody in the community wants to make public comment on this.

810
01:29:32.670 --> 01:29:35.070
Daffodil Tyminski: I see no public comment on this.

811
01:29:35.700 --> 01:29:36.330
james murez: Okay.

812
01:29:36.990 --> 01:29:42.690
Daffodil Tyminski: So we're going to close public comment and go on to the board, and I see no board hands raised.

813
01:29:43.980 --> 01:29:46.920
james murez: Okay, then, Melissa let's take a boat.

814
01:30:01.020 --> 01:30:02.520
Daffodil Tyminski: And we'll see you have to unmute yourself.

815
01:30:20.220 --> 01:30:22.800
Daffodil Tyminski: I go ahead and call the vote without Melissa here.

816
01:30:25.050 --> 01:30:27.750
Andrea Boccaletti: If you want, I can call the book, then I can take the notes for.

817
01:30:28.110 --> 01:30:29.850
Daffodil Tyminski: Perfect well, thank you right.

818
01:30:31.230 --> 01:30:35.520
Andrea Boccaletti: Okay um Oh, you know what why don't you do it on sorry I don't have to list of everybody.

819
01:30:36.720 --> 01:30:40.260
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay i'll call myself what Jimmy is.

820
01:30:40.530 --> 01:30:40.980
james murez: Yes.

821
01:30:41.070 --> 01:30:41.520
Are you.

822
01:30:43.320 --> 01:30:45.960
Daffodil Tyminski: A daffodil sieminski will vote yes.

823
01:30:47.070 --> 01:30:48.810
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm Andrea.

824
01:30:49.320 --> 01:30:49.800
Yes.

825
01:30:52.260 --> 01:30:53.850
Daffodil Tyminski: Clark Brown.

826
01:30:54.120 --> 01:30:54.600
Yes.

827
01:30:57.210 --> 01:30:58.560
Daffodil Tyminski: ELISE bukowski.

828
01:30:58.800 --> 01:30:59.400
Yes.

829
01:31:04.110 --> 01:31:04.560
Yes.

830
01:31:07.950 --> 01:31:08.550
Yes.

831
01:31:11.670 --> 01:31:12.090
jim robb: Yes.

832
01:31:14.820 --> 01:31:15.330
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

833
01:31:17.760 --> 01:31:18.660
Daffodil Tyminski: vicki holiday.

834
01:31:18.990 --> 01:31:19.470
Yes.

835
01:31:22.290 --> 01:31:23.790
Daffodil Tyminski: Wait everyone's in.

836
01:31:27.120 --> 01:31:28.080
Daffodil Tyminski: Elizabeth clay.

837
01:31:29.280 --> 01:31:29.850
ElizabethClay: Yes.

838
01:31:33.630 --> 01:31:34.380
Daffodil Tyminski: Mike bravo.

839
01:31:35.190 --> 01:31:35.610
Yes.

840
01:31:38.280 --> 01:31:39.330
Daffodil Tyminski: NICO Berman.

841
01:31:41.250 --> 01:31:41.700
Nico Ruderman: Yes.

842
01:31:45.960 --> 01:31:46.500
robertthibodeau: Yes.

843
01:31:47.970 --> 01:31:49.080
Daffodil Tyminski: and see Mona.

844
01:31:51.030 --> 01:31:51.420
Sima Kostovetsky: yeah.

845
01:31:52.380 --> 01:31:57.570
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, so I got a text, by the way, in the middle of this that stay in the home and had to step out.

846
01:31:58.740 --> 01:32:00.360
Daffodil Tyminski: For looking neighborhood emergency.

847
01:32:01.410 --> 01:32:01.830
Alley Bean: And Dan.

848
01:32:02.490 --> 01:32:04.410
robertthibodeau: bruno's raising his hand, you might have missed him.

849
01:32:04.680 --> 01:32:09.690
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay yeah I will, for some reason I can't get them to a panelist i'm allie.

850
01:32:10.440 --> 01:32:10.920
Yes.

851
01:32:14.160 --> 01:32:16.110
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, most i'm going to mark absent.

852
01:32:18.180 --> 01:32:22.200
Daffodil Tyminski: And then Bruno you should be able to speak go ahead.

853
01:32:23.010 --> 01:32:23.340
yeah.

854
01:32:24.930 --> 01:32:25.410
Bruno Hernandez: Okay.

855
01:32:27.270 --> 01:32:30.390
Daffodil Tyminski: um if you are a palace and you've been missed raise your hand.

856
01:32:33.030 --> 01:32:33.990
Daffodil Tyminski: I think that's everyone.

857
01:32:35.610 --> 01:32:36.720
james murez: So does the motion carry.

858
01:32:37.200 --> 01:32:40.380
Daffodil Tyminski: The motion carries with everyone present voting yes.

859
01:32:40.770 --> 01:32:42.840
Andrea Boccaletti: Can you give me the vote count for that, please.

860
01:32:43.650 --> 01:32:52.320
234 517.

861
01:32:53.640 --> 01:32:54.120
Daffodil Tyminski: and

862
01:32:54.480 --> 01:32:56.010
Daffodil Tyminski: Zero and then.

863
01:32:57.030 --> 01:33:00.420
Daffodil Tyminski: Like I guess 17 00 which you members out to them.

864
01:33:00.840 --> 01:33:03.150
Andrea Boccaletti: Okay, who made the motion did you make the motion definitely.

865
01:33:03.240 --> 01:33:05.400
Daffodil Tyminski: I made the motion and I believe you second it yes.

866
01:33:05.430 --> 01:33:12.750
Andrea Boccaletti: Okay, all right, thank you and then just the last thing here i'll touch on is a stakeholder made a.

867
01:33:13.890 --> 01:33:18.450
Andrea Boccaletti: suggestion that we catch up and get better than going.

868
01:33:20.010 --> 01:33:20.430
Soledad Ursua: to war.

869
01:33:21.570 --> 01:33:22.860
Soledad Ursua: But I haven't done so because it's.

870
01:33:22.860 --> 01:33:24.450
james murez: not bad, can you me, a place.

871
01:33:28.260 --> 01:33:38.070
Andrea Boccaletti: That we we get more caught up on the monthly expenditure reports so we're looking into that just about maybe changing the date for the budget and Finance Committee.

872
01:33:38.640 --> 01:33:51.090
Andrea Boccaletti: Somehow that we'd still be able to get motions if we needed for them to get on to the outcome, so that they make it to the board agenda so we're going to work on that and hopefully we'll just be going one month back meetings.

873
01:33:51.120 --> 01:33:52.710
Andrea Boccaletti: So that okay thanks.

874
01:33:52.890 --> 01:33:57.690
james murez: yeah let's take that let's take that up in committee that sounds like a good idea let's move along.

875
01:33:58.950 --> 01:34:00.480
james murez: So now we're at.

876
01:34:02.130 --> 01:34:07.950
james murez: Item number seven announcements from the public on items, not on the agenda.

877
01:34:10.410 --> 01:34:13.020
james murez: The agenda so everybody gets a minute.

878
01:34:14.280 --> 01:34:18.480
james murez: And daffodil, how do you want to do this, you want to go through and call them one, at a time.

879
01:34:18.570 --> 01:34:19.620
Daffodil Tyminski: sure we have.

880
01:34:20.370 --> 01:34:21.660
james murez: Are you going to keep the time.

881
01:34:22.470 --> 01:34:25.950
Daffodil Tyminski: I will keep the time just give me one second sorry I was charging up here.

882
01:34:26.160 --> 01:34:27.720
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay um we have.

883
01:34:30.300 --> 01:34:33.060
Daffodil Tyminski: A six hands raised.

884
01:34:35.280 --> 01:34:49.680
Daffodil Tyminski: Nikita dal defend against a cello Helen fallon shauna Brian you'll want to consolidate Lisa redmen Lisa we will stop with you and close public comment after Lisa i'm Darrell why don't you go ahead, first, and here is the time.

885
01:34:51.450 --> 01:34:56.340
Darryl DuFay: Oh, thank you, I wanted to know what is the status of the neighborhood committee.

886
01:34:57.360 --> 01:35:09.750
Darryl DuFay: There is on the website, there are no names on anything, and I assume that in terms of chuck rosen that you were going to add, so the silver triangle to represent, where he lives.

887
01:35:12.360 --> 01:35:27.750
james murez: Okay, thank you Darrell will take that we don't respond to public comment, but we will take that into consideration and and I will just meant mentioned that daffodil did say that there would be a month, a meeting of the neighborhood Council last Thursday of this month.

888
01:35:28.830 --> 01:35:29.490
Darryl DuFay: Thank you.

889
01:35:29.730 --> 01:35:30.600
james murez: Thank you very much.

890
01:35:31.890 --> 01:35:33.870
Daffodil Tyminski: I Nick answer and show go ahead.

891
01:35:36.870 --> 01:35:43.650
Nick Antonicello: yeah, I just wanted to make a point that as we get closer to the deadline for the recall bonding campaign.

892
01:35:44.220 --> 01:35:51.810
Nick Antonicello: There are many of you who may not have signed the petition who support this effort and we're hopeful, we could use all hands on deck.

893
01:35:52.320 --> 01:36:01.680
Nick Antonicello: grab a clipboard and go out and get signatures if everyone on the neighborhood Council who supports this initiative went out and got signatures at the an extra thousand.

894
01:36:02.400 --> 01:36:12.210
Nick Antonicello: And we're very close this is going to happen, and I want to thank NICO is a member of the Vinci for leading us in this historic effort to get rid of my time, thank you.

895
01:36:13.590 --> 01:36:16.140
james murez: Thank you, Nick go ahead who's the next one.

896
01:36:16.410 --> 01:36:21.390
Daffodil Tyminski: Helen fallin go ahead hold on one guide you yeah.

897
01:36:22.140 --> 01:36:29.550
Helen Fallon: I just want to remind this or that the restrictions on public comment did not come to you as a recommendation from add con.

898
01:36:30.030 --> 01:36:37.770
Helen Fallon: And it really is for the board to decide, it should have gone through a committee, it should be decided by the board as Jim said, this is procedural.

899
01:36:37.980 --> 01:36:44.700
Helen Fallon: So it would require the adoption of a standing rule it's not just something that can be unilaterally and post and.

900
01:36:45.360 --> 01:36:55.800
Helen Fallon: I remind you, to that the purpose of the mcs so listen to the stakeholders lemonade community to less than 10 seconds per item that's exactly what's going to happen to get two minutes to.

901
01:36:56.130 --> 01:37:04.620
Helen Fallon: comment on the entire agenda or on several items on the agenda absolutely sends a message that you clearly don't care about hearing from the stakeholders.

902
01:37:05.130 --> 01:37:14.700
Helen Fallon: And our input is irrelevant if you're going to do this, I would suggest that you limit every board member to 10 second comments on agenda items and see how that works.

903
01:37:17.340 --> 01:37:18.990
Helen Fallon: So okay.

904
01:37:20.850 --> 01:37:21.240
Daffodil Tyminski: Sorry.

905
01:37:21.990 --> 01:37:22.830
james murez: I think she was done.

906
01:37:23.130 --> 01:37:26.730
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, thank you Sean o'brien go ahead.

907
01:37:28.200 --> 01:37:33.930
sean obrien: awesome yeah thanks so just wanted to remind everybody three weeks left to the MIC button and recall.

908
01:37:34.410 --> 01:37:46.920
sean obrien: I did want you guys to send the police report to Mike bonnen who claims that homelessness and crime of there's no data backing it up that an increase of homelessness increases crime.

909
01:37:47.880 --> 01:37:56.250
sean obrien: So please send that to him i'd love to see his face on that I remember venice's a containment zone of my biggest thing is monster in the median.

910
01:37:56.700 --> 01:38:17.640
sean obrien: of November 2 2pm please call 669 to 545252 meeting ID 1616446631 this is our last chance to reach the city and give our input on the monster on the median fight back bennett's need your help.

911
01:38:18.240 --> 01:38:34.200
sean obrien: You can go to fight back venice.org plenty of information they need donations, as well as recall bond, and they need donations so everybody use your stimulus money help these recalls help these lawsuits well let's take Venice back, thank you for your time everybody love you guys.

912
01:38:36.330 --> 01:38:36.930
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you.

913
01:38:39.690 --> 01:38:40.530
Daffodil Tyminski: The speaker.

914
01:38:40.710 --> 01:38:41.070
james murez: Know on.

915
01:38:41.100 --> 01:38:43.860
Daffodil Tyminski: Our next speaker Yolanda guide ELENA.

916
01:38:45.630 --> 01:38:46.710
Yolanda Gonzalez: hi can you hear me.

917
01:38:47.250 --> 01:38:47.550
james murez: Yes, I.

918
01:38:47.610 --> 01:38:49.650
Yolanda Gonzalez: Can okay um.

919
01:38:50.700 --> 01:39:01.410
Yolanda Gonzalez: i'm our fence was set on fire, last Thursday morning I live on the corner of Abbot kinney and Venice and.

920
01:39:02.130 --> 01:39:09.900
Yolanda Gonzalez: i'm very grateful that the fire department did get here, it could have set my husband's car on fire in the tree that's.

921
01:39:10.470 --> 01:39:24.600
Yolanda Gonzalez: got dead leaves right now, it could have just gone up tremendously, it was intentional, one of the cameras did catch a person coming into our property move my fence open the fence and the fire started.

922
01:39:25.680 --> 01:39:31.290
Yolanda Gonzalez: That last week, there were three fires here in Venice and i'm surprised the police department did not report this.

923
01:39:32.700 --> 01:39:41.550
Yolanda Gonzalez: And it's very scary that we have to live like this and be on the lookout it happened at four o'clock in the morning.

924
01:39:42.150 --> 01:40:01.650
Yolanda Gonzalez: So I just want to warn people out there, that there are some really nasty people out there, why they are doing this, I have no idea, but the arson unit did come to my home late that evening at eight o'clock and they were wonderful and they need help, there are only two.

925
01:40:02.880 --> 01:40:06.120
Daffodil Tyminski: Yolanda, we need to cut you off just because of the time, but thank you.

926
01:40:06.660 --> 01:40:08.340
Yolanda Gonzalez: Okay, thank you mm hmm.

927
01:40:09.450 --> 01:40:10.080
Daffodil Tyminski: um.

928
01:40:11.160 --> 01:40:13.350
Daffodil Tyminski: Lisa redmen go ahead.

929
01:40:15.480 --> 01:40:25.680
Lisa Redmond: hope I can go as long as Yolanda to um, thank you for starting it the meeting for indigenous peoples day wish you could have spelled that correctly, though in the agenda.

930
01:40:26.880 --> 01:40:36.930
Lisa Redmond: I am against this new public speaking Rule you are not the City Council, you are not the coastal Commission you are at the first line of.

931
01:40:38.910 --> 01:40:43.650
Lisa Redmond: participation of stakeholders and constituents and they need access.

932
01:40:44.220 --> 01:41:02.490
Lisa Redmond: Even City Council allows three minutes for people to speak up three individual items plus one minute for general public comment so four minutes at a city council, I also want to bring up that I know people are upset about homelessness and encampments but you need to maintain patience.

933
01:41:03.570 --> 01:41:11.400
Lisa Redmond: Many people are removing campaigns illegally by hiring people hiring private contractors private security firms to do that.

934
01:41:11.760 --> 01:41:20.250
Lisa Redmond: It is illegal to do that some people on this board have said that they don't know that that happens, it does happen.

935
01:41:21.000 --> 01:41:30.750
Lisa Redmond: So please don't remove people and then, finally, I want to bring up that one year ago, this month the Venice neighborhood Council voted 40 $500 for the final piece of.

936
01:41:31.680 --> 01:41:39.510
Lisa Redmond: The Frederick passageway to be finished it's still sitting one years later, and done so please spend your money responsibly, thank you.

937
01:41:39.720 --> 01:41:47.280
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you so much Lisa and we actually have one more comment that I missed earlier, and that is Robin murals Robin.

938
01:41:49.080 --> 01:41:49.590
Vicki Halliday: Go ahead.

939
01:41:51.900 --> 01:42:00.000
Robin Murez: hi good evening, so I just want to bring up that the prior board has a motion to have a Mexican American.

940
01:42:00.720 --> 01:42:12.450
Robin Murez: monument put in the middle of Windward circle to commemorate the Mexican Americans who had built the railroads in California and well that's like sounds really politically correct.

941
01:42:13.170 --> 01:42:17.670
Robin Murez: In reality, there were no railroads in the middle of Windward circle that was the lagoon.

942
01:42:18.120 --> 01:42:31.200
Robin Murez: And, but there was a railroad that still has a nationally registered historic bridge that crosses grand canal and is currently at the risk of being destroyed by the monster on the median.

943
01:42:31.590 --> 01:42:35.580
Robin Murez: And so I think that this is something that the Board should correct.

944
01:42:36.450 --> 01:42:44.580
Robin Murez: That a monument or that a plaque at least should be put on the bridge, which is the true location of a historic location for.

945
01:42:44.910 --> 01:42:55.290
Robin Murez: Recognizing Mexican Americans having built the railroad system and, at the same time we shouldn't be putting it in the middle of one word circle so let's do that correction, thank you.

946
01:42:55.950 --> 01:42:56.760
Daffodil Tyminski: So much.

947
01:42:57.300 --> 01:42:58.920
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you, closing public.

948
01:42:59.340 --> 01:43:01.890
james murez: Public comment you Thank you good to have it oh um.

949
01:43:02.970 --> 01:43:05.340
james murez: Okay let's get back to our.

950
01:43:06.360 --> 01:43:07.200
james murez: Agenda

951
01:43:10.980 --> 01:43:15.540
james murez: Where are we now i'm number eight general consent calendar.

952
01:43:16.980 --> 01:43:18.030
james murez: So.

953
01:43:19.590 --> 01:43:20.400
james murez: We have.

954
01:43:22.140 --> 01:43:22.470
james murez: eight.

955
01:43:22.530 --> 01:43:23.130
A.

956
01:43:24.510 --> 01:43:25.620
james murez: Eight be.

957
01:43:26.910 --> 01:43:28.110
james murez: Eight see.

958
01:43:31.560 --> 01:43:34.230
james murez: We have three items on the consent calendar.

959
01:43:35.490 --> 01:43:40.200
james murez: Do I have a motion to approve the general consent calendar.

960
01:43:40.380 --> 01:43:41.400
Alley Bean: i'll make a motion.

961
01:43:41.820 --> 01:43:42.090
Andrea Boccaletti: Who is.

962
01:43:42.870 --> 01:43:44.520
melissadiner: You don't need a motion Jim.

963
01:43:45.300 --> 01:43:50.280
melissadiner: If there's no one pulls it off, and nobody then it's unanimous done.

964
01:43:51.090 --> 01:43:55.410
james murez: Okay, well, I see no hands so it's unanimous and it's done.

965
01:43:56.280 --> 01:43:57.570
Daffodil Tyminski: Right, there are no hands.

966
01:43:57.750 --> 01:44:00.870
jim robb: Okay, everybody, I appreciate all those, thank you very much.

967
01:44:01.260 --> 01:44:02.370
james murez: Okay, thank you.

968
01:44:04.620 --> 01:44:07.080
james murez: yeah and let's move on now to.

969
01:44:08.520 --> 01:44:09.450
james murez: nine.

970
01:44:11.130 --> 01:44:16.140
james murez: I received a message earlier that there was one other item that might have belonged.

971
01:44:17.310 --> 01:44:19.410
james murez: I believe it was this CREST.

972
01:44:19.440 --> 01:44:20.850
Alix: More CREST more Jim.

973
01:44:21.450 --> 01:44:22.560
james murez: Yes, it's a.

974
01:44:22.620 --> 01:44:23.760
james murez: it's a four to vote.

975
01:44:24.990 --> 01:44:26.610
james murez: So we only put them on on.

976
01:44:27.330 --> 01:44:30.630
Alix: It was two people who were recused.

977
01:44:31.980 --> 01:44:32.370
Alix: So.

978
01:44:32.400 --> 01:44:34.710
james murez: The vote that was sent through was incorrect.

979
01:44:37.140 --> 01:44:38.610
james murez: It says here for two zero.

980
01:44:40.320 --> 01:44:47.610
james murez: So would have been poor 02 is that what you're saying you're yeah the minute The minutes of blue pack reflected support 02 or.

981
01:44:48.030 --> 01:44:51.600
Alix: 3040 let me double check them right now, Jim.

982
01:44:52.050 --> 01:44:53.940
james murez: Okay, why don't you double check that real quick.

983
01:44:54.360 --> 01:44:54.630
Alix: and

984
01:44:54.690 --> 01:44:59.460
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm not sure that it's a fortress zoo if there were accused of standing is different than recusal.

985
01:45:00.840 --> 01:45:05.940
james murez: yeah that's true they just been tried so it's actually five possibilities.

986
01:45:06.030 --> 01:45:10.440
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm not sure that they had a forum for that, but let's.

987
01:45:12.180 --> 01:45:14.520
james murez: Go you're right for wouldn't be corn for loop and.

988
01:45:14.520 --> 01:45:17.040
Alix: might have been extension, let me, let me check Jim.

989
01:45:17.220 --> 01:45:17.790
james murez: Thank you.

990
01:45:23.970 --> 01:45:28.020
Daffodil Tyminski: And we didn't go through nine so let's why don't we do the loop at consent calendar.

991
01:45:28.350 --> 01:45:31.710
james murez: Well, this is there, what we're doing is we're trying to decide if this is going on, we pack consent.

992
01:45:33.900 --> 01:45:34.380
Daffodil Tyminski: That yeah.

993
01:45:37.080 --> 01:45:45.870
james murez: We could we could do twice, we could do this twice does anybody want to take to 18 Main Street or 2321 Abba Kenny off of consent.

994
01:45:47.040 --> 01:45:50.940
Alix: Oh sorry, there were two notes, it was done correctly.

995
01:45:51.570 --> 01:45:53.040
james murez: Okay, so it stays where it is.

996
01:45:54.000 --> 01:46:02.160
james murez: hey so I see no hands to take nine eight or nine be off of the loop at consent, so those paths as well.

997
01:46:04.650 --> 01:46:09.540
james murez: we're now on to 10 707 CREST more.

998
01:46:10.680 --> 01:46:13.260
james murez: A leak, you want to make the motion and then do we have.

999
01:46:15.390 --> 01:46:18.690
james murez: The staff person here to make the presentation.

1000
01:46:20.670 --> 01:46:23.700
Daffodil Tyminski: I do not believe many she's here.

1001
01:46:26.940 --> 01:46:28.650
Daffodil Tyminski: ELISE can you present it.

1002
01:46:29.790 --> 01:46:35.520
Alix: um, yes, but that's not the correct motion that went on to my dnc minutes.

1003
01:46:36.450 --> 01:46:37.650
james murez: Then we have a problem.

1004
01:46:38.310 --> 01:46:51.270
Alix: The motion was the dnc recommends approval of the project is presented as a de minimis project with a letter issue to the city that this is a de minimis project, and now I know why this wasn't.

1005
01:46:52.320 --> 01:47:06.840
Alix: This wasn't a consent is because I said that it and, and I think marunouchi agreed that it was redundant having it having it stated as a de minimis project with the letter issue that it's a de minimis project as well too.

1006
01:47:07.170 --> 01:47:07.800
Alix: yeah so the way.

1007
01:47:08.160 --> 01:47:19.980
james murez: The way the motion is there reads correctly, it was reviewed by our parliamentarian and it says exactly the same thing we're sending a letter to the city saying it's a de minimis project.

1008
01:47:21.240 --> 01:47:37.680
Alix: Okay, so just so you know, Jim for clarity that's what what we wanted the original motion to be in in lupa and that was amended with the devil de minimis and that's why we did not support that motion myself.

1009
01:47:38.730 --> 01:47:44.970
Alix: But anyway, i'll read the motion the dnc she'll send a letter to the city approving this project is presented to be de minimis.

1010
01:47:45.840 --> 01:47:46.710
james murez: He made the motion.

1011
01:47:47.130 --> 01:47:50.040
james murez: So leaks, is making a week you're making the motion.

1012
01:47:53.880 --> 01:47:55.800
james murez: elite you're you're the maker of the motion.

1013
01:47:56.160 --> 01:47:57.360
Alix: I am the maker of motion.

1014
01:47:57.390 --> 01:47:58.530
robertthibodeau: thanks again.

1015
01:47:58.830 --> 01:48:00.420
robertthibodeau: Who was Robert.

1016
01:48:00.600 --> 01:48:04.500
james murez: Thank you, Robert now let's look to public comment do.

1017
01:48:04.500 --> 01:48:06.840
james murez: We have any public comment, we have at least one hand up.

1018
01:48:07.020 --> 01:48:12.570
Daffodil Tyminski: We do have public comment i'm Helen found anyone else wanna put their hand up here.

1019
01:48:14.580 --> 01:48:20.190
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay we'll take our and found an enclosed public comment up sorry we've got maybe just Helen Helen go ahead.

1020
01:48:21.450 --> 01:48:31.470
Helen Fallon: minus a point of information, I thought, if the committee sense of recommendation it goes to the board, as the committee voted on it, and then it can be amended at the board level.

1021
01:48:32.130 --> 01:48:40.500
Helen Fallon: it's a little troubling to hear that the parliamentarian rewrites motions seems to be what you're saying here that's not I don't think that's proper procedure oh.

1022
01:48:44.490 --> 01:48:45.180
Daffodil Tyminski: OK.

1023
01:48:45.270 --> 01:48:47.130
Daffodil Tyminski: We are closing public comment.

1024
01:48:47.370 --> 01:48:50.370
james murez: i'm suppose public comment does a committee have any.

1025
01:48:50.610 --> 01:48:51.870
james murez: comment yeah.

1026
01:48:57.270 --> 01:48:58.770
jim robb: glendale de minimis mean.

1027
01:48:59.250 --> 01:49:06.990
james murez: That means that we're not taking a position on it yay or nay we're just we're saying that we don't have any objections yeah.

1028
01:49:07.020 --> 01:49:07.470
jim robb: Thank you.

1029
01:49:07.500 --> 01:49:14.580
james murez: Well we're not we're not supporting it and we're not denying it it to us to us, it means that's what the meaning the meaning of de minimis is.

1030
01:49:15.150 --> 01:49:16.890
james murez: We were neutral on it.

1031
01:49:17.520 --> 01:49:18.450
Daffodil Tyminski: I didn't go.

1032
01:49:18.720 --> 01:49:21.390
Daffodil Tyminski: I think that's not exactly correct.

1033
01:49:21.660 --> 01:49:23.040
james murez: Okay, go ahead, what do you want.

1034
01:49:23.040 --> 01:49:26.940
Daffodil Tyminski: me de minimis means have minimal impact right, so I think it's.

1035
01:49:26.940 --> 01:49:29.310
Alix: A perfect thanks dad.

1036
01:49:29.640 --> 01:49:30.120
um.

1037
01:49:31.170 --> 01:49:32.340
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah it means.

1038
01:49:32.490 --> 01:49:38.970
Daffodil Tyminski: You know it's so minor that it's not something that we would pass on and typically in the land use context that's because it's within.

1039
01:49:40.320 --> 01:49:45.090
Daffodil Tyminski: The the the rules already prescribed fire land use plan and specific plan.

1040
01:49:45.360 --> 01:49:46.440
james murez: I stand corrected.

1041
01:49:47.220 --> 01:49:49.140
Alix: That is great yeah for correcting that.

1042
01:49:49.500 --> 01:49:50.100
james murez: Look let's.

1043
01:49:50.130 --> 01:49:51.510
james murez: let's take a vote on this.

1044
01:49:52.500 --> 01:49:53.100
Daffodil Tyminski: Yes, there's no.

1045
01:49:53.160 --> 01:49:53.550
Work on.

1046
01:49:55.170 --> 01:49:56.580
Daffodil Tyminski: Melissa Melissa are you back.

1047
01:49:58.410 --> 01:49:59.130
melissadiner: yeah i'm here.

1048
01:49:59.430 --> 01:50:03.840
james murez: Thank you, can you take a roll call vote, please item yeah Chen a.

1049
01:50:15.090 --> 01:50:18.150
Excuse me for one second.

1050
01:50:29.130 --> 01:50:30.510
melissadiner: Who is the second again.

1051
01:50:31.770 --> 01:50:32.430
Alley Bean: him rob.

1052
01:50:36.900 --> 01:50:37.650
melissadiner: Thanks.

1053
01:50:44.010 --> 01:50:49.020
melissadiner: Why it's not letting me alright well roll call vote is.

1054
01:50:52.290 --> 01:50:52.770
melissadiner: Jim.

1055
01:50:53.280 --> 01:50:54.660
melissadiner: Yes, Jaffa.

1056
01:50:55.080 --> 01:50:57.060
melissadiner: Yes, I have Oh yes, the leaks.

1057
01:50:59.820 --> 01:51:00.450
leaks.

1058
01:51:01.980 --> 01:51:03.000
Alix: Sorry, yes.

1059
01:51:03.120 --> 01:51:04.530
Vicki Halliday: vicki yes.

1060
01:51:04.740 --> 01:51:05.280
tema.

1061
01:51:06.510 --> 01:51:06.960
Sima Kostovetsky: yeah.

1062
01:51:07.140 --> 01:51:08.490
Alley Bean: holly yes.

1063
01:51:08.580 --> 01:51:11.220
melissadiner: hi yes Mike.

1064
01:51:11.730 --> 01:51:12.570
melissadiner: Yes, oh.

1065
01:51:14.040 --> 01:51:14.640
ElizabethClay: Yes.

1066
01:51:14.790 --> 01:51:15.360
melissadiner: Oh dad.

1067
01:51:15.600 --> 01:51:18.690
melissadiner: Yes, James rob NICO.

1068
01:51:21.840 --> 01:51:22.470
Nico Ruderman: So.

1069
01:51:22.650 --> 01:51:24.000
clark brown: Clark yes.

1070
01:51:24.120 --> 01:51:25.800
robertthibodeau: Our yes.

1071
01:51:25.890 --> 01:51:27.300
Bruno Hernandez: or no yes.

1072
01:51:28.680 --> 01:51:29.220
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes.

1073
01:51:29.340 --> 01:51:30.870
CJ Cole: cj yes.

1074
01:51:31.020 --> 01:51:34.410
melissadiner: Stan did anyone else show up that I missed Jason.

1075
01:51:34.530 --> 01:51:36.120
james murez: Yet Stan had to leave the meeting.

1076
01:51:36.900 --> 01:51:40.290
melissadiner: Okay, so got it thanks 18 00.

1077
01:51:41.310 --> 01:51:43.860
james murez: Thank you, moving right along.

1078
01:51:45.720 --> 01:51:53.850
james murez: we're now at a new business i'm Sema you want to make this motion, please.

1079
01:51:57.570 --> 01:51:58.260
Sima Kostovetsky: Thank you.

1080
01:52:00.330 --> 01:52:11.010
Sima Kostovetsky: The Venice neighborhood Council, led by the outreach committee will work in collaboration with the Department of recommend Park, to create the first annual Halloween party at the.

1081
01:52:11.040 --> 01:52:14.790
james murez: Venice you see here, excuse me, can you just read the motion.

1082
01:52:14.850 --> 01:52:15.900
Sima Kostovetsky: So we can get him reading.

1083
01:52:16.170 --> 01:52:18.120
james murez: The motion, no, no you're reading the description.

1084
01:52:18.570 --> 01:52:23.460
Sima Kostovetsky: Now i'm reading the motion five lines on page six bottom paid six.

1085
01:52:25.080 --> 01:52:26.220
james murez: Oh, excuse me you're right.

1086
01:52:27.300 --> 01:52:27.810
Sima Kostovetsky: Thank you.

1087
01:52:29.160 --> 01:52:39.510
Sima Kostovetsky: So first annual Halloween party at the Venice appear on October 31 from six to 9pm event will include a costume party contest.

1088
01:52:39.990 --> 01:52:51.180
Sima Kostovetsky: and be sponsored by the Washington square merchants, including arbor Fernando to Venezuela and others the event will be open to the general public and all ages are welcome.

1089
01:52:52.680 --> 01:52:54.720
james murez: And can we get a second, please.

1090
01:52:56.160 --> 01:52:56.700
Alley Bean: i'll second.

1091
01:52:56.760 --> 01:52:57.420
jim robb: One second it.

1092
01:52:58.500 --> 01:52:59.130
jim robb: Go alley.

1093
01:53:00.210 --> 01:53:01.320
james murez: Who was at the second.

1094
01:53:02.100 --> 01:53:03.900
james murez: alley Okay, thank you ellie.

1095
01:53:07.980 --> 01:53:13.980
james murez: um okay let's see if we have any public comment, it looks like there's one hand up.

1096
01:53:17.220 --> 01:53:18.120
Daffodil Tyminski: Go ahead Helen.

1097
01:53:21.900 --> 01:53:37.620
Helen Fallon: i'm rather confused by the language here, says the outreach committee is working with I don't know who the person rack the private restaurants, I don't know what it sounds like you're sponsoring this event, and if you are.

1098
01:53:39.780 --> 01:53:52.560
Helen Fallon: I thought you had a file paperwork, but there's all sorts of regulations that have to occur all I gotta say if you're going to vote to approve and I hope that all of you got your umbrella policies in order and they cover because.

1099
01:53:53.880 --> 01:53:57.570
Helen Fallon: Have you covered your soul to the liability of sponsoring an event without approval.

1100
01:53:58.860 --> 01:54:05.820
Helen Fallon: By the by the city clerk's office let's basic funding round one will take it so.

1101
01:54:07.950 --> 01:54:10.260
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you Helen Lisa go ahead.

1102
01:54:11.580 --> 01:54:13.290
Daffodil Tyminski: And then we're closing public comment, by the way.

1103
01:54:14.970 --> 01:54:28.770
Lisa Redmond: I feel like this is a little too much too late and be your two weeks out from Halloween and it even says that this was debated in the outreach committee in September, so why is this coming to the board just now.

1104
01:54:29.340 --> 01:54:47.220
Lisa Redmond: i'm or could have been thought of earlier plus didn't I see earlier that you're already sponsoring as a Venice neighborhood Council an event earlier in the day for Halloween so at the art walls and around Windward and then you're going to rush down to the Pier to do another thing.

1105
01:54:48.450 --> 01:54:53.070
Lisa Redmond: it's a good idea it's just it's way backwards and way too late.

1106
01:54:54.180 --> 01:54:55.590
Lisa Redmond: This motion should be for next year.

1107
01:54:57.180 --> 01:54:57.840
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you.

1108
01:54:59.010 --> 01:54:59.430
Daffodil Tyminski: Any.

1109
01:54:59.970 --> 01:55:00.570
Daffodil Tyminski: amount man.

1110
01:55:00.810 --> 01:55:01.920
james murez: My comment is closed.

1111
01:55:02.520 --> 01:55:05.310
james murez: Yes, i'm cj you have your hand up go ahead.

1112
01:55:06.630 --> 01:55:17.190
CJ Cole: Yes, um I kind of agree with Lisa um but I don't know what sponsorship means.

1113
01:55:17.700 --> 01:55:28.260
CJ Cole: I don't know if this is involving any financial aspect, if it is, it has not gone through the Budget Committee is not been approved anywhere that I know of.

1114
01:55:28.710 --> 01:55:43.680
CJ Cole: I agree that is just way too quick unless somebody just wants to put our name on something and still I don't even know if we're covered by the insurance by putting our name on so I just think it's awful quick.

1115
01:55:45.600 --> 01:55:46.770
james murez: Thank you um.

1116
01:55:48.630 --> 01:55:50.820
james murez: what's next Andre go ahead place.

1117
01:55:52.050 --> 01:55:58.260
Andrea Boccaletti: Basically I echo the same things that cj just said and I don't believe we're spending any money for this right, because no.

1118
01:55:59.430 --> 01:56:02.700
Andrea Boccaletti: requests have been made to the Budget Committee so thanks.

1119
01:56:03.660 --> 01:56:05.190
james murez: Thank you Mike go ahead.

1120
01:56:06.030 --> 01:56:14.520
Mike Bravo: yeah i'm just looked confused about the motion aspect of it, it sounds more like a like an announcement and emotion, but that's just me that's it.

1121
01:56:15.120 --> 01:56:16.410
james murez: Thank you elite go ahead.

1122
01:56:18.540 --> 01:56:30.930
Alix: um I agree with Mike and I just want to say the following that with with the pandemic and covered we've had no sort of dnc events or no real sort of Venice Community events for quite some time.

1123
01:56:31.410 --> 01:56:41.370
Alix: And it doesn't look like this is something we're sponsoring it just looks like we're working with the Department of REC and parks and it doesn't look like there's a financial output and I think this would be a great.

1124
01:56:41.640 --> 01:56:52.380
Alix: Community building event and, yes, sometimes we like to dot our i's and cross our t's, but I think that the in the interest of our Community, this would this would be a.

1125
01:56:52.920 --> 01:56:58.710
Alix: You know, a wonderful thing, and I, and I hope it happens, and this is surfer i'm super stoked the purists finally open so that's all.

1126
01:56:59.070 --> 01:57:00.180
Sima Kostovetsky: Thank you, thank you.

1127
01:57:00.480 --> 01:57:09.510
Alley Bean: Ali go ahead, please yeah I mean I think it's a great it to to I before it, I just I worry about liability, but that I leave that to lawyers.

1128
01:57:09.930 --> 01:57:21.690
Alley Bean: But just as a board I just don't know what our liability would be enough, there was a big accident or something or a coven thing you know, like all that code preparation and stuff so that would be my only question.

1129
01:57:21.990 --> 01:57:24.870
james murez: Thank you very much, definitely you have your hand up.

1130
01:57:25.500 --> 01:57:25.920
james murez: Now.

1131
01:57:26.370 --> 01:57:27.330
Daffodil Tyminski: Oh no I don't sorry.

1132
01:57:28.110 --> 01:57:28.980
james murez: Okay um.

1133
01:57:30.570 --> 01:57:32.700
james murez: see my did you want to answer any other questions.

1134
01:57:34.950 --> 01:57:41.910
Sima Kostovetsky: Now, I think the motion speaks for itself, and I agree with some of the comments from the board, thank you for the support this is needed and.

1135
01:57:44.340 --> 01:57:49.140
Sima Kostovetsky: let's get everyone together it's Halloween and the weather is going to turn bad and let's.

1136
01:57:50.970 --> 01:57:51.480
Sima Kostovetsky: Thank you.

1137
01:57:51.780 --> 01:57:55.980
james murez: yeah I will make a comment that i'll make the last comment, then we'll take a quick vote.

1138
01:57:57.150 --> 01:58:01.740
james murez: The outreach committee is working in collaboration with department of record parks we're helping to organize it.

1139
01:58:02.970 --> 01:58:06.840
james murez: The sponsorships are being made by the private businesses down in the area.

1140
01:58:07.260 --> 01:58:16.620
james murez: And, and so the liability of somebody having spent money, or whatever you know it's the liability issue is going to be between the Department of REC and parks i'm sure they're covered.

1141
01:58:17.070 --> 01:58:28.020
james murez: And, and any of the restaurants or other merchants that are participating I think it's a great opportunity to start what I hope becomes a big annual event for us every year.

1142
01:58:28.590 --> 01:58:36.210
james murez: This is a really positive thing it's a great place that people can make noise and have a good time out on the Pier and and enjoy costumes.

1143
01:58:37.890 --> 01:58:40.020
james murez: let's take a boat Melissa roll call, please.

1144
01:58:40.080 --> 01:58:50.940
melissadiner: Can I just say one clarification thing for people to it that I think is really important is that Sema and outreach can promote anything that's already a.

1145
01:58:51.810 --> 01:59:06.270
melissadiner: city county state federal event no she doesn't have to ask permission she can do that at any time and and does that's why you see a lot of the things from all the different departments, whether they're fun or not.

1146
01:59:06.690 --> 01:59:19.440
melissadiner: I believe this particular thing, just to clarify what she's asking for is to also just have our dnc logo on it and cross promote the dnc is really at the end of the day, that all you're voting for, so I hope you support it.

1147
01:59:20.250 --> 01:59:21.420
james murez: Thank you, Melissa um.

1148
01:59:21.510 --> 01:59:23.520
Sima Kostovetsky: let's take a look, and I just add one last thing real.

1149
01:59:23.520 --> 01:59:24.780
james murez: Quick oh we're done.

1150
01:59:27.270 --> 01:59:27.960
james murez: let's move on.

1151
01:59:30.180 --> 01:59:30.660
melissadiner: Jim.

1152
01:59:30.990 --> 01:59:32.310
melissadiner: Yes, staff at all.

1153
01:59:32.550 --> 01:59:35.010
melissadiner: Yes, I bought, yes, the leaks.

1154
01:59:35.070 --> 01:59:36.300
melissadiner: Yes, vicki.

1155
01:59:36.570 --> 01:59:37.740
melissadiner: Yes, tema.

1156
01:59:39.480 --> 01:59:41.220
Sima Kostovetsky: Let me think about it ya.

1157
01:59:41.820 --> 01:59:43.380
Alley Bean: Ali yes.

1158
01:59:43.440 --> 01:59:44.760
Chie Lunn: hi yes.

1159
01:59:44.880 --> 01:59:46.800
Mike Bravo: Mike bravo yes.

1160
01:59:47.310 --> 01:59:49.440
ElizabethClay: clay, yes, absolutely.

1161
01:59:50.700 --> 01:59:51.210
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

1162
01:59:51.480 --> 01:59:52.200
melissadiner: James job.

1163
01:59:53.040 --> 01:59:55.680
jim robb: i'm having a party at James beach chapter, and I say yes.

1164
01:59:56.130 --> 01:59:57.210
melissadiner: NICO Berman.

1165
01:59:58.440 --> 01:59:59.280
Nico Ruderman: Yes, I can't wait.

1166
01:59:59.640 --> 02:00:01.020
clark brown: Clark yes.

1167
02:00:02.400 --> 02:00:03.090
robertthibodeau: Yes.

1168
02:00:03.270 --> 02:00:03.690
melissadiner: or no.

1169
02:00:04.500 --> 02:00:04.740
Yes.

1170
02:00:06.300 --> 02:00:07.440
Andrea Boccaletti: No yes.

1171
02:00:08.490 --> 02:00:08.970
melissadiner: Yes.

1172
02:00:09.270 --> 02:00:10.710
melissadiner: Yes, thank you cj.

1173
02:00:11.040 --> 02:00:11.730
Yes.

1174
02:00:13.230 --> 02:00:13.620
melissadiner: Great.

1175
02:00:15.330 --> 02:00:18.660
Sima Kostovetsky: need help from you guys just a warning or Thank you.

1176
02:00:19.140 --> 02:00:20.640
james murez: Melissa what's the vote on that.

1177
02:00:21.300 --> 02:00:23.070
melissadiner: Unanimous 18 00.

1178
02:00:23.460 --> 02:00:26.010
james murez: Thank you, let me remind everybody there's not.

1179
02:00:26.010 --> 02:00:36.120
james murez: supposed to be any talking during votes so Jim, although I would, I will be happy to see you at James beach after the the event.

1180
02:00:36.720 --> 02:00:54.420
james murez: We can't make those kinds of comments during the middle of a boat that goes for everybody we're voting it's yes, no abstain, we got to keep going we got to keep it above board um next item is john read here I don't see him, he was going to be making this presentation.

1181
02:00:55.980 --> 02:00:56.310
james murez: um.

1182
02:00:56.460 --> 02:00:58.410
Daffodil Tyminski: I do not see him either.

1183
02:00:58.830 --> 02:01:03.210
james murez: let's come back to this one, I will text him quickly because he did say he was going to do it.

1184
02:01:03.210 --> 02:01:05.610
Alix: I can text him Jim while you're while you're doing it.

1185
02:01:05.670 --> 02:01:06.840
james murez: Okay, thank you ollie.

1186
02:01:06.900 --> 02:01:07.350
Alix: you're welcome.

1187
02:01:07.770 --> 02:01:08.370
um.

1188
02:01:10.860 --> 02:01:13.470
james murez: So the next is also a rack motion.

1189
02:01:15.600 --> 02:01:16.650
james murez: daffodil do you want to.

1190
02:01:18.330 --> 02:01:19.410
james murez: Go ahead and read this one.

1191
02:01:20.370 --> 02:01:29.010
Daffodil Tyminski: tour um this is on the empty camping ordinance regarding Council file 21 dash 0929.

1192
02:01:29.910 --> 02:01:36.510
Daffodil Tyminski: um the motion is the Venice neighborhood Council supports the proposed resolution for the city council.

1193
02:01:37.020 --> 02:01:53.040
Daffodil Tyminski: To prohibit sitting lying sleeping or storing using maintaining or placing personal property inner upon any street sidewalk or other public rights away within a radius of 500 feet from all schools listed in attachment a to the Council file.

1194
02:01:54.120 --> 02:02:03.390
Daffodil Tyminski: And further upon adoption or the resolution for the city council to direct the Department of Transportation to post signs giving notice of the restrictions in the radius specified.

1195
02:02:04.560 --> 02:02:20.340
Daffodil Tyminski: Venice neighborhood Council also request that the definition of radius be clarified to specify a radius of 500 feet from the exterior boundary lines of the schools, listen to attachment a to the Council file and then we have an attachment that represents the West side.

1196
02:02:22.380 --> 02:02:23.820
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you, I will make the motion.

1197
02:02:24.570 --> 02:02:25.920
james murez: You did make the motion.

1198
02:02:26.130 --> 02:02:27.750
Daffodil Tyminski: I will i'm making it yes.

1199
02:02:28.140 --> 02:02:28.950
Andrea Boccaletti: A little second to.

1200
02:02:29.400 --> 02:02:36.090
james murez: Thank you undress um OK now let's open this up for public comment, do we have any hands looks like we have two hands.

1201
02:02:37.800 --> 02:02:39.330
Daffodil Tyminski: three.

1202
02:02:40.020 --> 02:02:41.700
james murez: Three hands forehands.

1203
02:02:42.480 --> 02:02:45.330
Daffodil Tyminski: way Sean why don't you go first.

1204
02:02:45.450 --> 02:02:46.050
james murez: i've had.

1205
02:02:46.200 --> 02:02:47.670
Daffodil Tyminski: Let me see if I can.

1206
02:02:48.840 --> 02:02:49.800
Daffodil Tyminski: see why john.

1207
02:02:50.040 --> 02:02:51.330
Daffodil Tyminski: what's the time.

1208
02:02:51.900 --> 02:02:54.120
james murez: what's he doing let's ended after Yolanda.

1209
02:02:59.070 --> 02:02:59.760
james murez: whose first.

1210
02:03:01.710 --> 02:03:04.440
Daffodil Tyminski: letter let that shine his hand raise for shine go ahead.

1211
02:03:04.710 --> 02:03:13.230
sean obrien: Okay, thanks guys yeah i'll be i'll be brief, just support the motion of its weak, but you know every little baby steps you know every little bit, we can get.

1212
02:03:13.530 --> 02:03:23.370
sean obrien: You know, Venice is a containment zone um one thing I did want to say is like don't listen to the activists well you notice MacArthur park got cleaned up there was no news.

1213
02:03:23.820 --> 02:03:30.840
sean obrien: No news no problems, hardly any activity showed up they target Venice but That said, I support the motion thanks guys.

1214
02:03:32.400 --> 02:03:33.480
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks so much on.

1215
02:03:34.710 --> 02:03:38.460
Daffodil Tyminski: And okay Lisa why don't you go ahead.

1216
02:03:43.320 --> 02:03:43.800
Daffodil Tyminski: Lisa.

1217
02:03:44.640 --> 02:03:50.520
Lisa Redmond: I didn't know is unmuted hi I am against this motion, first of all i'm very much against.

1218
02:03:52.230 --> 02:03:54.960
Lisa Redmond: It will be found unconstitutional, as the last time.

1219
02:03:55.980 --> 02:04:06.960
Lisa Redmond: got past but it's i'm against it i'm against pretty much every rack motion to begin with it's wrong there is no we can't support this because there's no good.

1220
02:04:08.640 --> 02:04:16.110
Lisa Redmond: Housing plan in place for people to go, people are supposed to be offered housing before they can be found through city council.

1221
02:04:17.070 --> 02:04:27.120
Lisa Redmond: To get rid of these encampments but there's nothing in place so there's no housing to put people in, so I think it's wrong to start removing people.

1222
02:04:27.810 --> 02:04:43.530
Lisa Redmond: When there's no place for them to go all we're doing is just shuffling people around away from the services away from the outreach service people that know where they're at and are working to find them housing, so I know i'm speaking into avoid here, but please vote no.

1223
02:04:45.120 --> 02:04:50.910
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you Lisa i'm gonna say go ahead.

1224
02:04:52.920 --> 02:04:53.550
Darryl DuFay: Thank you.

1225
02:04:54.750 --> 02:05:14.370
Darryl DuFay: I am concerned about the description here, first of all, I support it because it's it's focusing on schools that it says listed in attachment a list of schools and then you also have a Venice site file to 5510.

1226
02:05:16.260 --> 02:05:24.930
Darryl DuFay: But the attachments and i'm reading doesn't have any public schools in it, it has private schools charter schools.

1227
02:05:25.380 --> 02:05:43.530
Darryl DuFay: child care, libraries and public parks missing our then inside scoop Mark Twain middle school walnut grove elementary broadway elementary Westminster avenue elementary currently an avenue and West side global awareness magnet.

1228
02:05:45.090 --> 02:06:04.620
Darryl DuFay: Maybe i'm reading something wrong or that the list that you put there to 5510 is not attachment a but I assume that that's what you're referring to, so there is a great missing of the public schools, if this has to do with schools.

1229
02:06:05.820 --> 02:06:06.750
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you Darrell.

1230
02:06:08.490 --> 02:06:12.660
Daffodil Tyminski: M and our last speaker Yolanda Gonzales go ahead Yolanda.

1231
02:06:13.920 --> 02:06:24.540
Yolanda Gonzalez: Yes, I am and supported this motion, most of you just stick to this side and we never seem to get anything done they're already doing it on the east side.

1232
02:06:25.230 --> 02:06:37.170
Yolanda Gonzalez: In Elsa no they removed encampments they house people, and not only that they have fenced the medium of Huntington avenue.

1233
02:06:38.070 --> 02:06:45.930
Yolanda Gonzalez: Because they were going in robbing getting into the supermarkets and just walking out with items.

1234
02:06:46.320 --> 02:06:55.890
Yolanda Gonzalez: I am very much in favor, we need to all work together to stop what is going on and make sure that City Council does the proper thing.

1235
02:06:56.190 --> 02:07:05.700
Yolanda Gonzalez: they're doing it somewhere else, like in MacArthur Park, as well as other parts of the city and we all need to work together, enough of this robbing enough of this attack.

1236
02:07:06.030 --> 02:07:15.300
Yolanda Gonzalez: My friends have been robbed from the chains off their neck, it is just getting so bad, because we have a mental issue, but these people are getting served.

1237
02:07:17.850 --> 02:07:18.480
Yolanda Gonzalez: Thanks great.

1238
02:07:18.570 --> 02:07:19.980
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you so much, Elena.

1239
02:07:20.760 --> 02:07:22.680
Daffodil Tyminski: And with that we'll close public comment and.

1240
02:07:22.680 --> 02:07:23.400
james murez: go to court.

1241
02:07:23.850 --> 02:07:25.980
james murez: Thank you definitely know i'm.

1242
02:07:27.690 --> 02:07:29.460
james murez: Clark, you have your hand up first.

1243
02:07:30.390 --> 02:07:36.780
clark brown: yeah I had a question and a comment, the question is why doesn't this motion also apply.

1244
02:07:37.530 --> 02:07:45.450
clark brown: To the thousand foot radius around your facilities that serve the homeless, like a bridge home, why is this only the 500 foot.

1245
02:07:45.990 --> 02:08:02.640
clark brown: radius that applies to school so that's a question I wanted to respond to a comment that Lisa made that housing is not available for these people that's not correct in a couple months ago the mayor's office filed in to touch Carter and case a.

1246
02:08:03.660 --> 02:08:08.790
clark brown: spreadsheet which listed 90 over 9600 beds that were available for the homeless.

1247
02:08:11.100 --> 02:08:11.790
james murez: Thank you Claire.

1248
02:08:12.870 --> 02:08:14.160
james murez: vicki go ahead, please.

1249
02:08:17.370 --> 02:08:32.880
Vicki Halliday: Have the first to answer Darrell question Darrell in the original motion for by rack and to the city um la USD did a blanket list of every one of their their schools.

1250
02:08:33.570 --> 02:08:46.620
Vicki Halliday: Ours was a supplemental list that we we compile to private schools and things that la USD did not cover i'm to clark's question um.

1251
02:08:47.640 --> 02:08:51.060
Vicki Halliday: No i'm just gonna leave it at that, I just wanted to answer Darrell question.

1252
02:08:51.270 --> 02:08:51.960
james murez: Thank you baby.

1253
02:08:52.650 --> 02:08:53.670
james murez: NICO go ahead, please.

1254
02:08:55.860 --> 02:09:00.390
Nico Ruderman: Sure, I guess i'd like to start off asking you vicki so just to clarify.

1255
02:09:02.520 --> 02:09:05.880
Nico Ruderman: public schools are already covered, but by this was just like a supplements.

1256
02:09:06.330 --> 02:09:06.780
Vicki Halliday: This was.

1257
02:09:07.950 --> 02:09:12.360
Vicki Halliday: All schools recovered because la USD had already done there.

1258
02:09:13.890 --> 02:09:20.340
Vicki Halliday: And so we had to do the supplemental buy a dress because it wasn't covered in the La USD list.

1259
02:09:22.170 --> 02:09:24.000
Vicki Halliday: So that the attachment.

1260
02:09:25.260 --> 02:09:26.040
james murez: Is it is it.

1261
02:09:26.070 --> 02:09:27.840
james murez: Great well, thank you for clarifying.

1262
02:09:29.100 --> 02:09:36.900
Nico Ruderman: yeah no I mean that I had that question for my comments, because my comment was going to vary, based on the answer to that, so I feel that all school should be covered.

1263
02:09:36.990 --> 02:09:46.830
Nico Ruderman: yeah and it, you know, this is something that's very important to me, I think that's um you know I wish I went further to actually cover core doors to schools.

1264
02:09:47.310 --> 02:09:56.820
Nico Ruderman: So kids actually had safe passage to schools, not just not just a safe boundary around them, but I think this is a I think this is a good start, and I strongly strongly support this.

1265
02:09:57.720 --> 02:09:58.470
james murez: Thank you, Nicole.

1266
02:09:59.820 --> 02:10:00.660
james murez: Andre please.

1267
02:10:02.730 --> 02:10:11.340
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes, I mean I I believe it's time to start enforcing the laws, I mean I I also know, I thought the law meant that she couldn't.

1268
02:10:13.020 --> 02:10:23.550
Andrea Boccaletti: block any sideways anywhere in the city so i'm hope everyone will vote yes for this and it's time to really start enforcing these laws, and one thing I can understand is if the military can.

1269
02:10:24.270 --> 02:10:38.730
Andrea Boccaletti: build the base out in the middle of nowhere in the course of you know, a week or two weeks for all of our troops that can we can't do the same thing for the homeless, instead of proposing these mega hundred and $30 million shelters, right here in our neighborhood enough's enough.

1270
02:10:39.330 --> 02:10:45.540
james murez: Thank you Clark you put your hand back up a second time, do you want to speak, one more time we don't usually do that but, but do you have something.

1271
02:10:47.550 --> 02:11:01.110
clark brown: Right now there's an rv that has been parked for some time, behind the Westminster elementary school on on Main Street and it's created real problems for everybody who participates in that school, to the extent, where the school had to erect.

1272
02:11:01.950 --> 02:11:13.410
clark brown: blinds across it's it's fence, so the people from the rv couldn't look into the school and create problems, so this is something I think that's very necessary.

1273
02:11:14.040 --> 02:11:14.790
james murez: Thank you Clark.

1274
02:11:15.210 --> 02:11:19.620
james murez: Okay i'm Melissa I don't see more hands let's take a boat.

1275
02:11:24.300 --> 02:11:24.840
james murez: Yes.

1276
02:11:25.020 --> 02:11:27.990
melissadiner: daffodil yes, I vote yes, the leaks.

1277
02:11:29.160 --> 02:11:30.000
Alix: Yes.

1278
02:11:30.060 --> 02:11:31.380
Vicki Halliday: vicki yes.

1279
02:11:31.410 --> 02:11:32.010
Vima.

1280
02:11:33.750 --> 02:11:34.050
Sima Kostovetsky: ya.

1281
02:11:34.380 --> 02:11:35.880
Alley Bean: Ali yes.

1282
02:11:36.030 --> 02:11:39.210
Mike Bravo: hi yes, I know.

1283
02:11:41.370 --> 02:11:42.240
melissadiner: Moses play.

1284
02:11:42.960 --> 02:11:43.590
Yes.

1285
02:11:44.760 --> 02:11:45.450
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

1286
02:11:46.290 --> 02:11:47.190
James rob.

1287
02:11:55.410 --> 02:11:55.890
melissadiner: Clark.

1288
02:11:56.220 --> 02:11:58.500
robertthibodeau: Yes, yes.

1289
02:11:58.620 --> 02:11:59.190
melissadiner: or no.

1290
02:12:01.560 --> 02:12:02.220
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes.

1291
02:12:02.400 --> 02:12:05.220
CJ Cole: And cj yes okay.

1292
02:12:05.250 --> 02:12:07.440
melissadiner: So it's 17 01.

1293
02:12:10.650 --> 02:12:16.770
james murez: Okay um, we have to take a 10 second interruption a leak, do you want me to present this next item.

1294
02:12:18.330 --> 02:12:19.170
Alix: here for Jim.

1295
02:12:19.800 --> 02:12:23.610
james murez: Okay, so devil, I have to pass you the gavel.

1296
02:12:24.840 --> 02:12:26.730
james murez: For the item.

1297
02:12:27.960 --> 02:12:31.230
1212 be.

1298
02:12:33.210 --> 02:12:33.720
james murez: Okay.

1299
02:12:35.790 --> 02:12:36.330
Daffodil Tyminski: Yes.

1300
02:12:36.570 --> 02:12:43.680
james murez: yeah i'm gonna i'm going to be making this motion of the motion, the westside regional alliance of Councils request the city of.

1301
02:12:44.130 --> 02:13:01.800
james murez: The city council direct city attorney Mike you're to provide a legal opinion as to whether or not city planning department and commissions have the legal right under state and city laws and ordinances to consider the financial interest of the developer.

1302
02:13:01.950 --> 02:13:04.800
james murez: When considering entitlements.

1303
02:13:05.250 --> 02:13:07.410
Alix: i'm setting that Jim it's a lakes.

1304
02:13:07.950 --> 02:13:09.570
james murez: it's not Jim you got to talk to death.

1305
02:13:09.960 --> 02:13:11.040
Alix: Death i'm second thing.

1306
02:13:13.050 --> 02:13:21.210
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay um so let's go to public comment first, if you have public comment, please put raise your hand now.

1307
02:13:23.760 --> 02:13:27.330
Daffodil Tyminski: It should bump you up you see how and Lisa anybody else Yolanda.

1308
02:13:30.180 --> 02:13:35.430
Daffodil Tyminski: anyone else alright so we're gonna close Yolanda want to start talking will close the shona.

1309
02:13:35.430 --> 02:13:37.500
Daffodil Tyminski: Brian go ahead Yolanda.

1310
02:13:39.240 --> 02:13:45.420
Yolanda Gonzalez: Yes, I would like a better explanation on this, we are in a drought.

1311
02:13:46.560 --> 02:13:49.050
Yolanda Gonzalez: We are being restricted already water.

1312
02:13:50.100 --> 02:13:53.370
Yolanda Gonzalez: In other cities, they are restricting the usage of water.

1313
02:13:54.870 --> 02:13:58.830
Yolanda Gonzalez: I want to know how's the city going to execute.

1314
02:14:00.150 --> 02:14:15.360
Yolanda Gonzalez: The fact that we're building, but there is no concentration on how much water are we going to be receiving or are we going to be the ones that are be going to cut off water, we already have a mandate on flood insurance i'm waiting for the flood to come through.

1315
02:14:16.590 --> 02:14:24.630
Yolanda Gonzalez: I just want an explanation of how is this going to take place, how the city is going to accomplish this Thank you.

1316
02:14:25.290 --> 02:14:26.160
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Yolanda.

1317
02:14:27.990 --> 02:14:30.630
Daffodil Tyminski: And Helen why don't you go next.

1318
02:14:33.690 --> 02:14:42.990
Helen Fallon: um I just would like to point out that all this is asking the city attorney to provide a legal opinion so I don't think it has to be a whole lot of debate.

1319
02:14:43.530 --> 02:14:51.150
Helen Fallon: acid is concerned about this what's your from the city attorney and goes legal opinion because apparently he's an assignment on this issue.

1320
02:14:54.180 --> 02:14:54.510
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you.

1321
02:14:59.700 --> 02:15:00.930
Daffodil Tyminski: Lisa redmond go ahead.

1322
02:15:03.720 --> 02:15:08.490
Lisa Redmond: i'm against this motion it's a rack motion i'm also against it because of who else has passed it.

1323
02:15:08.850 --> 02:15:14.400
Lisa Redmond: Well, I know it's not a good thing if the city attorney wanted to make a.

1324
02:15:15.420 --> 02:15:18.300
Lisa Redmond: Recommendation he or maybe she.

1325
02:15:20.580 --> 02:15:22.080
Lisa Redmond: In the future, would do the soap.

1326
02:15:23.670 --> 02:15:27.840
Lisa Redmond: And, as it stands now, no i'm against it, so please vote no.

1327
02:15:29.250 --> 02:15:30.000
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Lisa.

1328
02:15:31.470 --> 02:15:37.830
Daffodil Tyminski: And our last speaker and then we're closing public comment is shauna Brian i'm Sean go ahead.

1329
02:15:39.540 --> 02:15:45.540
sean obrien: Go me the money show me the money follow the money baby that's it, I support the motion.

1330
02:15:49.080 --> 02:15:49.680
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Sean.

1331
02:15:50.010 --> 02:15:50.400
sean obrien: Thank you.

1332
02:15:52.200 --> 02:15:57.540
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay we're closing public comment and now let's go to the board if anyone on the Board has.

1333
02:15:59.430 --> 02:16:03.840
Daffodil Tyminski: comment raise your hand and ELISE I see you have your henry's anyone else.

1334
02:16:05.490 --> 02:16:06.570
Daffodil Tyminski: Alright ELISE God.

1335
02:16:07.200 --> 02:16:12.090
Alix: And so quickly to Helens point, this is basically just asking the city attorney to.

1336
02:16:13.410 --> 02:16:20.760
Alix: write a legal opinion on something and to launch this point about water for those of you that did not see Gavin newsom just declared state of drought for.

1337
02:16:23.220 --> 02:16:26.310
Alix: very real issues that we should address and think about as we.

1338
02:16:26.970 --> 02:16:28.740
Alix: Look at our building in our district.

1339
02:16:30.330 --> 02:16:30.840
Daffodil Tyminski: Thankfully.

1340
02:16:31.980 --> 02:16:32.100
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm.

1341
02:16:33.810 --> 02:16:39.210
Daffodil Tyminski: sorry about that Jimmy well Jim I let you go last i'm solid why don't you go next.

1342
02:16:39.780 --> 02:16:42.210
Soledad Ursua: I was wondering if you guys could kind of explain.

1343
02:16:42.900 --> 02:16:54.840
Soledad Ursua: Just what the legal opinion would really do it seems a little confusing on On one hand I just get worried that an extra legal opinion kind of holding up development so just trying to figure out, you know where people were going with this.

1344
02:16:57.570 --> 02:16:59.460
Soledad Ursua: So we just better experimentation.

1345
02:16:59.820 --> 02:17:00.360
um.

1346
02:17:01.920 --> 02:17:07.590
Daffodil Tyminski: Why don't we take all the comments and then the makers of the motion can respond i'm Melissa what are you going to.

1347
02:17:10.680 --> 02:17:28.170
melissadiner: Oh, I just wanted to say that Jay handle with somebody that used to spend a lot of rv MC meetings and drinks afterwards that how he's been on the budget advocates forever he is all about what that public comment just said, show me the money and tracking your money so.

1348
02:17:29.790 --> 02:17:41.460
melissadiner: I imagine that he was proposing this with you know, to get more information to get to the bottom of that is that was always something he came and spoke to us about and we keep us in the loop on so.

1349
02:17:42.150 --> 02:17:48.720
melissadiner: It doesn't sound like it's a bad thing to get clarification on conflicting laws at the city state and.

1350
02:17:49.770 --> 02:17:51.090
melissadiner: The city and state level.

1351
02:17:53.580 --> 02:17:56.280
Daffodil Tyminski: awesome and Jim why don't you go last.

1352
02:17:56.670 --> 02:18:07.500
james murez: Okay developers are being asked to provide financial information about their stability or about their ability to be able to do a project and and there's a.

1353
02:18:09.030 --> 02:18:19.710
james murez: fair number of developers that don't feel that it's the city's right, be able to ask a developer to open their bank account up and show them just how much money they have their.

1354
02:18:20.880 --> 02:18:22.530
james murez: You know it's it's.

1355
02:18:23.790 --> 02:18:28.230
james murez: Going across boundary lines if they're coming in, for a permit or for some sort of entitlement.

1356
02:18:28.740 --> 02:18:35.010
james murez: Why should they have to open their their tax return or whatever to to the planning department or whoever.

1357
02:18:35.310 --> 02:18:42.720
james murez: And all of a sudden, does that information, then become public record, because now it's been taken in but it's just a whole lot of Gray area that that.

1358
02:18:43.560 --> 02:18:54.960
james murez: You know, in my opinion, it makes sense let's just ask the city attorney for the legal opinion of whether or not what's being subjected to some of the developers is actually illegal.

1359
02:18:59.340 --> 02:19:01.230
Daffodil Tyminski: I have come on to this as well, but as the.

1360
02:19:02.400 --> 02:19:04.650
Daffodil Tyminski: current holder the gavel i'll abstain.

1361
02:19:06.480 --> 02:19:08.070
Daffodil Tyminski: Why don't we call the vote, Melissa.

1362
02:19:18.690 --> 02:19:19.290
Daffodil Tyminski: Melissa.

1363
02:19:21.930 --> 02:19:22.680
melissadiner: Myself Jim.

1364
02:19:23.340 --> 02:19:24.810
melissadiner: Yes, daffodil.

1365
02:19:25.350 --> 02:19:26.250
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm going to abstain.

1366
02:19:26.700 --> 02:19:27.690
melissadiner: I vote yes.

1367
02:19:29.310 --> 02:19:29.880
Alix: Yes.

1368
02:19:30.690 --> 02:19:31.380
melissadiner: I think he.

1369
02:19:31.590 --> 02:19:32.130
Yes.

1370
02:19:35.310 --> 02:19:36.000
Alley Bean: Yes.

1371
02:19:36.060 --> 02:19:37.530
Chie Lunn: hi yes.

1372
02:19:37.830 --> 02:19:39.210
Mike Bravo: Bravo, no.

1373
02:19:51.510 --> 02:19:53.580
melissadiner: I took Elizabeth right yes.

1374
02:19:55.320 --> 02:19:55.920
ElizabethClay: didn't call me.

1375
02:19:56.970 --> 02:19:58.440
melissadiner: Close with that, so I wanted to double check.

1376
02:19:59.130 --> 02:20:00.570
melissadiner: No, thank you.

1377
02:20:10.380 --> 02:20:10.830
Soledad Ursua: i'm.

1378
02:20:17.580 --> 02:20:18.330
melissadiner: James rob.

1379
02:20:24.810 --> 02:20:25.560
melissadiner: James rob.

1380
02:20:27.570 --> 02:20:28.020
james murez: Jim.

1381
02:20:28.440 --> 02:20:29.220
jim robb: What abstain.

1382
02:20:31.740 --> 02:20:32.370
melissadiner: Pico.

1383
02:20:33.660 --> 02:20:34.110
Nico Ruderman: Yes.

1384
02:20:36.360 --> 02:20:36.900
clark brown: Yes.

1385
02:20:37.170 --> 02:20:37.680
melissadiner: All right.

1386
02:20:37.980 --> 02:20:39.660
melissadiner: Yes or no.

1387
02:20:39.930 --> 02:20:41.610
melissadiner: Yes, Andrea.

1388
02:20:42.120 --> 02:20:43.680
melissadiner: Yes, and cj.

1389
02:20:44.070 --> 02:20:45.840
melissadiner: Yes, and Stan are you back.

1390
02:20:46.800 --> 02:20:48.000
Ansar Muhammad: Yes, i'm saying.

1391
02:20:48.360 --> 02:20:48.780
melissadiner: Thank you.

1392
02:20:51.630 --> 02:20:56.160
james murez: never know i'm not sure exactly how we pass gamble back now I did I don't know if you just comes back to the.

1393
02:20:57.150 --> 02:21:00.240
Daffodil Tyminski: gym i'm going to pass the gavel back to you and you take it from here.

1394
02:21:00.450 --> 02:21:04.620
james murez: Okay, thank you i'm not sure what the procedure is for that, and since.

1395
02:21:04.980 --> 02:21:05.940
Daffodil Tyminski: I think we just did it.

1396
02:21:06.270 --> 02:21:13.380
james murez: Okay, our parliamentarians not here tonight, see you know we always have questions Okay, so we did 12 see already, we are on to 12 D.

1397
02:21:15.300 --> 02:21:19.530
james murez: Can I get the whole thing on one page, you have to do you want to read that one.

1398
02:21:23.520 --> 02:21:31.140
Daffodil Tyminski: Can you scroll up just a little bit yep this is item 12 D, this is a rack motion little bit more.

1399
02:21:31.500 --> 02:21:32.460
james murez: You want more scroll.

1400
02:21:32.640 --> 02:21:35.580
Daffodil Tyminski: Oh, I guess, this is fine, I wanted to give what it was, but.

1401
02:21:35.940 --> 02:21:36.270
james murez: No, the.

1402
02:21:36.720 --> 02:21:37.860
Daffodil Tyminski: emotion that he.

1403
02:21:37.950 --> 02:21:38.670
james murez: hears the title.

1404
02:21:39.330 --> 02:21:47.370
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah, this is a request for Council members to cooperate with Member Councils regarding the designation of sites under Los Angeles municipal code section.

1405
02:21:50.640 --> 02:21:57.690
Daffodil Tyminski: The motion is that the Venice neighborhood Council urges Council members bonnen correct bratman and ridley Thomas.

1406
02:21:58.260 --> 02:22:11.580
Daffodil Tyminski: Council members representing rack Member Councils to consult as soon as possible with their respective rack Member councils for input as to the designation of sites within their district for enforcement pursuant to La MC section.

1407
02:22:13.680 --> 02:22:30.810
Daffodil Tyminski: See one dash four and 4118 D, including one schools daycare centers public parks and libraries, as defined in Los Angeles municipal code section one a 5.01 quote sensitive uses.

1408
02:22:34.830 --> 02:22:44.160
Daffodil Tyminski: To overpasses underpasses freeway ramps tunnels bridges pedestrian bridges subways washes spreading grounds and active railways.

1409
02:22:44.610 --> 02:23:07.530
Daffodil Tyminski: When public health safety or welfare is served by the prohibition as 4118 see two three designated facilities open after January 1 2018 that provide shelter slave see safe sleeping or safe parking the homeless persons or that service homeless services navigation centers that's under.

1410
02:23:10.170 --> 02:23:18.960
Daffodil Tyminski: And for any locations and public rights of way for which there is documentation of a quote particular and ongoing threat to public health or safety and quote.

1411
02:23:19.530 --> 02:23:28.440
Daffodil Tyminski: that's under 4118 see for no enforcement action shall be taken unless the individuals have been offered shelter and review have refused the offer.

1412
02:23:29.730 --> 02:23:37.110
Daffodil Tyminski: The Venice neighborhood Council further request that one Council members bring resolutions and Council pursuant to Los Angeles municipal code section.

1413
02:23:38.010 --> 02:23:47.190
Daffodil Tyminski: See one through four and 4118 D as soon as any sites meeting the requirements of such sub sections are identified to them by the respective rap Member Councils.

1414
02:23:47.610 --> 02:23:59.040
Daffodil Tyminski: And to the distance of the radius prohibitions set forth in such resolution selby as requested by the relevant rack Member Councils consistent with the distance set forth and such sub sections.

1415
02:24:00.600 --> 02:24:02.100
james murez: Thank you, do we hear a second.

1416
02:24:03.840 --> 02:24:04.560
Alley Bean: i'll second it.

1417
02:24:04.740 --> 02:24:04.980
clark brown: Like a.

1418
02:24:06.120 --> 02:24:07.440
james murez: Second, was alley.

1419
02:24:08.790 --> 02:24:10.620
james murez: um OK.

1420
02:24:11.490 --> 02:24:12.240
Daffodil Tyminski: I will comment.

1421
02:24:12.330 --> 02:24:14.070
james murez: let's take public comment now.

1422
02:24:14.970 --> 02:24:15.840
um.

1423
02:24:17.970 --> 02:24:21.120
Daffodil Tyminski: We have a few people on um.

1424
02:24:22.500 --> 02:24:24.090
Daffodil Tyminski: Why don't we start Margaret with you.

1425
02:24:25.440 --> 02:24:27.210
james murez: looks like the last one will be Lisa redmond.

1426
02:24:27.900 --> 02:24:29.190
Margaret Molloy: Thank you and.

1427
02:24:30.240 --> 02:24:41.070
Margaret Molloy: I think that this is all punitive it seems to be the mo of this Council and the city council and you need to give people options before you impose.

1428
02:24:41.520 --> 02:24:54.930
Margaret Molloy: These kind of punitive restrictions, so I don't see anybody, not one of you proposing where are the safe places to Camp to sleep to be safe to not be raped, I don't hear it, I never heard, I have never heard it.

1429
02:24:55.440 --> 02:25:05.430
Margaret Molloy: So where are they and what does it mean to say if they're offered housing abstractly, what are we talking about, on the other side of you know pomona.

1430
02:25:06.480 --> 02:25:17.460
Margaret Molloy: radius so start being proactive, these are Community Members a lot of them are multi generational families who've been displaced start finding solutions.

1431
02:25:18.030 --> 02:25:37.080
Margaret Molloy: within our community in the neighboring communities and then then maybe start you know looking for these restrictions you're putting the cart before the horse you're putting your pleasure or your privilege over people's very existence get it right, please vote no on this.

1432
02:25:38.010 --> 02:25:39.060
Daffodil Tyminski: So much for.

1433
02:25:40.740 --> 02:25:43.800
Daffodil Tyminski: China, Brian why don't you go next i'll get the timer going.

1434
02:25:44.820 --> 02:25:46.380
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you yep.

1435
02:25:46.470 --> 02:25:56.550
sean obrien: Oh yeah hi i'm green view because I know it's a long meeting support the motion of city council's already passed something similar again I wish I had more teeth.

1436
02:25:57.000 --> 02:26:12.120
sean obrien: um and just to rebut of the last comment you know we will take care of our people we can't take care of the country or the world's homeless, they can't all come here and expect beach housing, but thank you guys.

1437
02:26:14.010 --> 02:26:14.850
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you Sean.

1438
02:26:16.440 --> 02:26:18.930
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm rubbing your eyes, why don't you go next.

1439
02:26:21.330 --> 02:26:21.810
Robin Murez: hi.

1440
02:26:22.860 --> 02:26:43.830
Robin Murez: Lisa I know you care, and we all care, and I want to bring to your attention that it was what four or five years ago that Jim Jerez put up the suggestion that the hundreds of acres near lx could be used for emergency housing at very little cost to make safe.

1441
02:26:44.880 --> 02:26:58.440
Robin Murez: Housing available it since has been described by many people is there could be fema style there could be safe camping safe parking and it's only not done because our City Council member won't do it.

1442
02:26:58.770 --> 02:27:12.360
Robin Murez: it's there it's available, it would be completely humanitarian and safe, so please let's all including you Lisa please let's work toward having some safe solutions here thanks.

1443
02:27:13.170 --> 02:27:15.870
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks so much i'm Helen go ahead.

1444
02:27:18.060 --> 02:27:29.910
Helen Fallon: I just want to remind everyone that this 41 at 41 it was modified it was a compromise between people who wanted strict enforcement and the people who wanted no enforcement.

1445
02:27:30.270 --> 02:27:35.550
Helen Fallon: A compromise was to allow the city council members to designate the spaces.

1446
02:27:36.000 --> 02:27:51.720
Helen Fallon: Unfortunately, our Council person is refusing to do that he's delaying it other Council members have stepped forward and and designated the sites, the problem thing the problem sites, why are we being discriminated against because.

1447
02:27:52.260 --> 02:27:58.680
Helen Fallon: Mr bond and apparently doesn't believe in majority rule, I mean that thing was voted on it was aired properly.

1448
02:27:59.010 --> 02:28:07.290
Helen Fallon: There was a lot of input into it, and this was the compromise, so we should we deserve to have a councilman is going to represent the interests of the Community.

1449
02:28:07.950 --> 02:28:25.650
Helen Fallon: Not just ignore it, because he didn't get his way on this issue and I would also mentioned that the list that was prepared on the other, motion on should be probably added to to go along with this, you know when you're talking about what you're going to submit to the Council.

1450
02:28:25.980 --> 02:28:27.450
james murez: I hope you have a public Thank you.

1451
02:28:27.570 --> 02:28:28.380
james murez: Thank you know.

1452
02:28:28.800 --> 02:28:33.300
Daffodil Tyminski: thanks him Darrell you'll be our last public comment or go ahead, please.

1453
02:28:34.920 --> 02:28:35.340
Darryl DuFay: Thank you.

1454
02:28:36.390 --> 02:28:45.210
Darryl DuFay: I know this is a political document, because if you have bonding and his friend ramen were the two people that voted against it.

1455
02:28:45.930 --> 02:28:56.820
Darryl DuFay: And then you have rick ridley Thomas who date who take today to clarity will no longer attend any meetings of the city council or be on any committee.

1456
02:28:57.480 --> 02:29:14.130
Darryl DuFay: So it it's it seems to be an overwhelming that I guess, this is what you have to do in order to move something forward, and I would suggest that it would be, this is the right way to go about moving something forward, thank you.

1457
02:29:15.180 --> 02:29:15.960
Daffodil Tyminski: So much.

1458
02:29:17.100 --> 02:29:23.520
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, with that we're closing comment um anyone on the board, have any comments.

1459
02:29:26.310 --> 02:29:27.540
james murez: Andre go ahead, please.

1460
02:29:29.970 --> 02:29:32.280
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes, I hope I will vote yes for this.

1461
02:29:33.300 --> 02:29:44.370
Andrea Boccaletti: For Council person is neglecting all good ideas and neglecting the homeless and neglecting the stakeholders of Venice so enough is enough, thank you.

1462
02:29:44.850 --> 02:29:46.650
james murez: Thank you Clark go ahead, please.

1463
02:29:46.800 --> 02:29:50.970
clark brown: yeah with respect to these two parcels at La X on September 21.

1464
02:29:51.360 --> 02:30:04.080
clark brown: The executive director of La la Los Angeles world airports, sent a letter to the NGOs counterpart of the FAA said, please tell us if you were aware of any written regulations which would prohibit the city.

1465
02:30:04.350 --> 02:30:16.260
clark brown: from using these two parcels for palette housing, so that letter makes very clear that the city is not aware of such regulations and so these two processes, I think, will be shortly available.

1466
02:30:16.950 --> 02:30:37.260
clark brown: For relocating people from the homeless encampments your point I want to make is that about three weeks ago I emailed Lisa redmond this to page spreadsheet which the mayor's office filed on July 15th 2021 and the judge Carter case which identified.

1467
02:30:38.280 --> 02:30:51.780
clark brown: 909,633 beds, all within the city of Los Angeles, which are available for take care of taking care of the homeless people so we've got plenty of resources and.

1468
02:30:52.980 --> 02:30:54.480
clark brown: I support this motion.

1469
02:30:54.900 --> 02:30:57.030
james murez: Thank you Clark i'm.

1470
02:30:58.500 --> 02:30:58.800
james murez: Mike.

1471
02:30:59.250 --> 02:31:00.120
james murez: Mike go ahead.

1472
02:31:00.990 --> 02:31:08.160
Mike Bravo: yeah that's Why make it clear that you know 41 point 18 i'm i'm totally against that motion in general, so I can't support anything that even.

1473
02:31:08.910 --> 02:31:17.820
Mike Bravo: reinforces that just the way authorizes police powers to see employees and expands law enforcement powers like that I just not I can't.

1474
02:31:18.240 --> 02:31:26.310
Mike Bravo: support that and for all of you one of you who've been a part of the black lives matter had bumper stickers or science, this is totally against.

1475
02:31:27.300 --> 02:31:36.150
Mike Bravo: allow their principles and our tenants to so just fyi that's a major contradiction if you had your signs up and you've done the parades and all that stuff that's it.

1476
02:31:36.810 --> 02:31:38.430
james murez: Thank you Mike allie go ahead.

1477
02:31:38.970 --> 02:31:51.990
Alley Bean: um I mean I just sort of to answer Mike and Lisa my feeling is this is, this is the result of housing first it's a concept that is a wonderful concept in theory.

1478
02:31:52.410 --> 02:31:59.580
Alley Bean: But because of it all of the money is going towards new development we don't have any it's not offering any shelter and a transitional housing.

1479
02:32:00.120 --> 02:32:07.560
Alley Bean: And so, yes, we need beds Lisa we need beds Mike We need people housed period it's getting to be winter.

1480
02:32:07.920 --> 02:32:19.050
Alley Bean: We need people not dying on the streets, but we've been crippled and I feel like the city's not listening to us for alternatives so that's why people are voting for things like this, you know.

1481
02:32:19.500 --> 02:32:31.350
Alley Bean: And and it's an incredibly frustrating situation but that's where we are, because we have to get people off the streets and we can't just be waiting for new developments that cost too much way too much money.

1482
02:32:31.980 --> 02:32:46.200
Alley Bean: I mean the project here in La I mean in Venice is 750 to 92 $50,000 a unit that's insane so i'm frustrated and even though i'm with you guys on wanting people House I want a mouse now.

1483
02:32:46.770 --> 02:32:50.790
Alley Bean: And not and I housing first is blowing the whole thing to me all the money is going to the wrong place.

1484
02:32:51.720 --> 02:32:54.030
james murez: Thank you ellie elite go ahead, please.

1485
02:32:55.230 --> 02:33:05.670
Alix: I would echo alleys comments and just to like reinforce that to sit, excuse me, the statistic that we have five people a day dying on our streets.

1486
02:33:06.000 --> 02:33:14.730
Alix: And this has happened under our study this has happened under ridley Thomas this has happened under her Wesson yes, we have.

1487
02:33:15.390 --> 02:33:26.970
Alix: challenges with the police force, but that doesn't excuse five people dying on the streets per day, and so we are at a point where, unfortunately, we need to support motions like this.

1488
02:33:28.260 --> 02:33:30.240
james murez: Thank you, a leak NICO go ahead, please.

1489
02:33:31.770 --> 02:33:35.880
Nico Ruderman: yeah but first like to start off by I do understand mike's point.

1490
02:33:37.080 --> 02:33:38.760
Nico Ruderman: About about how this is.

1491
02:33:40.050 --> 02:33:48.360
Nico Ruderman: going to increase policing and law enforcement and and how that might affect minority communities, I guess.

1492
02:33:49.200 --> 02:33:59.610
Nico Ruderman: The bigger issue is, though, I feel like this will also force the city to offer people housing which they're not doing a lot of a lot of the time, and we need to get people off the streets.

1493
02:34:00.300 --> 02:34:07.590
Nico Ruderman: And even further this this will help protect keeping encampments and meth labs away from schools.

1494
02:34:08.460 --> 02:34:15.150
Nico Ruderman: You know I know of to two separate meth labs of imparts near near elementary schools and it's it's completely unacceptable.

1495
02:34:15.810 --> 02:34:25.860
Nico Ruderman: it's been a lot of crime, and we need to, we need to keep our children safe, you know our homeless population needs to be protected, but our children do too, so I, I support this motion.

1496
02:34:27.930 --> 02:34:35.520
james murez: Thank you i'm seeing no other board hands up Melissa let's take a vote.

1497
02:34:40.680 --> 02:34:42.060
melissadiner: Okay i'm Jim.

1498
02:34:42.390 --> 02:34:42.870
Yes.

1499
02:34:43.890 --> 02:34:44.610
melissadiner: daffodil.

1500
02:34:45.090 --> 02:34:47.340
melissadiner: Yes, yes, the leaks.

1501
02:34:47.490 --> 02:34:49.050
melissadiner: Yes, a key.

1502
02:34:49.440 --> 02:34:50.490
melissadiner: Give the ummah.

1503
02:34:51.300 --> 02:34:51.690
yeah.

1504
02:34:53.370 --> 02:34:53.910
melissadiner: Ali.

1505
02:34:54.210 --> 02:34:55.860
melissadiner: Yes, hi.

1506
02:34:56.910 --> 02:34:57.630
melissadiner: Like bravo.

1507
02:34:58.170 --> 02:34:58.530
Low.

1508
02:35:00.090 --> 02:35:00.420
melissadiner: play.

1509
02:35:03.030 --> 02:35:03.780
melissadiner: Solid I.

1510
02:35:04.140 --> 02:35:06.240
melissadiner: guess dreams rob.

1511
02:35:09.600 --> 02:35:10.080
jim robb: Yes.

1512
02:35:13.320 --> 02:35:13.710
Nico Ruderman: Yes.

1513
02:35:16.800 --> 02:35:18.060
clark brown: Clark yes.

1514
02:35:19.530 --> 02:35:20.130
melissadiner: Robert.

1515
02:35:20.550 --> 02:35:21.030
Yes.

1516
02:35:22.170 --> 02:35:22.620
Bruno Hernandez: Yes.

1517
02:35:24.870 --> 02:35:25.440
melissadiner: DJ.

1518
02:35:25.830 --> 02:35:27.540
melissadiner: Yes, Stan Muhammad.

1519
02:35:28.470 --> 02:35:28.920
know.

1520
02:35:32.820 --> 02:35:33.570
melissadiner: Stan here.

1521
02:35:36.120 --> 02:35:37.380
Daffodil Tyminski: He said no, no.

1522
02:36:06.450 --> 02:36:08.610
james murez: Melissa did we get a count on that.

1523
02:36:10.680 --> 02:36:11.220
melissadiner: yep.

1524
02:36:14.550 --> 02:36:16.170
melissadiner: it's 16 zero to.

1525
02:36:19.170 --> 02:36:22.260
james murez: 16 02 those two abstentions.

1526
02:36:23.760 --> 02:36:24.090
melissadiner: No.

1527
02:36:24.330 --> 02:36:26.160
james murez: No 16.

1528
02:36:26.220 --> 02:36:26.580
again.

1529
02:36:29.400 --> 02:36:31.290
james murez: It would be 16 to zero human.

1530
02:36:31.710 --> 02:36:33.240
melissadiner: Okay 16 to zero.

1531
02:36:33.420 --> 02:36:33.930
james murez: Thank you.

1532
02:36:35.280 --> 02:36:38.310
james murez: um okay let's move on 12 p.

1533
02:36:40.530 --> 02:36:41.370
james murez: daffodil you're up.

1534
02:36:45.000 --> 02:36:49.260
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay 12 years a request for revision of the proposed amendment to the done.

1535
02:36:50.430 --> 02:36:55.050
Daffodil Tyminski: I believe that's the Department of neighborhood empowerment code of conduct brought by Rack.

1536
02:36:56.550 --> 02:37:01.980
Daffodil Tyminski: Whereas the board of neighborhood Commissioners, let me just do it should I read the whole thing or I think just the.

1537
02:37:01.980 --> 02:37:02.430
Daffodil Tyminski: My thing.

1538
02:37:02.550 --> 02:37:04.230
james murez: I think, just the motion is fine.

1539
02:37:04.410 --> 02:37:15.810
Daffodil Tyminski: Right now, therefore, be it resolved that colon bonk that's the Bureau of neighborhood Councils is advised against approving the proposed amendments to the Code of Conduct in their current form.

1540
02:37:16.620 --> 02:37:23.760
Daffodil Tyminski: The Venice neighborhood Council request that the Department of neighborhood empowerment in consultation with an ad hoc group of neighborhood Council members.

1541
02:37:24.510 --> 02:37:34.860
Daffodil Tyminski: provides the proposed amendments to ensure they afford the board and committee members, adequate due process rather than granting the department sole discretion to immediately suspend a member.

1542
02:37:35.310 --> 02:37:47.040
Daffodil Tyminski: Based on an alleged violation of applicable rules that any amendments to the Code of Conduct must take into account varying degrees of conduct when considering suspension and appropriate penalties if warranted.

1543
02:37:48.060 --> 02:37:53.250
Daffodil Tyminski: The code of conduct shall require that the minimum correction necessary to address any issue be used.

1544
02:37:54.000 --> 02:37:59.940
Daffodil Tyminski: The workplace equity policy shall be incorporated into the proposed amendments to the city to the code of conduct.

1545
02:38:00.570 --> 02:38:12.540
Daffodil Tyminski: Only a formally adopted by the city prior to the neighborhood Council city department review process and in the alternative the Code of Conduct shall incorporate the city's workplace violence policy and guidelines.

1546
02:38:13.890 --> 02:38:14.670
james murez: Do I have a second.

1547
02:38:15.930 --> 02:38:16.560
Alix: i'll second.

1548
02:38:16.680 --> 02:38:22.560
james murez: leaks, thank you leaks, I just want to add in here for anybody that doesn't understand what this is about.

1549
02:38:23.850 --> 02:38:30.000
james murez: The city has a program right now that there actually is a hearing board.

1550
02:38:30.420 --> 02:38:47.760
james murez: And, and there are procedures for removing somebody from a board of a neighborhood Council and other board member of the neighborhood Council in in most cases was elected, and that pretty much citywide what this is doing is it's transferring the authority to be.

1551
02:38:47.760 --> 02:38:48.180
Soledad Ursua: able to.

1552
02:38:48.300 --> 02:39:01.050
james murez: Remove somebody from a board that was voted into office to the person this woman raquel that's in charge of the Department of Labor of empowerment, she will be able to otter sole discretion.

1553
02:39:01.590 --> 02:39:11.010
james murez: remove any board member or any committee Member from any neighborhood Council without any process without any form of due process or appeal process.

1554
02:39:11.610 --> 02:39:20.130
james murez: And she can suspend them are completely remove them so that's what this is about, I was at the meeting, where it was held, and on that note let's see if we have any public comment.

1555
02:39:22.110 --> 02:39:23.700
james murez: looks like we have three hands up.

1556
02:39:25.260 --> 02:39:27.150
james murez: For hands up five hands up.

1557
02:39:29.280 --> 02:39:32.970
james murez: Okay let's stop after Erica more definitely want to start.

1558
02:39:33.390 --> 02:39:35.730
Daffodil Tyminski: or Yolanda why don't you go first.

1559
02:39:37.020 --> 02:39:42.840
Yolanda Gonzalez: Yes, i'm very familiar with this motion this comes down from mijares i'm.

1560
02:39:44.220 --> 02:39:55.980
Yolanda Gonzalez: The President of the Council, and because they don't like in certain neighborhood Councils that where people got voted in they think they can just remove them, it was going to happen and suddenly to hunger.

1561
02:39:56.970 --> 02:40:07.950
Yolanda Gonzalez: This please do not vote vote no on this and all of a sudden, this is a political movement in order to take over the council's Thank you.

1562
02:40:08.910 --> 02:40:16.050
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks so much i'm Margaret why don't you go next and actually sorry, let me start timing this go ahead, Margaret.

1563
02:40:16.290 --> 02:40:29.640
Margaret Molloy: So I think, as you all know, the last meeting was that rages I filed a major complaint asking for removal of several Members people telling us to Fuck off people slamming elected officials.

1564
02:40:30.060 --> 02:40:38.580
Margaret Molloy: People giving a thumbs up to people who want to get rid of elected officials, I mean just the gamut so several people need to go.

1565
02:40:38.940 --> 02:40:48.900
Margaret Molloy: And I would absolutely support this motion because you guys are incapable of policing yourself, not one single person called anybody out for that behavior not one of.

1566
02:40:48.900 --> 02:41:03.060
Margaret Molloy: You multi you know years on these boards, not one of you, it was disgusting and you know I want several you gone in the same in the same breath and because there were more than one violation.

1567
02:41:04.500 --> 02:41:19.050
Margaret Molloy: And power like grievances won't deal with it, they only deal with one violation, so they sent me back my complaint suggested I file and empower la complaint based on these three separate issues I know it will be denied.

1568
02:41:20.070 --> 02:41:27.540
Margaret Molloy: grievance 100 from para la was several grievances in one meeting denied because you can only address one single grief and.

1569
02:41:27.540 --> 02:41:28.290
james murez: Thank you, Mario.

1570
02:41:30.300 --> 02:41:30.750
Margaret Molloy: away.

1571
02:41:31.920 --> 02:41:33.690
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm Helen found go ahead.

1572
02:41:37.530 --> 02:41:50.430
Helen Fallon: i've attended at least one meeting where we're cowbell try and explain the purpose of this issue here is allegations she could suspend somebody based on an allegation not based.

1573
02:41:50.430 --> 02:41:50.790
Helen Fallon: On a.

1574
02:41:50.880 --> 02:41:52.770
Helen Fallon: On proof or actual fact.

1575
02:41:53.940 --> 02:42:07.350
Helen Fallon: I believe that empower does have the right to step in and disciplines words that don't follow the rules, but there has to be factual basis for that not just someone's opinion that they didn't like the way somebody talked to them or.

1576
02:42:07.830 --> 02:42:17.400
Helen Fallon: You know that kind of thing, so I look at this as this is raquel BELTRAN trying to consolidate or power bank is an appointed group weighted by the mayor.

1577
02:42:17.820 --> 02:42:29.610
Helen Fallon: If you guys don't take a position on this and say you're opposed to this, it will be interpreted as you support recals consolidation of power, I don't believe that we need an Empress of empower.

1578
02:42:30.090 --> 02:42:48.570
Helen Fallon: We need a functional in john that supports the mcs and just support and does discipline and step in when people don't follow the rules violate you know robert's rules, the brown active cetera but allegations are not the basis for discipline it's just wrong.

1579
02:42:49.200 --> 02:42:49.710
james murez: Thank you.

1580
02:42:49.770 --> 02:42:50.550
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Helen.

1581
02:42:53.310 --> 02:42:56.850
Daffodil Tyminski: yo Yolanda why don't you go ahead, did you I don't think he spoke on this.

1582
02:42:57.180 --> 02:42:58.410
james murez: A lot Yolanda already spoke.

1583
02:42:58.500 --> 02:43:00.600
Daffodil Tyminski: She did okay Lisa redmond why don't you go ahead.

1584
02:43:02.880 --> 02:43:03.240
Lisa Redmond: i'll.

1585
02:43:04.260 --> 02:43:11.490
Lisa Redmond: yeah I really agree with Helen um this is, you know is is wrong as.

1586
02:43:13.290 --> 02:43:24.360
Lisa Redmond: There are a lot of big fish in a little pond in neighborhood Councils, including this Council itself, where a lot of people think that they're you know the president's kings dictators.

1587
02:43:24.720 --> 02:43:25.860
Lisa Redmond: of their little communities.

1588
02:43:26.160 --> 02:43:36.840
Lisa Redmond: And there are people in the West valley that very much should be removed, but based on an allegation is not the right way and where there's injustice for one there's injustice for all.

1589
02:43:38.280 --> 02:43:49.140
Lisa Redmond: So as much as I truly agree with Margaret with what happened last month was extremely egregious i'm i'm going to have to on a rare occasion support this.

1590
02:43:49.140 --> 02:44:01.380
Lisa Redmond: rack motion, and also the last mission my hand was up somehow it got put down, and it was really upsetting considering that many of the commenters addressed to me and I didn't get a chance to comment that's all.

1591
02:44:03.750 --> 02:44:04.590
james murez: Thank you Lisa.

1592
02:44:05.070 --> 02:44:08.640
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay Erica we're gonna close public comment with you go ahead.

1593
02:44:13.950 --> 02:44:14.460
Daffodil Tyminski: Erica.

1594
02:44:20.520 --> 02:44:20.880
Erica Moore: hi.

1595
02:44:21.000 --> 02:44:21.870
Erica Moore: sorry about that.

1596
02:44:22.350 --> 02:44:22.800
Daffodil Tyminski: No worries.

1597
02:44:23.460 --> 02:44:35.700
Erica Moore: Okay, so basically both Helen and Lisa so I was going on yep Helen was so sustained and then what Lisa said is absolutely true, and I feel margaret's pain, because.

1598
02:44:36.270 --> 02:44:46.500
Erica Moore: I definitely think that you can't police yourself is really the bottom line so it's kind of tricky but I absolutely believe in due process, I do not think one person.

1599
02:44:46.890 --> 02:44:53.370
Erica Moore: should be able to make these decisions based on allegations, I think I think a panel should be assessing the situation, I understand.

1600
02:44:53.850 --> 02:45:00.270
Erica Moore: The reasoning, to try to push things through faster, but I don't think that that makes sense it's not it's not reasonable and it's not equitable.

1601
02:45:00.780 --> 02:45:14.610
Erica Moore: So I really think that Helen and Lisa said it best and and Margaret but I absolutely understand why Margaret said what she said to so please do support that this does not go through, thank you.

1602
02:45:15.660 --> 02:45:16.440
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Erica.

1603
02:45:16.890 --> 02:45:17.700
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay let's take.

1604
02:45:17.760 --> 02:45:21.420
james murez: A look comment at this point soledad you were the first had your hand up.

1605
02:45:21.600 --> 02:45:22.560
Soledad Ursua: You gotta go.

1606
02:45:22.800 --> 02:45:33.630
Soledad Ursua: I am against done having more control over our new word Councils, but I just want to make sure how am I gonna vote to pose this would I vote against this motion rainbow know.

1607
02:45:35.820 --> 02:45:51.120
james murez: If you vote to support this motion, you will be voting to support the Rack motion, and then the Rack, in turn, if they get the nine supporting Councils will then send forward.

1608
02:45:51.450 --> 02:45:54.450
james murez: A united front message to the city.

1609
02:45:57.330 --> 02:45:57.540
Alley Bean: To the.

1610
02:45:57.900 --> 02:45:59.670
Soledad Ursua: Beginning yeah so.

1611
02:46:02.070 --> 02:46:02.700
Soledad Ursua: This isn't me.

1612
02:46:03.930 --> 02:46:04.350
Sima Kostovetsky: yeah.

1613
02:46:04.470 --> 02:46:24.000
james murez: We are again if you wanna if you want to support the Rack motion, which is to send the message No, this is not okay to the Department of neighborhood empowerment, you would say yes to this, which in turn rack is saying no it's not okay.

1614
02:46:25.170 --> 02:46:30.360
Soledad Ursua: Okay, so I will be voting yes to pose done having more control over the neighborhood Councils.

1615
02:46:30.390 --> 02:46:31.230
james murez: that's correct.

1616
02:46:31.320 --> 02:46:31.710
and

1617
02:46:34.170 --> 02:46:34.740
james murez: All week.

1618
02:46:36.180 --> 02:46:53.130
Alix: I cannot stress enough how important it is to support this motion for anyone who is not following what is going on at done, and with this code of conduct, I suggest you take some time to to read it is it, it is a terrible consolidation of power.

1619
02:46:54.180 --> 02:46:56.550
Alix: jack Humphrey ville I think is doing a lot of.

1620
02:46:56.850 --> 02:47:01.650
Alix: Reporting for see watch on going on at done and I think there's some investigations there.

1621
02:47:02.130 --> 02:47:14.340
Alix: I urge all of the board members to support this motion, I know it's a little unclear, the way it's written, but it is, it is essentially to not support the current done code of conduct so that's all.

1622
02:47:16.620 --> 02:47:18.060
james murez: Thank you Alice go ahead, please.

1623
02:47:18.420 --> 02:47:20.700
Alley Bean: um yeah, I just wanted to.

1624
02:47:22.170 --> 02:47:27.570
Alley Bean: To to I don't know what the word is, but like maybe encouraged Margaret and Lisa that there's a.

1625
02:47:28.170 --> 02:47:37.740
Alley Bean: Venice neighborhood Council email system, and there was a lot of apology and a lot of conversation about the conduct last week, I know you guys didn't get to hear it, but.

1626
02:47:38.280 --> 02:47:45.300
Alley Bean: A lot of people talked about it within the board, and I think Jim sort of addressed it at the beginning that we need to be more civil and.

1627
02:47:46.020 --> 02:47:56.280
Alley Bean: There was public not public apologies, because it was just amongst us, but I thought it might make you feel better to know that there was a lot of conversation in the emails about it, about what you were saying.

1628
02:47:57.180 --> 02:47:59.790
james murez: Thank you ellie i'm Mike go ahead.

1629
02:48:00.660 --> 02:48:07.350
Mike Bravo: yeah i'll probably support the Rack motion, but in my opinion, is come like a free for all because.

1630
02:48:08.940 --> 02:48:13.770
Mike Bravo: If you remember, ECHO park in 2015 when allowed the or get a community.

1631
02:48:14.880 --> 02:48:26.490
Mike Bravo: took the last seats against identification forces air, you know done via their power with other local council people they wouldn't they had no has a way and dismantle That said, they always find a way to make.

1632
02:48:27.660 --> 02:48:38.490
Mike Bravo: dismantle something if they really don't want it so that's what it kind of a given, and then we flash back to what like two years ago with matt Fisher to and even you know, is a brace of you know personality.

1633
02:48:40.140 --> 02:48:51.030
Mike Bravo: considered to what that happened it doesn't arbitrary removal him to so either way the way I see it, we're both kind of screwed either way we go so but i'll plan to support in Iraq motion.

1634
02:48:52.110 --> 02:48:54.480
james murez: Thank you Mike Clark go ahead.

1635
02:48:55.290 --> 02:49:04.560
clark brown: If I understand this motion correctly, it would require hearings and other procedures before action can be taken against an individual or.

1636
02:49:05.220 --> 02:49:15.000
clark brown: Having done something something wrong, the problem I have with this is that I think the interest at stake, of the individuals interested steak or not great enough.

1637
02:49:15.450 --> 02:49:27.900
clark brown: To justify these additional procedures, the problem with the additional procedures is that it focuses on procedure rather than focusing on substantive things that need to be done in the Community.

1638
02:49:28.380 --> 02:49:36.570
clark brown: it's kind of an internal thing rather than an external focus, so my understanding of this thing is correct i'm against it.

1639
02:49:38.820 --> 02:49:42.660
james murez: Thank you Clark i'm daffodil last but not least.

1640
02:49:43.020 --> 02:49:43.350
Oh.

1641
02:49:44.550 --> 02:49:53.190
Daffodil Tyminski: Well, I just you know I think we're all familiar with the phrase life, liberty, you know the the government shall not denies of life, liberty, or property right.

1642
02:49:53.970 --> 02:50:03.540
Daffodil Tyminski: What we never hear the end of that which is without due process of law that's our fifth amendment that comes out of the Magna Carta goes back to the 1215.

1643
02:50:03.990 --> 02:50:11.280
Daffodil Tyminski: You know, even the kings in England recognize that we needed some protection of process right so for people talking about kings and dictatorships.

1644
02:50:12.480 --> 02:50:19.530
Daffodil Tyminski: I just think it's absolutely fundamental for any fair governing body that there has to be due process.

1645
02:50:19.830 --> 02:50:31.380
Daffodil Tyminski: And if we have an election system where we're going to actually spend the time and money and effort to elect people, we have to have due process in whatever role we have in centering removing or.

1646
02:50:32.100 --> 02:50:48.120
Daffodil Tyminski: disciplining them, so I think for the city to to to take this move is just sort of it's it's some evidence of its complete disregard for the neighborhood Council system and for the role that we all play which I think is very important, even though we have no power.

1647
02:50:48.720 --> 02:50:51.300
Daffodil Tyminski: And I would urge people to vote against us because.

1648
02:50:51.300 --> 02:51:08.310
Daffodil Tyminski: I think this is the one thing when people talk about how great it is to be an American how people fight for our country and they fight for civil liberties, it is for this kind of system that people fight for and so I think, to vote against this would really just be a sad testament to.

1649
02:51:09.540 --> 02:51:11.010
Daffodil Tyminski: You know who we are, as Americans.

1650
02:51:13.860 --> 02:51:16.410
james murez: Thank you Danielle so just to be clear.

1651
02:51:18.420 --> 02:51:42.000
james murez: Yes vote would be supporting the Rack motion which sends the message to the city, no, we don't agree with the policies that you're proposing a no vote will send the message from rack to the city saying it's Okay, for them to impose this new.

1652
02:51:43.830 --> 02:51:44.640
james murez: way of acting.

1653
02:51:46.110 --> 02:51:47.850
james murez: Okay, Melissa let's take about.

1654
02:52:01.230 --> 02:52:02.070
james murez: Is Melissa here.

1655
02:52:05.430 --> 02:52:07.770
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah I think her mute is a little slow to unmute.

1656
02:52:09.210 --> 02:52:10.740
melissadiner: i'm here, Jim.

1657
02:52:10.830 --> 02:52:11.580
Yes.

1658
02:52:12.630 --> 02:52:13.200
Daffodil Tyminski: Yes.

1659
02:52:13.290 --> 02:52:14.820
melissadiner: I vote yes police.

1660
02:52:15.030 --> 02:52:16.140
melissadiner: Yes, ricky.

1661
02:52:16.410 --> 02:52:16.860
Yes.

1662
02:52:18.090 --> 02:52:18.630
Sima Kostovetsky: yeah.

1663
02:52:18.750 --> 02:52:20.130
Alley Bean: holly yes.

1664
02:52:20.190 --> 02:52:20.640
hi.

1665
02:52:23.400 --> 02:52:23.760
melissadiner: Okay.

1666
02:52:23.970 --> 02:52:25.410
melissadiner: Yes, like bravo.

1667
02:52:25.830 --> 02:52:27.270
melissadiner: Yes, so the clay.

1668
02:52:27.750 --> 02:52:28.380
Yes.

1669
02:52:29.400 --> 02:52:29.970
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

1670
02:52:30.180 --> 02:52:30.840
melissadiner: James rob.

1671
02:52:31.200 --> 02:52:32.460
jim robb: Yes, yes.

1672
02:52:33.990 --> 02:52:34.410
Nico Ruderman: Yes.

1673
02:52:34.710 --> 02:52:35.940
clark brown: Clark, though.

1674
02:52:38.250 --> 02:52:39.450
melissadiner: Roberts have it oh.

1675
02:52:39.750 --> 02:52:40.350
Yes.

1676
02:52:43.080 --> 02:52:43.590
melissadiner: or no.

1677
02:52:44.130 --> 02:52:45.420
melissadiner: Yes, Andrea.

1678
02:52:45.900 --> 02:52:47.520
melissadiner: Does cj.

1679
02:52:47.640 --> 02:52:50.610
melissadiner: Yes, Stan yes.

1680
02:52:53.670 --> 02:52:54.510
melissadiner: Last night.

1681
02:52:54.780 --> 02:52:57.840
melissadiner: or 18 one zero.

1682
02:52:58.950 --> 02:53:01.380
james murez: Thank you motion gary's.

1683
02:53:02.670 --> 02:53:05.190
james murez: Moving right along next one.

1684
02:53:08.100 --> 02:53:10.590
james murez: Definitely, you want to read this one i'm.

1685
02:53:11.370 --> 02:53:14.640
Daffodil Tyminski: sure this is 12 s.

1686
02:53:14.880 --> 02:53:26.370
Daffodil Tyminski: Yes, Okay, so this is emotion for Community impact statement and supportive Council file 21 dash 1115 to prohibit bicycle chop shops within the public right of way.

1687
02:53:28.140 --> 02:53:32.550
Daffodil Tyminski: This is a motion to file Community impact statement and supportive that Council file.

1688
02:53:33.000 --> 02:53:49.110
Daffodil Tyminski: That request the creation of a bicycle chop shop ordinance prohibiting assembly, disassembly sale offer sale distribution of bicycles and bike parts on public property or within the public right of way and, as many of you know we've heard this issue.

1689
02:53:49.800 --> 02:53:51.480
james murez: That was your motion, we need to second.

1690
02:53:53.580 --> 02:53:54.600
Alix: i'll second Italy.

1691
02:53:55.080 --> 02:53:56.700
james murez: Thank you go ahead def don't sorry.

1692
02:53:56.820 --> 02:54:06.180
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm sorry, as many of you know, this has been an issue that's come before the dnc for several years now, at multiple times and multiple motions.

1693
02:54:07.080 --> 02:54:17.220
Daffodil Tyminski: So this is nothing new, but it's now that the issue is coming back to cancel the request is that we now file a Community impact statement reflecting our previous decisions.

1694
02:54:18.570 --> 02:54:20.310
Daffodil Tyminski: So let's take some public comment.

1695
02:54:20.490 --> 02:54:21.030
james murez: Thank you.

1696
02:54:22.800 --> 02:54:27.750
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm lunch Lisa redmond go ahead.

1697
02:54:32.880 --> 02:54:43.950
Lisa Redmond: And, as I stated at the Ad COM meeting My problem with this is it's not gone through committee it's not an immediate urgency it's not scheduled for Council.

1698
02:54:44.490 --> 02:54:59.070
Lisa Redmond: At this time it definitely could go to committee i'm bothered by anything that's rushed to the actual board, without going through committee when there isn't a pressing urgent time need Thank you.

1699
02:55:00.210 --> 02:55:01.170
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks so much Lisa.

1700
02:55:01.230 --> 02:55:01.980
james murez: Thank you Lisa.

1701
02:55:02.970 --> 02:55:07.410
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm Yolanda why don't you go, we lost Yolanda there.

1702
02:55:07.470 --> 02:55:08.460
james murez: We lost you along.

1703
02:55:08.700 --> 02:55:10.350
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay Helen why don't you go next.

1704
02:55:13.980 --> 02:55:20.730
Helen Fallon: This was supported by this Council two years ago, the concept of doing something about bicycle chop shops.

1705
02:55:21.120 --> 02:55:29.250
Helen Fallon: You sent a letter to bond and a year ago, saying hey how about doing emotion about asking for an ordinance that would tackle this issue.

1706
02:55:29.700 --> 02:55:43.350
Helen Fallon: dead silence, we can hear the crickets they have finally gotten before the city council, a request emotion, to request that they consider adopting an ordinance that would address this criminal activity.

1707
02:55:43.650 --> 02:55:49.500
Helen Fallon: That is basically happening and homeless and countless those criminals are lighting among the homeless and.

1708
02:55:50.040 --> 02:55:56.520
Helen Fallon: it's outrageous I mean it's like the broken window syndrome, when you see piles of bicycles it doesn't criminalize the homeless.

1709
02:55:56.850 --> 02:56:04.110
Helen Fallon: It doesn't make like worse for them, it should make it better because you're actually removing some of these criminals use these.

1710
02:56:04.710 --> 02:56:18.480
Helen Fallon: encampments to hide out in and hide their criminal activities, I don't think I think this community is 100% in favor of it, I don't think you have very many people who say it's cool to see all these bikes being stolen stacked up under tarps.

1711
02:56:18.600 --> 02:56:19.290
james murez: Thank you over.

1712
02:56:19.320 --> 02:56:20.520
Helen Fallon: Our city streets.

1713
02:56:20.640 --> 02:56:21.060
james murez: Thank you.

1714
02:56:23.550 --> 02:56:24.780
Daffodil Tyminski: Erica more go ahead.

1715
02:56:27.630 --> 02:56:31.380
Erica Moore: hi I absolutely am in supportive this.

1716
02:56:33.120 --> 02:56:35.640
Erica Moore: i've been a witness to all sides of it.

1717
02:56:36.450 --> 02:56:49.590
Erica Moore: So it absolutely for our Community I don't know anybody who's there's a lot of people getting their bike stolen, I mean it's it's calmed down right now, more than it was like a year ago, but it absolutely needs to be addressed and I hope you support it, thank you.

1718
02:56:51.450 --> 02:56:52.350
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Erica.

1719
02:56:54.360 --> 02:56:57.180
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay lydia ponce go ahead.

1720
02:56:59.280 --> 02:57:15.210
Lydia Ponce: So what does this say about lamps the bike whisper I mean this whole blanket thing the generalization hate the generalized heat that you have for other people being creative you know I understand about bicycles being stolen.

1721
02:57:16.230 --> 02:57:25.110
Lydia Ponce: being left in the yard being unattended and all of that i've witnessed everything that has happened with 1012 Bytes and such.

1722
02:57:25.500 --> 02:57:32.610
Lydia Ponce: it's called mental health issues it's called trauma it's called they can't explain it to themselves, how can they explain to anybody else.

1723
02:57:33.120 --> 02:57:42.510
Lydia Ponce: On the other side of it, I don't I vote no because it doesn't clarify someone who has a license for their business and who does occupy some of the public.

1724
02:57:43.050 --> 02:57:52.920
Lydia Ponce: walkway to conduct his business, and I think it's pretty shitty if you guys vote this through without considering him he's a great upstanding guy in the Community, thank you.

1725
02:57:54.750 --> 02:57:57.780
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks so much Sean o'brien go ahead.

1726
02:58:00.690 --> 02:58:22.170
sean obrien: As a 30 year Venice resident I probably at least 10 bike stolen I keep my nice bikes locked up in the House, keep ready cruiser in the garage of that last comment you know bikes aren't left on attended blocks are being cut and sawed through, I support the motion enough is enough.

1727
02:58:23.910 --> 02:58:31.740
sean obrien: God, there was a I think 10 1020 years ago they're supposed to be a sting operation going on at a more of the state or federal level.

1728
02:58:32.640 --> 02:58:43.470
sean obrien: Because they know the bike rings, are they still the bikes up here and train them for the bikes up North So there are a lot harder to find but anyways I digress support the motion thanks guys.

1729
02:58:44.670 --> 02:58:46.920
james murez: And then we'll close public comment now.

1730
02:58:47.310 --> 02:58:51.990
james murez: Yes, and let's move on to committee common NICO go ahead, please.

1731
02:58:53.460 --> 02:59:01.620
Nico Ruderman: yeah hi um I actually had the same concern as as video when I first heard this I was happy to hear her say that.

1732
02:59:02.550 --> 02:59:06.420
Nico Ruderman: You know i'm curious and I don't know if Helen can address this or somebody else who was involved as.

1733
02:59:06.420 --> 02:59:12.660
Nico Ruderman: Much How does this affect laughs and the by SWIFT bike whisper, who is a fixture of our Community no quit.

1734
02:59:13.650 --> 02:59:20.970
Nico Ruderman: You know, I strongly support this except right, you know somebody like him who who does operate and the public, out of his band.

1735
02:59:21.420 --> 02:59:29.100
Nico Ruderman: near the awkward REC Center and around the Community i'm curious how this how this affects them because you know it would be unacceptable for it to negatively affect him.

1736
02:59:30.330 --> 02:59:31.320
Nico Ruderman: So I don't know if anybody can.

1737
02:59:31.410 --> 02:59:34.860
james murez: address that question, thank you NICO um.

1738
02:59:37.650 --> 02:59:44.430
james murez: i'm just I put the motion back up on the screen, because I hate to have taken my bicycle over to the nice man bye oh quick park.

1739
02:59:45.990 --> 02:59:55.770
james murez: And he seems to know what he's doing so, it says here, request the creation of a bicycle chop shop coordinates what Would he be considered a chop shop.

1740
02:59:56.940 --> 02:59:59.280
Soledad Ursua: Business per man, he is a illegal business so.

1741
02:59:59.940 --> 03:00:02.700
james murez: He is he has a business license.

1742
03:00:02.760 --> 03:00:03.960
Alley Bean: that's not a chop shop.

1743
03:00:04.080 --> 03:00:04.530
james murez: Yes.

1744
03:00:04.620 --> 03:00:11.790
james murez: How to chop shop, so I think that that would probably disqualify him from falling into a category with this.

1745
03:00:12.600 --> 03:00:16.470
Nico Ruderman: Right my my concern have been distribution of bicycles and bike parts on.

1746
03:00:16.920 --> 03:00:21.420
Nico Ruderman: yeah with the property or within public right away, which he operates on a sidewalk Nero Nero could park.

1747
03:00:21.720 --> 03:00:25.590
james murez: So what if what if we added to this without a business license.

1748
03:00:28.080 --> 03:00:36.780
james murez: I mean, do we think that that would address it, I kind of think it probably would I mean I don't know that it not be in there, but a chop shop is is not something that's they don't license.

1749
03:00:36.780 --> 03:00:37.620
Nico Ruderman: Child he.

1750
03:00:37.980 --> 03:00:41.790
Nico Ruderman: He doesn't operate a top shot by any means, but my only concern with that last sentence for him.

1751
03:00:42.540 --> 03:00:52.080
Alix: Let me Boucher food trucks have licenses So this was going to say you added in a license right like if he has a license and he's authorized operate.

1752
03:00:53.580 --> 03:00:54.270
Alix: wouldn't that.

1753
03:00:54.660 --> 03:01:03.030
james murez: I I personally do not see the issue and I guess the the way to deal with this would be let's get this the Community impact statement into the city.

1754
03:01:03.330 --> 03:01:12.780
james murez: So we're on file and as it goes through the process of being heard in Council and and elsewhere let's just make sure that we raise our hand and and say that.

1755
03:01:13.260 --> 03:01:21.030
james murez: You know, a licensed business that did I mean you know most on Lincoln he has his bicycles out on the sidewalk sometimes but he's a store.

1756
03:01:21.390 --> 03:01:26.520
Soledad Ursua: So I just looked up the Council file, it says all of that do you want me to share my screen, I can.

1757
03:01:26.580 --> 03:01:30.600
james murez: Sure, please, by all means, if that'll clarify it for everybody, because I think everybody has the same.

1758
03:01:31.980 --> 03:01:33.810
james murez: Go ahead just click share there you go.

1759
03:01:34.440 --> 03:01:35.490
Soledad Ursua: So you can.

1760
03:01:35.730 --> 03:01:40.290
james murez: enlarge out of can you zoom on that at all the way up to the right of 100% plus.

1761
03:01:42.030 --> 03:01:42.600
james murez: There you go.

1762
03:01:42.840 --> 03:01:43.140
Soledad Ursua: and

1763
03:01:43.770 --> 03:01:45.360
james murez: keep going keep keep going.

1764
03:01:48.900 --> 03:01:49.290
Soledad Ursua: Okay.

1765
03:01:49.350 --> 03:01:52.320
Soledad Ursua: So, like right here, we see that.

1766
03:01:53.670 --> 03:02:03.990
Soledad Ursua: there's exemptions for licensed businesses and for individuals, making repairs, so I mean he wouldn't fall under that category, this is really trying to address illicit activity.

1767
03:02:06.210 --> 03:02:07.320
Soledad Ursua: Thank you for sharing that.

1768
03:02:07.770 --> 03:02:09.990
Nico Ruderman: Thank you, thank you for the clarification great.

1769
03:02:13.320 --> 03:02:14.640
james murez: oops wrong wrong button.

1770
03:02:15.660 --> 03:02:18.420
james murez: Okay um let me get back to.

1771
03:02:19.530 --> 03:02:21.690
james murez: Wait Am I still sharing.

1772
03:02:23.490 --> 03:02:23.940
No.

1773
03:02:25.290 --> 03:02:27.840
james murez: disappeared on me okay so Andre go ahead.

1774
03:02:28.830 --> 03:02:36.600
Andrea Boccaletti: Had the very same concern the bicycle was for is amazing he's a great guy but if emotion needs to be made to.

1775
03:02:38.580 --> 03:02:42.690
Andrea Boccaletti: exclude people that have a license I would make that motion so.

1776
03:02:43.230 --> 03:02:54.270
james murez: And I think it's already there so we're good with them um if anybody else has comments about the same problem I think we've resolved so they could put their hands down Clark go ahead, please.

1777
03:02:54.450 --> 03:03:00.330
clark brown: I have a question in the comment but I hate to ask this question what is a car, yes, what is a Community impact statement.

1778
03:03:00.720 --> 03:03:08.880
james murez: Oh okay so you're new to the city count to the neighborhood Council process Community impact statement is is the one mechanism that we have.

1779
03:03:09.300 --> 03:03:20.520
james murez: To actually address the city Los Angeles city council with a written document that whenever there's a Council file that's open you go to the Clerk system, you can find a Council file.

1780
03:03:22.080 --> 03:03:28.440
james murez: If a neighborhood Council has taken an opinion on a particular Council file item that's open.

1781
03:03:29.160 --> 03:03:43.890
james murez: The Community impact statement is the one thing that neighborhood councils are allowed to do it's it's a process of attaching a written opinion about the Council file for the neighborhood Councils, so if you read.

1782
03:03:45.540 --> 03:03:49.170
james murez: Chapter nine of the of the reformed city charter.

1783
03:03:50.940 --> 03:04:05.640
james murez: It was reported in 2000 it would describe in there, that a Community impact statement is one of the things it's actually the only thing that we really have any controller power over it allows us to stick an opinion on to the Council bottle.

1784
03:04:06.930 --> 03:04:25.440
clark brown: thanks for the education, I also had had a comment on this this measure strikes me and says quite narrow it doesn't apply to all drop shops, it only applies to unlicensed chop shops which are conducting their business on public property and in the absence of the owner of the bike.

1785
03:04:26.790 --> 03:04:30.480
clark brown: I think it's a narrow measure that that's appropriate.

1786
03:04:32.580 --> 03:04:33.150
james murez: Thank you Clark.

1787
03:04:34.410 --> 03:04:35.400
james murez: Mike you have your hand up.

1788
03:04:36.120 --> 03:04:40.200
Mike Bravo: yeah I think it's it's still it's to arbitrary, you know, like is.

1789
03:04:41.400 --> 03:04:48.510
Mike Bravo: Going the boardwalk there's people hard working people who sell bike lights and help people to assemble their bikes and get them hooked up or whatever.

1790
03:04:48.840 --> 03:04:54.120
Mike Bravo: there's different types of business, not just you know the light people but it's people like that just good as good.

1791
03:04:55.020 --> 03:04:57.570
Mike Bravo: know just general people on the boardwalk down out whatever trying to.

1792
03:04:58.020 --> 03:05:06.300
Mike Bravo: hook people up, so I think it doesn't really define what a chop shop is, and I think we kind of know like there's some people certain spots it like yeah like okay.

1793
03:05:07.020 --> 03:05:14.940
Mike Bravo: that's no good but as people were like this can be enforced arbitrarily and that's something we need to consider that's it's some because, like if i'm.

1794
03:05:15.600 --> 03:05:22.200
Mike Bravo: At the boardwalk and i'm talking to someone, and you know, a certain authority figure doesn't care for me or things I say.

1795
03:05:22.620 --> 03:05:33.960
Mike Bravo: Then they can kind of give someone a hard time from hanging out with someone who's might be doing the lights are in helping me with my bike fix my wheels or something which I prefer to go to local people versus you know businesses.

1796
03:05:34.980 --> 03:05:37.620
Mike Bravo: Know storefront businesses, but just want to throw that out there.

1797
03:05:38.400 --> 03:05:40.110
james murez: Thank you, my vicki go ahead, please.

1798
03:05:41.040 --> 03:05:47.160
Vicki Halliday: i'm i'm having a hot I tend to agree with lydia and Mike both arm.

1799
03:05:48.840 --> 03:05:50.580
Vicki Halliday: It worries me that this.

1800
03:05:52.230 --> 03:06:01.020
Vicki Halliday: They could use this as a blanket thing I doubt that they would because chop shops, even the really illegal ones, have been really ignored.

1801
03:06:01.860 --> 03:06:17.880
Vicki Halliday: But I don't want to see the people get hurt that I know who repair bikes on the side and stuff like that lance being one but there's smaller ones, without trucks, to work out off that have helped me out from time to time and.

1802
03:06:20.880 --> 03:06:25.890
Vicki Halliday: The wording just bothers me so i'm not quite sure what to do about this, thank you.

1803
03:06:25.920 --> 03:06:27.510
james murez: Thank you Vicky what Stan go ahead.

1804
03:06:29.310 --> 03:06:31.710
Ansar Muhammad: I was just thinking with lydia spoke.

1805
03:06:32.790 --> 03:06:46.800
Ansar Muhammad: Last, as somebody i've been known for over 40 years and near 40 years and I would hate for emotion like this to impact his business I didn't read anything and emotion that indicated that the.

1806
03:06:47.820 --> 03:07:02.670
Ansar Muhammad: stolen bike so the the shops that got the bikes is connected to the encampments I don't know if we can get that added that you know, dealing with the homeless encampment that none of these.

1807
03:07:03.900 --> 03:07:16.080
Ansar Muhammad: outfits should be allowed there because when I walk around Venice that's what I see is most of the bikes is around the in kemet areas, and I would hate for this to him PAC man.

1808
03:07:18.180 --> 03:07:20.100
james murez: Thank you, Sam elite go ahead place.

1809
03:07:20.820 --> 03:07:31.530
Alix: So I agree with with vicki I think there could be some unintended consequences, and I think we have a really smart group of people here and to I think it was lisa's point.

1810
03:07:32.430 --> 03:07:41.010
Alix: And I am theory support some of this, but I think there's challenges and maybe because it's not pressing it should go back to a neighborhood committee.

1811
03:07:41.310 --> 03:07:49.920
Alix: And we can wordsmith some of this language and figure out how to make this a better motion that that doesn't potentially you know impact.

1812
03:07:50.280 --> 03:08:02.790
Alix: Members of the Community, that all of the draft and interface with, and this is from someone who's had a bike stolen right out of my my garage some a walk down the driveway so i'm empathetic to the problem with stolen bikes.

1813
03:08:03.870 --> 03:08:12.060
james murez: Thank you leaks solar day, did you happen to notice when you brought up that Council file if there was a date of when Council was going to be acting on it.

1814
03:08:12.960 --> 03:08:18.000
Soledad Ursua: Let me, let me share my screen with you guys um, I just wanted to point out, though, that it.

1815
03:08:18.510 --> 03:08:27.270
Soledad Ursua: On it does say that if the owner is there and it's their bike it's not an issue so we're saying that you know could have a wrong.

1816
03:08:27.690 --> 03:08:37.470
Soledad Ursua: consequence, so there is the exemption for licensed businesses and for individuals, making repairs or while present when repairs are being made to their own bicycles.

1817
03:08:37.860 --> 03:08:46.500
Soledad Ursua: um let's see but this Council with file size that let's see so it expires on so there's I guess some time.

1818
03:08:46.950 --> 03:08:58.920
Soledad Ursua: But maybe it'd be a good idea to send this motion out to everyone so that people can actually read this first instead of us, you know coming up with issues that we think will be applicable.

1819
03:09:00.600 --> 03:09:01.140
Thank you.

1820
03:09:02.250 --> 03:09:05.640
james murez: Thank you for bringing the screen up as well holly go ahead, please.

1821
03:09:05.970 --> 03:09:10.680
Alley Bean: Oh no I was just agreeing with basically everyone that that the wording has to be right.

1822
03:09:10.980 --> 03:09:11.400
james murez: Thank you.

1823
03:09:11.490 --> 03:09:13.230
james murez: i'm happy to go ahead, please.

1824
03:09:13.680 --> 03:09:20.250
Daffodil Tyminski: um I believe that there was a deadline and committee for this, which is why there were some urgency to.

1825
03:09:21.630 --> 03:09:38.340
Daffodil Tyminski: Have the board basically reaffirm its previous position taken a couple times over the years that there was a concern that this was going to Venice was one of the largest afflicted areas with this stolen bike chop shop issue, and this motion may go to committee without comment by Venice.

1826
03:09:39.480 --> 03:09:44.190
Daffodil Tyminski: um I don't have the dates off the top of my head, but sold out if you have it up there.

1827
03:09:44.880 --> 03:09:45.240
It says.

1828
03:09:47.010 --> 03:09:48.420
Soledad Ursua: Introduce was on.

1829
03:09:49.470 --> 03:09:51.420
Soledad Ursua: It was on October 5.

1830
03:09:52.170 --> 03:09:58.500
Soledad Ursua: I didn't look like there's any date I don't see anything that says when it will be heard, though i'm not sure.

1831
03:09:59.130 --> 03:10:04.110
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, I don't have the details of my head, but that that is why this was pressing.

1832
03:10:05.250 --> 03:10:06.630
Daffodil Tyminski: To get on this month's agenda.

1833
03:10:07.020 --> 03:10:07.530
james murez: Thank you.

1834
03:10:08.580 --> 03:10:11.580
james murez: I will just add my two cents and then, I guess, we should.

1835
03:10:12.630 --> 03:10:21.150
james murez: vote on it, my feeling is is that the police have plenty to do, and that I don't believe that they're just going to randomly pick on people.

1836
03:10:21.480 --> 03:10:25.590
james murez: That they don't like, for whatever reason, I mean I heard that comment I heard that.

1837
03:10:25.980 --> 03:10:33.030
james murez: You know they're going to go out and do terrible things to people that are running legitimate businesses I just don't think they have the time.

1838
03:10:33.540 --> 03:10:39.630
james murez: I don't think that they have the interest in doing that, I think that they're trying to help us and they're not trying to pick on people that.

1839
03:10:40.530 --> 03:10:58.050
james murez: Are following the rules so that that's my two cents, I mean i'm supporting the police, and I believe that they're doing a good job and and if there's a way that we can clean up the crime that's happening on our street with all of the stolen bicycles and clearly they are around the encampments.

1840
03:10:59.280 --> 03:11:01.920
james murez: I think if this if this upset that would be a good thing.

1841
03:11:03.000 --> 03:11:05.280
james murez: Having said that, Melissa let's take about.

1842
03:11:35.370 --> 03:11:35.850
james murez: Yes.

1843
03:11:37.110 --> 03:11:38.580
melissadiner: Yes, yes.

1844
03:11:42.810 --> 03:11:43.290
melissadiner: vicki.

1845
03:12:06.450 --> 03:12:06.840
Sima Kostovetsky: ya.

1846
03:12:08.280 --> 03:12:08.700
melissadiner: Ali.

1847
03:12:09.360 --> 03:12:09.960
No.

1848
03:12:17.550 --> 03:12:18.090
Chie Lunn: Yes.

1849
03:12:22.500 --> 03:12:23.070
melissadiner: Bravo.

1850
03:12:23.430 --> 03:12:23.820
No.

1851
03:12:26.430 --> 03:12:26.970
ElizabethClay: Yes.

1852
03:12:30.990 --> 03:12:31.650
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

1853
03:12:33.060 --> 03:12:33.360
jim robb: Oh.

1854
03:12:34.950 --> 03:12:36.450
melissadiner: i'm sorry it was difficult to hear you.

1855
03:12:38.730 --> 03:12:39.300
melissadiner: Go.

1856
03:12:42.000 --> 03:12:43.770
Nico Ruderman: Oh yes, park.

1857
03:12:46.530 --> 03:12:47.130
robertthibodeau: Yes.

1858
03:12:47.700 --> 03:12:48.180
melissadiner: or no.

1859
03:12:48.870 --> 03:12:49.140
No.

1860
03:12:57.120 --> 03:12:58.920
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes, cj.

1861
03:12:59.490 --> 03:13:00.960
melissadiner: Yes, Stan.

1862
03:13:02.280 --> 03:13:02.760
Ansar Muhammad: No.

1863
03:13:09.240 --> 03:13:11.190
Alix: leaks, can you change me to a no please.

1864
03:13:12.450 --> 03:13:12.810
melissadiner: yeah.

1865
03:13:32.280 --> 03:13:32.940
james murez: Thank you.

1866
03:13:34.920 --> 03:13:35.610
james murez: um.

1867
03:13:37.590 --> 03:13:40.050
james murez: So what happened to my agenda.

1868
03:13:42.180 --> 03:13:43.830
james murez: Somehow cost.

1869
03:13:47.820 --> 03:13:50.670
Sima Kostovetsky: I think Ben trying to get in with the animal.

1870
03:13:52.170 --> 03:13:55.470
Daffodil Tyminski: So we're on a 12 G, which is the.

1871
03:13:55.620 --> 03:13:56.250
yeah.

1872
03:13:58.680 --> 03:14:01.350
james murez: I just need to figure out how to get it back up on my screen.

1873
03:14:08.970 --> 03:14:10.770
james murez: Some reason the share isn't working.

1874
03:14:12.030 --> 03:14:13.830
Daffodil Tyminski: it's a short motion I can read it.

1875
03:14:13.950 --> 03:14:15.030
james murez: I got it I got it.

1876
03:14:16.560 --> 03:14:18.630
james murez: Okay, there we go Thank you sorry.

1877
03:14:20.250 --> 03:14:20.700
james murez: Go ahead.

1878
03:14:22.080 --> 03:14:31.980
Daffodil Tyminski: Sure um, so this is item 12 G, it is the motion that the President is an ex officio on committees i'm.

1879
03:14:34.470 --> 03:14:39.900
Daffodil Tyminski: The motion is that the dnc board shall create and you standing rule as follows colon.

1880
03:14:40.470 --> 03:14:51.960
Daffodil Tyminski: The President shall be an ex officio member of every committee, so long as in so being the president's membership does not conflict with the bylaws, for example, as it doesn't the case with the land use planning committee.

1881
03:14:54.000 --> 03:14:56.250
james murez: Thank you um can we get a second.

1882
03:15:01.710 --> 03:15:03.210
melissadiner: yeah all i'll second that Melissa.

1883
03:15:03.930 --> 03:15:06.420
james murez: Thank you um let's go to public comment.

1884
03:15:06.570 --> 03:15:11.160
CJ Cole: Is there a point where one would have an amendment be considered.

1885
03:15:12.270 --> 03:15:13.050
james murez: um.

1886
03:15:14.070 --> 03:15:16.320
james murez: Well, we could consider it now, if you want to, if you want to.

1887
03:15:17.640 --> 03:15:22.950
james murez: make an amendment to the motion we can certainly do it now, or we can wait until we have public comment that we have here public comment again.

1888
03:15:23.670 --> 03:15:26.250
CJ Cole: Okay i'll make my amendment motion.

1889
03:15:28.110 --> 03:15:40.590
CJ Cole: I wanna amended to say an ex officio Member shall not be counted toward establishing a committee colon and still not have a voting rights.

1890
03:15:42.480 --> 03:15:43.950
Alix: i'll second that cj.

1891
03:15:44.310 --> 03:15:44.580
OK.

1892
03:15:46.860 --> 03:15:59.850
james murez: OK, so now we're going to open public comment to the amendment, Melissa did you get the wording alone would be in the transcript or in the in the audio file so let's just go.

1893
03:15:59.910 --> 03:16:09.270
melissadiner: out, I mean it would be nice if she could write it out and put it on the screen, since that wasn't just like an edit of a couple words because i'm I want to make sure I understand it.

1894
03:16:09.510 --> 03:16:12.270
james murez: Okay, do you have it written out cj.

1895
03:16:13.110 --> 03:16:17.790
CJ Cole: yeah but it's it's an on my agenda.

1896
03:16:20.190 --> 03:16:21.900
james murez: Working on paper all right well.

1897
03:16:22.950 --> 03:16:23.100
james murez: We.

1898
03:16:23.670 --> 03:16:24.690
melissadiner: can read it again.

1899
03:16:25.110 --> 03:16:26.010
james murez: read it read it again.

1900
03:16:26.040 --> 03:16:29.190
james murez: cj more slowly, where you want to put in where okay.

1901
03:16:29.340 --> 03:16:39.960
CJ Cole: An ex officio Member shall not be counted toward establishing a committee quorum and shall not have a voting.

1902
03:16:45.810 --> 03:16:49.920
james murez: So it's an extra sentence basically yeah okay.

1903
03:16:57.840 --> 03:16:59.220
Daffodil Tyminski: Shall we take some public comment.

1904
03:16:59.490 --> 03:17:00.210
james murez: Yes, please.

1905
03:17:00.870 --> 03:17:05.790
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay i'm Sean o'brien why don't you go first.

1906
03:17:07.170 --> 03:17:09.150
james murez: Eric and more will be our last speaker.

1907
03:17:09.330 --> 03:17:12.120
sean obrien: i'm sorry I didn't know my hand was up alright.

1908
03:17:13.740 --> 03:17:19.590
Daffodil Tyminski: Alright, thanks Sean i'm Nick answered a shallow why don't you go next.

1909
03:17:23.040 --> 03:17:26.490
Nick Antonicello: yeah I support, I support the man, thank you.

1910
03:17:27.540 --> 03:17:28.140
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Nick.

1911
03:17:30.240 --> 03:17:30.870
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm.

1912
03:17:31.170 --> 03:17:32.400
Daffodil Tyminski: Telling fallon go ahead.

1913
03:17:34.320 --> 03:17:41.160
Helen Fallon: I support the amendment I think the language clarifies for everyone and the purpose of somebody serving as ex officio.

1914
03:17:41.460 --> 03:17:54.780
Helen Fallon: robert's rules specifically said they don't count for him, but there's ambiguity about whether they're voting or non voting and I don't think the intention here is to have extra physio voting on committees if that's the intention, then.

1915
03:17:56.280 --> 03:18:05.850
Helen Fallon: Then, frankly, you should go the whole thing you know um I think the I definitely support the amendment, and I think it clarifies everything and removes any ambiguity.

1916
03:18:07.770 --> 03:18:08.460
Thanks Alan.

1917
03:18:10.110 --> 03:18:12.000
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm Lisa redmond go ahead.

1918
03:18:13.650 --> 03:18:30.420
Lisa Redmond: yeah before I thought the motion was such a you know, whatever but cj excellent job at the amendment for clarifying it and articulating exactly how it should be and made it a very strong motion, so I very support the motion with the amendment, thank you.

1919
03:18:31.860 --> 03:18:36.390
Daffodil Tyminski: So much Lisa i'm Isabelle GVA go ahead.

1920
03:18:39.240 --> 03:18:48.960
Isabelle Duvivier: hi we have on bb committee, we have an ex officio Member who's very knowledgeable and.

1921
03:18:50.130 --> 03:18:57.150
Isabelle Duvivier: i'm not exactly sure where where this comes from, but i'm just saying I don't quite understand.

1922
03:18:58.440 --> 03:18:59.010
Isabelle Duvivier: Thank you.

1923
03:19:01.230 --> 03:19:03.990
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Erica more go ahead.

1924
03:19:06.390 --> 03:19:14.550
Erica Moore: hi um I I do agree also that cj is edit makes it makes sense, so I do support it with cj edit Thank you.

1925
03:19:15.570 --> 03:19:16.290
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Marco.

1926
03:19:17.490 --> 03:19:18.930
Daffodil Tyminski: I appreciate the brief comment, I think.

1927
03:19:19.020 --> 03:19:20.640
james murez: I think that's everyone now right.

1928
03:19:20.670 --> 03:19:21.480
Daffodil Tyminski: I think so.

1929
03:19:21.810 --> 03:19:25.770
james murez: Okay let's go back to the board comment, let me just make one quick comment.

1930
03:19:26.820 --> 03:19:43.860
james murez: Is a word committee Member i'm not necessarily going to vote on this one, because I think that would be perhaps a conflict of interest, but I did want to mention the issue of voting, the comment that was brought up that everybody should be aware of that, if if there is a.

1931
03:19:46.020 --> 03:19:48.570
james murez: A tide vote then.

1932
03:19:49.890 --> 03:19:57.120
james murez: There, there is sometimes a benefit to having the President, who is on the committee being able to break the tie.

1933
03:19:58.650 --> 03:20:10.260
james murez: And i'm not suggest i'm Actually, I guess, I should probably pass the gavel at this point, adaptable and let her finish conducting the the the meeting because I had spoken on this, but I will also recuse from voting, thank you.

1934
03:20:11.790 --> 03:20:13.680
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay i'm.

1935
03:20:15.030 --> 03:20:22.020
Daffodil Tyminski: So bored comment why don't we take that now Alex you have your hand up first why don't you go ahead first.

1936
03:20:28.020 --> 03:20:29.160
Daffodil Tyminski: I think you need to unmute.

1937
03:20:29.310 --> 03:20:36.540
Alix: Oh sorry sorry sorry got it i'm just to jim's comment, the committee's are all advisory so if it's a yay.

1938
03:20:36.570 --> 03:20:37.770
Bruno Hernandez: My understanding is.

1939
03:20:37.860 --> 03:20:40.650
Alix: If it sounds really good though or.

1940
03:20:40.680 --> 03:20:50.160
Alix: tie committee that i'll get to pass board where the board can weigh in so I don't necessarily think there needs to be anything to.

1941
03:20:51.330 --> 03:20:55.920
Alix: Have a tiebreaker at the committee level, and thank you cj for amending the most.

1942
03:20:59.460 --> 03:21:02.160
Daffodil Tyminski: awesome thanks leaks Sema go ahead.

1943
03:21:04.590 --> 03:21:08.040
Daffodil Tyminski: Oh sorry Mike I skipped you, but just seeing what you go and then making go.

1944
03:21:08.460 --> 03:21:14.490
Sima Kostovetsky: Okay, I just had a question like How does this change how we've been operating before because, for example.

1945
03:21:15.000 --> 03:21:19.410
Sima Kostovetsky: You know, even in the prior administration, the President was always ex officio but.

1946
03:21:19.680 --> 03:21:31.470
Sima Kostovetsky: The way that I understood it, they never had voting rights right so they're always welcome to the meeting, and it was up to them whether they would attend so i'm just wondering how is this different, especially with the amendment.

1947
03:21:36.600 --> 03:21:38.430
Daffodil Tyminski: TIM I think that's a question for you now that you.

1948
03:21:38.430 --> 03:21:39.270
Daffodil Tyminski: Post gavel.

1949
03:21:39.390 --> 03:21:40.200
james murez: I can answer.

1950
03:21:40.500 --> 03:21:42.030
Daffodil Tyminski: Why don't we wait till the end.

1951
03:21:42.330 --> 03:21:44.580
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay Mike bravo go ahead.

1952
03:21:47.430 --> 03:21:55.380
Mike Bravo: yeah I just wanna say I agree with the amendment, and this law new shifts and how we're doing things too so it's kind of hard to tell.

1953
03:21:56.190 --> 03:22:05.700
Mike Bravo: what the impact is intention is one thing, but in patches another, and I think the amendment clarifies things and, as we all know, if it's not in writing it doesn't exist so encourage.

1954
03:22:08.520 --> 03:22:09.180
This motion.

1955
03:22:11.190 --> 03:22:11.430
Thanks.

1956
03:22:12.480 --> 03:22:13.530
Daffodil Tyminski: So that go ahead.

1957
03:22:13.860 --> 03:22:23.520
Soledad Ursua: And I have the same exact question is Sema when I chaired the Public Health and Safety Committee, I always have the President as ex officio so I just yeah so exact same questions Sema.

1958
03:22:26.640 --> 03:22:27.660
james murez: Okay answer.

1959
03:22:28.050 --> 03:22:33.480
Daffodil Tyminski: Oh yeah there's no other, as you know, their hands Jim why don't you go ahead and address the emotion and what the issue is.

1960
03:22:33.570 --> 03:22:55.020
james murez: So the the issue came up at the beginning of my term as President, the template that we were using in previous years, always had ex officio listed as IRA and it was it was on there, and when we went looking through the standing rules in the bylaws it was never defined.

1961
03:22:56.100 --> 03:23:08.040
james murez: There was no definition of where the ex officio got to participate and didn't and in some of the committee's it was being included.

1962
03:23:08.580 --> 03:23:21.960
james murez: And subcommittees it wasn't, and this was just an issue of let's clarify it let's let's let's make it clear, because we want to move forward, we want to try and clean up the standing roles in the bylaws and get things.

1963
03:23:22.800 --> 03:23:35.490
james murez: To be in sync I believe that i've been said that in previous bylaws and previous standing rules has it always been in there, and he didn't know what it happened to it and we didn't have copies of the previous.

1964
03:23:35.610 --> 03:23:39.750
james murez: By scanning rules to show that it had been so it was just like let's put it back in.

1965
03:23:45.960 --> 03:23:50.610
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, so why don't we call a vote on the motion as amended.

1966
03:23:55.230 --> 03:23:58.440
Mike Bravo: A real quick to is it typed up, so the public can see it.

1967
03:23:59.100 --> 03:24:02.550
Daffodil Tyminski: Does a great point Melissa do you have a typed up.

1968
03:24:10.290 --> 03:24:13.200
Daffodil Tyminski: um wait i'm looking here, we may have.

1969
03:24:14.670 --> 03:24:16.350
Daffodil Tyminski: lost Melissa perhaps.

1970
03:24:16.860 --> 03:24:17.280
Really.

1971
03:24:19.230 --> 03:24:20.580
Soledad Ursua: isn't attention attendee now.

1972
03:24:20.970 --> 03:24:22.170
Daffodil Tyminski: Oh sorry.

1973
03:24:22.230 --> 03:24:26.310
Daffodil Tyminski: zoom balance you out I apologize hold on a SEC masa.

1974
03:24:26.940 --> 03:24:28.710
james murez: I just did okay.

1975
03:24:34.860 --> 03:24:35.640
Daffodil Tyminski: There, she is.

1976
03:24:48.570 --> 03:24:51.600
Daffodil Tyminski: Melissa can you unmute and show us what the languages.

1977
03:24:55.080 --> 03:25:03.420
melissadiner: yeah I can I i'm not gonna I don't know how to screen share and my computer just died, which is why I got kicked out but i'll happily read it again.

1978
03:25:03.810 --> 03:25:14.490
melissadiner: Because DJ couldn't say the amendment on her screen that she had so the amendment is shall not be counted toward establishing a committee quorum and shall not have a voting right and that.

1979
03:25:14.910 --> 03:25:31.500
melissadiner: Only changes if you read it from the beginning, it is the board shock create a new standing rule as follows the President will be an ex officio Member and shall not be counted towards establishing a committee quorum and shall not have a voting right that crack cj.

1980
03:25:31.980 --> 03:25:32.370
know.

1981
03:25:34.680 --> 03:25:35.910
james murez: Ali, do you ever typed out.

1982
03:25:36.390 --> 03:25:39.360
Alley Bean: No, no, no, but she left out the part of the loop back.

1983
03:25:40.500 --> 03:25:41.580
melissadiner: There was nothing.

1984
03:25:41.640 --> 03:25:42.900
melissadiner: having to do with Luca.

1985
03:25:43.200 --> 03:25:50.640
Alley Bean: You know it's only emotion and Melissa it's important the original writing, and she just added a sentence at the end.

1986
03:25:52.110 --> 03:25:52.440
Alley Bean: Right.

1987
03:25:52.500 --> 03:25:53.280
melissadiner: we're ej.

1988
03:25:53.370 --> 03:26:03.240
melissadiner: Can you clarify, since it was your amendment because that's what I was told when when you read it so maybe cj I didn't read the whole thing can you read it all cj.

1989
03:26:08.910 --> 03:26:10.080
james murez: gj can you unmute.

1990
03:26:13.980 --> 03:26:25.110
CJ Cole: I was gonna leave the motion as is and then just have one more sentence after it, which i'm I can see if I can put it up i've never.

1991
03:26:25.320 --> 03:26:37.710
melissadiner: Know that's fine if that's what it was that's not, I believe, how you read it, I bet I thought you read it up after ex officio Member So if you wanted at the end great so then it's the board shall create a new standing rule as far as.

1992
03:26:38.100 --> 03:26:42.570
melissadiner: The president's will be an ex officio member of every committee, so long as.

1993
03:26:43.350 --> 03:26:55.920
melissadiner: In so being the president's membership does not conflict with the bylaws, for example, as it does not, in the case of land use and planning committee and shall not be counted towards establishing a committee quorum and shall not have a voting right.

1994
03:26:58.710 --> 03:26:59.730
james murez: Is that correct cj.

1995
03:27:00.210 --> 03:27:02.670
CJ Cole: yeah I was just trying i've never shared.

1996
03:27:04.560 --> 03:27:06.870
CJ Cole: yeah Okay, well, I was trying to put it up, but.

1997
03:27:07.410 --> 03:27:10.350
melissadiner: Well that's much clearer anyways if it just goes at that.

1998
03:27:10.410 --> 03:27:12.240
CJ Cole: So it's super sorry.

1999
03:27:15.720 --> 03:27:18.960
melissadiner: Does anyone have need further clarification on that.

2000
03:27:20.220 --> 03:27:29.880
Alley Bean: um you just read it wrong as all Melissa but it's what it's how it's written is right, you said, as it does not, in the case but it reads as it does in the case with but that's written.

2001
03:27:39.690 --> 03:27:41.100
melissadiner: Close so what am I doing now.

2002
03:27:42.420 --> 03:27:43.650
melissadiner: Gemini taking about.

2003
03:27:45.270 --> 03:27:46.680
Daffodil Tyminski: It is why we call the vote.

2004
03:27:46.950 --> 03:27:49.620
james murez: yeah daffodil your, you have the gavel.

2005
03:27:49.830 --> 03:27:59.670
james murez: yeah and you're only calling the vote on the amenity motion around the only on the amendment, not on the original motion.

2006
03:28:00.150 --> 03:28:05.460
Daffodil Tyminski: Right so Melissa let's call the vote for the motion on as amended.

2007
03:28:06.570 --> 03:28:11.970
james murez: Know that's your only calling the vote for the amendment of the motion.

2008
03:28:12.990 --> 03:28:16.440
james murez: Not the Amended motion just the amendment to the motion.

2009
03:28:19.080 --> 03:28:22.920
Daffodil Tyminski: So let's call the vote on the amendments to the motion call.

2010
03:28:23.190 --> 03:28:23.820
melissadiner: that's it oh.

2011
03:28:24.240 --> 03:28:24.840
Daffodil Tyminski: Yes.

2012
03:28:25.350 --> 03:28:27.000
melissadiner: I will, yes leaks.

2013
03:28:28.620 --> 03:28:28.920
Alix: Yes.

2014
03:28:30.090 --> 03:28:30.870
melissadiner: Thank you.

2015
03:28:31.140 --> 03:28:31.560
Yes.

2016
03:28:33.090 --> 03:28:33.630
Sima Kostovetsky: Yes.

2017
03:28:34.170 --> 03:28:35.370
Alley Bean: Ali yes.

2018
03:28:35.760 --> 03:28:36.180
hi.

2019
03:28:39.690 --> 03:28:41.730
Mike Bravo: Mike yes.

2020
03:28:43.350 --> 03:28:43.860
ElizabethClay: Yes.

2021
03:28:45.390 --> 03:28:45.930
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

2022
03:28:47.220 --> 03:28:47.730
jim robb: Yes.

2023
03:28:48.360 --> 03:28:48.870
melissadiner: me go.

2024
03:28:49.890 --> 03:28:50.400
Nico Ruderman: Yes.

2025
03:28:51.420 --> 03:28:52.050
clark brown: Yes.

2026
03:28:54.840 --> 03:28:55.380
robertthibodeau: Yes.

2027
03:28:55.920 --> 03:28:57.510
Bruno Hernandez: or no yes.

2028
03:28:59.010 --> 03:28:59.460
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes.

2029
03:28:59.910 --> 03:29:01.590
Ansar Muhammad: cj yes.

2030
03:29:02.070 --> 03:29:04.860
Ansar Muhammad: And yes, okay.

2031
03:29:04.950 --> 03:29:06.840
melissadiner: So 01.

2032
03:29:09.300 --> 03:29:09.510
james murez: and

2033
03:29:10.050 --> 03:29:11.640
james murez: Now yeah go ahead i'm sorry.

2034
03:29:11.970 --> 03:29:15.210
Daffodil Tyminski: Oh, so now we're going to take a vote on the emotion, as amended.

2035
03:29:18.390 --> 03:29:18.840
Daffodil Tyminski: So we have.

2036
03:29:20.370 --> 03:29:25.410
melissadiner: To, we need to redo it if anyone's not changing their vote or do you want me to just do it like.

2037
03:29:25.410 --> 03:29:30.810
Daffodil Tyminski: I do think we need a separate roll call vote and I would read the motion again.

2038
03:29:31.500 --> 03:29:33.480
james murez: You also have public comment on.

2039
03:29:33.540 --> 03:29:35.040
Daffodil Tyminski: I know i'm getting there.

2040
03:29:35.190 --> 03:29:35.820
james murez: Okay sorry.

2041
03:29:36.210 --> 03:29:40.710
Daffodil Tyminski: um so Melissa why don't you read the motion as amended.

2042
03:29:43.980 --> 03:29:50.400
melissadiner: emotion, as amended, again, is the board shove, create a new standing rule as follows.

2043
03:29:50.730 --> 03:29:59.280
melissadiner: The Presidents will be an ex officio member of every committee, so long as in so being the president's membership does not conflict with the bylaws.

2044
03:29:59.700 --> 03:30:09.570
melissadiner: For example, as it does in the case with land do some planning committee and shall not be counted towards establishing a committee quorum and shall not have a voting right.

2045
03:30:10.770 --> 03:30:16.440
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, so let's go to public comment um let's try to keep it under a minute so I don't have to be an octopus.

2046
03:30:16.440 --> 03:30:17.880
CJ Cole: And that is three things at once.

2047
03:30:18.090 --> 03:30:19.170
CJ Cole: Lisa why don't you go first.

2048
03:30:19.620 --> 03:30:21.060
Daffodil Tyminski: And Margaret will stop with you.

2049
03:30:22.380 --> 03:30:22.740
Daffodil Tyminski: guys.

2050
03:30:23.760 --> 03:30:26.040
Lisa Redmond: As much as I amendment.

2051
03:30:26.790 --> 03:30:27.810
Lisa Redmond: i'm just going to point out.

2052
03:30:27.930 --> 03:30:31.200
Lisa Redmond: Point of order you guys need to figure out a way to type that on the screen.

2053
03:30:31.620 --> 03:30:44.460
Lisa Redmond: And I was at the del rey neighborhood Council the other night they're managed to type their amendments onto the screen so voting on an amendment, where the public can't review it and see it as Britain technically makes this boat illegal.

2054
03:30:45.360 --> 03:30:45.840
So.

2055
03:30:47.310 --> 03:30:53.250
Lisa Redmond: that's i'm just putting that out there, but I agree with the amendment do what you're going to do, and yes, I know your volunteer.

2056
03:30:54.510 --> 03:30:58.560
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks Lisa i'm Nick go ahead, your next.

2057
03:31:00.120 --> 03:31:08.280
Nick Antonicello: One day, I was going to point out, this is a standing room with vision, if this was a bylaws of is needed, two thirds vote the other problem is is that.

2058
03:31:09.000 --> 03:31:21.540
Nick Antonicello: Your past President has served as an ex officio Member Mike knew her service served as an ex officio Member when the luck serve as an ex officio Member and that hasn't been addressed you may need to trust that moving forward.

2059
03:31:23.820 --> 03:31:26.310
Nick Antonicello: In terms of IRA being with an ex officio Member.

2060
03:31:27.330 --> 03:31:28.080
Daffodil Tyminski: Alright, thanks.

2061
03:31:30.330 --> 03:31:32.100
Daffodil Tyminski: Margaret go ahead you're the last one.

2062
03:31:39.000 --> 03:31:39.510
Daffodil Tyminski: Margaret.

2063
03:31:48.030 --> 03:31:49.140
Daffodil Tyminski: Margaret you have a comment.

2064
03:31:55.230 --> 03:32:00.270
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay here's margaret's not here i'm sorry Lisa you also have your hand up go ahead.

2065
03:32:02.250 --> 03:32:03.000
Lisa Redmond: I already spoke.

2066
03:32:03.480 --> 03:32:06.600
Daffodil Tyminski: Oh, you did okay alright so we're gonna close public comment.

2067
03:32:08.340 --> 03:32:11.940
Daffodil Tyminski: board the board comment anyone got their hand up.

2068
03:32:14.910 --> 03:32:18.090
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm seeing no hands, Melissa why don't you call the vote.

2069
03:32:19.350 --> 03:32:21.060
melissadiner: And can I just make one comment.

2070
03:32:23.040 --> 03:32:36.840
melissadiner: So I would happily put it up on the screen moving forward, but I also think like become for transparency for everyone and to make my job easier, so I we don't have to repeat it five times.

2071
03:32:37.170 --> 03:32:45.300
melissadiner: Moving forward why don't you just bring your emotion written out like people have done, I think that's super helpful, then people can throw it up on the screen.

2072
03:32:45.690 --> 03:33:01.530
melissadiner: And then we don't have to like worry about it, I would just ask all board members if you're going to make an amendment or an adjustment type it out and send it to us, so we can put it up or better yet like you just put it up, so we can see it, and now i'll take a roll call but.

2073
03:33:04.410 --> 03:33:04.710
Daffodil Tyminski: God.

2074
03:33:06.630 --> 03:33:07.230
melissadiner: damn it oh.

2075
03:33:07.890 --> 03:33:09.630
melissadiner: Yes, I vote.

2076
03:33:11.250 --> 03:33:12.330
melissadiner: Yes, leaks.

2077
03:33:12.570 --> 03:33:14.760
melissadiner: Yes, vicki yes.

2078
03:33:18.330 --> 03:33:18.900
Sima Kostovetsky: Yes.

2079
03:33:19.560 --> 03:33:20.790
Alley Bean: Ali yes.

2080
03:33:21.360 --> 03:33:23.070
Chie Lunn: hi Epstein.

2081
03:33:26.190 --> 03:33:27.030
melissadiner: Like bravo.

2082
03:33:27.480 --> 03:33:28.110
Yes.

2083
03:33:30.990 --> 03:33:31.830
melissadiner: let's play.

2084
03:33:32.580 --> 03:33:33.270
Yes.

2085
03:33:38.250 --> 03:33:38.730
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

2086
03:33:39.660 --> 03:33:40.050
James.

2087
03:33:44.460 --> 03:33:44.910
Nico Ruderman: Yes.

2088
03:33:45.240 --> 03:33:46.650
clark brown: Clark yes.

2089
03:33:48.360 --> 03:33:48.870
robertthibodeau: Yes.

2090
03:33:49.110 --> 03:33:49.650
For now.

2091
03:33:52.290 --> 03:33:52.710
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes.

2092
03:33:53.190 --> 03:33:54.780
CJ Cole: DJ yes.

2093
03:33:55.410 --> 03:33:55.890
Stan.

2094
03:34:00.390 --> 03:34:00.960
melissadiner: Stan.

2095
03:34:04.410 --> 03:34:04.920
melissadiner: See here.

2096
03:34:06.810 --> 03:34:07.680
Daffodil Tyminski: um he.

2097
03:34:09.360 --> 03:34:09.960
Daffodil Tyminski: here.

2098
03:34:10.440 --> 03:34:11.940
james murez: He was here, he left.

2099
03:34:13.980 --> 03:34:16.770
Daffodil Tyminski: So so so check the zoom to see what he dropped.

2100
03:34:16.770 --> 03:34:17.070
Daffodil Tyminski: out.

2101
03:34:17.820 --> 03:34:22.950
melissadiner: He was 1616 or 16 to 16 02.

2102
03:34:23.310 --> 03:34:27.780
james murez: He texted me that he had to leave at 930 earlier in the meeting.

2103
03:34:28.140 --> 03:34:28.890
Daffodil Tyminski: Ah, OK.

2104
03:34:34.740 --> 03:34:35.370
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay.

2105
03:34:35.610 --> 03:34:38.070
Daffodil Tyminski: So, moving right along let's pass the gavel back to.

2106
03:34:38.070 --> 03:34:39.570
james murez: Jim Thank you.

2107
03:34:39.600 --> 03:34:42.000
Daffodil Tyminski: Dan why don't you take 12 ah.

2108
03:34:43.050 --> 03:34:44.580
Daffodil Tyminski: i'll read the motion if you'd like.

2109
03:34:45.240 --> 03:34:46.650
james murez: Yes, please make a motion.

2110
03:34:47.640 --> 03:35:03.330
Daffodil Tyminski: 12 he is regarding joint meetings between committees and the dnc and the motion is the board shall approve the following addition to the standing rules colon all committee meeting Shelby agenda is is joint meetings between the committee and the dnc Board of officers.

2111
03:35:04.680 --> 03:35:05.430
james murez: right here a second.

2112
03:35:06.330 --> 03:35:06.780
Second.

2113
03:35:07.980 --> 03:35:08.130
james murez: Jeff.

2114
03:35:08.880 --> 03:35:13.440
james murez: Clark Thank you Clark um let's go to public comment.

2115
03:35:15.600 --> 03:35:18.060
Daffodil Tyminski: Like we've got one hand up Helen go ahead.

2116
03:35:20.910 --> 03:35:33.780
Helen Fallon: I just want to clarify that the reason to have a joint meeting with a committee is solely to deal with the issue of cereal meetings and the possibility that you might have a quorum of corn.

2117
03:35:34.830 --> 03:35:40.860
Helen Fallon: According to done maybe they don't know what they're talking about, but in their training they say that.

2118
03:35:41.220 --> 03:35:47.730
Helen Fallon: When board members go to a committee they're not there to weigh in on things they're not there to lobby the committee.

2119
03:35:48.030 --> 03:35:52.950
Helen Fallon: And not there to comment they're there to gather information to find out how the stakeholders about things.

2120
03:35:53.310 --> 03:36:01.650
Helen Fallon: And I think that needs to be clarified in the Standing rule, this is not an opportunity for the dnc board officers to show up and make.

2121
03:36:02.220 --> 03:36:14.430
Helen Fallon: and try and sway the votes of committee members and weigh in on things and basically show in advance how they what their position is that's not your job you're supposed to wait until you hear all the stakeholder comments.

2122
03:36:15.510 --> 03:36:22.620
Helen Fallon: So I think this is a very poorly written standing rule that needs to be explained further you're going to just have a lot of brown act violation.

2123
03:36:24.150 --> 03:36:24.840
Daffodil Tyminski: Thanks on.

2124
03:36:26.490 --> 03:36:30.750
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay board anyone's got anyone has their hand up on this.

2125
03:36:31.410 --> 03:36:33.330
james murez: leaks has her hand up alico head.

2126
03:36:34.710 --> 03:36:41.310
Alix: So I know there hasn't been a lot of public comment i'm highly opposed to this motion for a variety of reasons, number one.

2127
03:36:41.640 --> 03:36:55.320
Alix: All committee chairs should have the at their discretion whether this is a joint meeting or not a joint meeting, and you know to that to Helens point about board members not supposed to to be.

2128
03:36:56.760 --> 03:37:01.800
Alix: You know, speaking up and board meetings you know, there is something or in committee meetings, there is something to be said for that.

2129
03:37:03.420 --> 03:37:11.820
Alix: If you don't have a joint meeting, and there are more than five board members in a committee meeting that just means the board members have to stay silent and they should listen.

2130
03:37:13.770 --> 03:37:20.190
Alix: And in the case of Lou pack where you know we have specific bylaws where we don't want more than one board member.

2131
03:37:21.510 --> 03:37:31.650
Alix: On the on the loop at committee, I think it would be highly irresponsible to encourage you know constant joint meetings at the very least, with Lou peck and the board.

2132
03:37:32.010 --> 03:37:42.000
Alix: But I don't support this motion for a variety of reasons and mostly because I feel that committee should operate with their own degree of autonomy and it should be at their discretion.

2133
03:37:44.700 --> 03:37:46.560
james murez: Thank you, Robert go ahead.

2134
03:37:49.350 --> 03:37:58.710
robertthibodeau: um you guys wrote this for a reason, could we get an explanation on this this housekeeping I mean, I get the feeling you guys went through and did some housekeeping on the.

2135
03:37:59.550 --> 03:38:09.390
robertthibodeau: On the standing rules and that's where these these three or four items or whatever we're voting on are coming from, but these were things that needed to be cleaned up in the House.

2136
03:38:09.390 --> 03:38:21.750
robertthibodeau: Rules Could somebody who put this forward, because you guys voted on this could someone explain explain what this is procedurally because it doesn't mean much I think most of us.

2137
03:38:21.900 --> 03:38:33.630
james murez: So I think the leaks touched on it slightly that if more than five board members show up at a committee meeting the board members must remain silent.

2138
03:38:34.140 --> 03:38:45.330
james murez: The problem with that is is that when you have a project for instance the monster on the median more than five board members live within 500 feet.

2139
03:38:45.780 --> 03:38:58.410
james murez: of that project because it's so large and they have to all recuse themselves when the item gets before the board, because on the board they're a member of the decision making body.

2140
03:38:59.370 --> 03:39:04.830
james murez: When you're a member of the decision making body, the city says, if you live within 500 feet you can't be on there.

2141
03:39:05.940 --> 03:39:26.580
james murez: When the when the project goes before Lou Pack, for instance in this example, the issue is the board members are not members of the lupus committee they're not the ones making the decision, but they can still be able to speak out about their opinion of the project.

2142
03:39:27.720 --> 03:39:34.020
james murez: If they live within 500 feet, because they're not on the decision making body or its new Pack is making the decision.

2143
03:39:34.290 --> 03:39:41.310
james murez: they're not taking a voting position they're just going to voice their opinion does they were they were a member of the general public, they would get a minute or whatever.

2144
03:39:41.820 --> 03:39:48.900
james murez: leaked would feel it was appropriate to have people speaking so it gives them the opportunity that's the primary thrust behind this.

2145
03:39:49.200 --> 03:39:50.610
james murez: So it's a.

2146
03:39:50.670 --> 03:39:58.920
james murez: All the committee's have I mean the scooters on ocean front walk if you live within 500 feet of a scooter I mean within 500 feet of an ocean front.

2147
03:39:59.190 --> 03:40:10.770
james murez: Of ocean from walking there's an agenda item that comes up and you want to be able to speak about it, you go to the meeting you can't speak out about it, and if there's more than five board members so it'd be a violation of the brown at that point.

2148
03:40:11.160 --> 03:40:15.690
Alix: So, Jim just to really clarify my point because you're right, I did speak to part of that but.

2149
03:40:16.260 --> 03:40:28.380
Alix: You know I can speak as a loop picture, when I have big important items that I know, everybody in the Committee on the Community is going to want to weigh in on and make those meetings joint, but that should really be at the chairs.

2150
03:40:29.070 --> 03:40:43.410
Alix: discretion and I think most tears would act that way, I had a meeting last week that was a joint meeting that was a that that our city planner was supposed to come in and she couldn't make it was a joint meeting because I figured board members would want to show up.

2151
03:40:43.650 --> 03:40:56.910
james murez: A week I don't want to get into a debate with you, but I have been to at least two meetings where you were chair at the oakwood REC Center back in 2018 and 2019 where members of the board had to leave the room.

2152
03:40:57.810 --> 03:41:13.470
james murez: Because it was not a joint meeting this just makes it clear, it makes it a normal operating procedure thing normally it won't come up if it's a big issue and five, more than five Members show up it's a cover deal and and that's what this is doing this is Jay.

2153
03:41:13.680 --> 03:41:15.600
james murez: can get out of me that.

2154
03:41:15.660 --> 03:41:16.110
Alix: we've made it.

2155
03:41:16.170 --> 03:41:25.080
james murez: Very difficult for any any chair and i'm not picking on you, by any means that it's very difficult for the Chair to know when more than five people are going to show up.

2156
03:41:25.740 --> 03:41:38.040
james murez: you're just speculating that this is one that they're going to show up for and it's unfair to those people that they didn't get the opportunity to speak so that was the thrust behind anyway let's let's finish up public comment might go ahead, please.

2157
03:41:38.850 --> 03:41:44.700
Mike Bravo: yeah i'm just wondering what the negative aspects of it are league said to as far as.

2158
03:41:46.020 --> 03:41:56.610
Mike Bravo: Keeping autonomy for the committee's which I definitely agree with, but the same time to I know it's in the past, I thought that know sometimes people pop up to people's meetings, specifically, to get them.

2159
03:41:57.870 --> 03:42:03.120
Mike Bravo: You know, make it like a you know, a brown bag violation because it's not join me in or what have you too, so.

2160
03:42:03.930 --> 03:42:16.170
Mike Bravo: Aside from the autonomy factor like what would be the main negative aspect of having like an automatic joint meeting because, like you, don't know and 10 people from the you know the board, are going to pop up.

2161
03:42:16.740 --> 03:42:18.660
james murez: yeah there doesn't seem to be any Thank you Mike.

2162
03:42:19.740 --> 03:42:21.540
james murez: Clark go ahead, please, to give.

2163
03:42:21.810 --> 03:42:22.590
james murez: up again but.

2164
03:42:23.340 --> 03:42:27.720
clark brown: there's a question is the primary benefit of this proposal that.

2165
03:42:31.710 --> 03:42:39.420
clark brown: It makes it more likely that you will have a quorum, because if a if a board member shows up they count as a committee.

2166
03:42:39.480 --> 03:42:43.020
james murez: Is that no no it's absolutely incorrect.

2167
03:42:43.290 --> 03:42:53.100
james murez: Okay, a joint meeting only means that that the second committee can be there we've had many joint meetings we had a joint meeting when the.

2168
03:42:55.350 --> 03:43:01.290
james murez: median project was being proposed, where we had three committees, all in the room, at the same time, and it was a joint three way meeting.

2169
03:43:02.610 --> 03:43:08.190
james murez: we've done many joint meetings of different of different types, but this is just strictly because.

2170
03:43:08.520 --> 03:43:19.080
james murez: You know if you specify who the joint Members are yeah if you had a quorum of the board the board could make its own motion and take its own decision if it had been agenda eyes.

2171
03:43:20.040 --> 03:43:27.810
james murez: that's true you could do that but that's never come up where you would have 11 board members show up to a committee meeting.

2172
03:43:28.590 --> 03:43:46.080
james murez: And also have recognized their motion on the floor, and it was on the agenda and the committee also had their motion, so it was two separate motions and then they both walked away with separate motions that's never come up I can't imagine it happened, but it's possible I guess.

2173
03:43:48.240 --> 03:43:49.770
james murez: Okay i'm soda go ahead.

2174
03:43:50.250 --> 03:43:56.280
Soledad Ursua: It just wanted to clarify to everyone that when I chair the Public Health and Safety Committee, I always made them joint.

2175
03:43:56.700 --> 03:44:07.290
Soledad Ursua: meetings with the full neighborhood Council board I just I think I was the latest chair to be you know, to take over committee, so I just kind of follow all the rules, given or just the suggestions given to me.

2176
03:44:07.590 --> 03:44:15.660
Soledad Ursua: And when other board members came, I did not treat them like members of my committee, they were members of the public, and even if 10 board members join.

2177
03:44:15.960 --> 03:44:26.760
Soledad Ursua: They could just comment as the public me I didn't have them on, so I think this is a lot of these election things you know we're clearing up some of our bylaws but it's just not very clear.

2178
03:44:27.210 --> 03:44:33.690
Soledad Ursua: And maybe for some other stuff you could explain this more, but I think what it's just saying is that we just so we just don't run a quorum issues.

2179
03:44:34.200 --> 03:44:42.270
Soledad Ursua: That, if you show up you're not considered a voting Member or member of the committee, you can just comment as public comments just as anybody should.

2180
03:44:43.020 --> 03:44:49.620
james murez: You that your understanding is correct, do we have any other hands up I don't think so alley go ahead.

2181
03:44:49.980 --> 03:45:06.750
Alley Bean: um, I just wanted to make sure that I understand so it's for you this is emotion that all meetings or joint meetings all committee meetings or joint meetings and it doesn't give the Chair any discretion to have just their committee meet.

2182
03:45:08.040 --> 03:45:09.600
Alley Bean: As a non enjoyed meeting.

2183
03:45:09.990 --> 03:45:19.320
james murez: Now I think solid dad explained it more correctly you're still going to conduct your meeting just like you always did, because this is how meetings, all of the meetings have always been conducted this way.

2184
03:45:19.590 --> 03:45:21.000
Alley Bean: they've always been joint meetings.

2185
03:45:21.060 --> 03:45:33.300
james murez: They are almost all meetings have been joined the have been joined meetings it's only one one committee that has not made to join meetings and it's only been a problem in that one committee, where more than five people have shown up.

2186
03:45:35.190 --> 03:45:37.260
Alley Bean: And there's that loop back yep okay.

2187
03:45:39.090 --> 03:45:46.140
james murez: And it happened when the median project is being discussed, I mean it's happened before, anyway, we don't need to get into all of that.

2188
03:45:46.800 --> 03:45:51.210
Alix: happened on the median project, it was a joint meeting then jump okay sorry.

2189
03:45:51.960 --> 03:45:53.910
james murez: davidow go ahead, please your last speaker.

2190
03:45:54.330 --> 03:46:06.270
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm just saying, I agree with this idea that if there's a need to have a joint meeting we have it, but otherwise I just don't like the idea that every I mean to me it's pointless to have committees if everything's going to be joined committee with the board.

2191
03:46:07.590 --> 03:46:19.800
Daffodil Tyminski: I don't I have never understood this i've tried to understand it i've tried to get explanations, the idea that it just lets other people attend doesn't make sense to me that's my two cents.

2192
03:46:20.400 --> 03:46:21.660
james murez: Okay NICO go ahead, please.

2193
03:46:24.720 --> 03:46:37.860
Nico Ruderman: yeah I mean, I think you know us us says board members, even if we show up as members of public you know our our our voices carry a little more weight and I, so I don't know I think there's an issue with that.

2194
03:46:41.310 --> 03:46:42.870
james murez: Okay, thank you see my go ahead.

2195
03:46:45.990 --> 03:46:57.000
Sima Kostovetsky: i'd like to kind of second and third some of our views already expressed in that I think it's important that our committees are the backbone of neighborhood Councils, and I think it's important for them to be autonomous.

2196
03:47:00.930 --> 03:47:03.810
james murez: Okay, no more hands let's take a boat Melissa.

2197
03:47:08.700 --> 03:47:10.800
james murez: Smaller system here I don't see her.

2198
03:47:12.150 --> 03:47:12.750
Let me looking.

2199
03:47:15.420 --> 03:47:15.870
Andrea Boccaletti: Back in.

2200
03:47:17.550 --> 03:47:18.720
james murez: yeah I got a Finder.

2201
03:47:19.140 --> 03:47:20.760
Daffodil Tyminski: piece here I got her okay.

2202
03:47:28.560 --> 03:47:31.560
Daffodil Tyminski: Unless we're trying to promote you panelists, but you can go ahead and talk.

2203
03:47:33.540 --> 03:47:34.800
melissadiner: Can I say something.

2204
03:47:35.250 --> 03:47:43.560
melissadiner: Yes, yeah these were these things have come up almost never in 10 years and I honestly think that.

2205
03:47:44.040 --> 03:47:52.050
melissadiner: The last one, and this one it's all about participation, you know, like it's letting everyone participate, so I think it's strange.

2206
03:47:52.350 --> 03:48:01.080
melissadiner: That it's being perceived otherwise like, even though it doesn't maybe doesn't make sense to deaths point like these, this is the way it's always been explained to me so like.

2207
03:48:01.470 --> 03:48:08.100
melissadiner: If you go to a meeting and five of you are there, like go ahead and speak i'm not going to file a grievance but if whoever.

2208
03:48:08.460 --> 03:48:21.360
melissadiner: loves to file grievances all the time does and then all the work of that committee could somehow be affected, like that's why he's doing these things, so I vote on it, however, you want, I just wanted to add that, thank you.

2209
03:48:21.990 --> 03:48:23.010
Soledad Ursua: I agree, Melissa.

2210
03:48:28.530 --> 03:48:29.700
james murez: you're taking the boat Melissa.

2211
03:48:29.940 --> 03:48:31.860
melissadiner: yeah I got it Jim.

2212
03:48:32.130 --> 03:48:34.200
melissadiner: Yes, that's it oh.

2213
03:48:34.590 --> 03:48:35.040
No.

2214
03:48:36.150 --> 03:48:37.050
melissadiner: I vote yes.

2215
03:48:49.110 --> 03:48:49.560
Vicki Halliday: Yes.

2216
03:48:51.270 --> 03:48:51.660
Sima Kostovetsky: No.

2217
03:48:57.900 --> 03:48:58.410
melissadiner: Okay.

2218
03:49:00.870 --> 03:49:01.440
Yes.

2219
03:49:05.550 --> 03:49:06.000
Mike Bravo: No.

2220
03:49:10.710 --> 03:49:11.340
ElizabethClay: Yes.

2221
03:49:13.650 --> 03:49:14.160
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

2222
03:49:29.190 --> 03:49:29.670
clark brown: No.

2223
03:49:36.780 --> 03:49:37.260
robertthibodeau: Yes.

2224
03:49:39.420 --> 03:49:39.960
Bruno Hernandez: Yes.

2225
03:49:41.910 --> 03:49:42.330
Andrea Boccaletti: So.

2226
03:49:49.980 --> 03:50:18.780
james murez: 791891 you want to recount.

2227
03:50:22.140 --> 03:50:22.950
melissadiner: Eight sure.

2228
03:50:24.870 --> 03:50:25.890
james murez: How many total are there.

2229
03:50:27.000 --> 03:50:30.420
james murez: 8910 18 people how many people are there.

2230
03:50:32.640 --> 03:50:38.430
melissadiner: I don't know i'm just going to stick with that vote and not recount everyone if you want to recount everyone on the screen, you can.

2231
03:50:38.520 --> 03:50:38.820
james murez: You can.

2232
03:50:38.850 --> 03:50:40.650
Daffodil Tyminski: We have 18 panelists present.

2233
03:50:42.690 --> 03:50:43.950
james murez: Yes, would be 891.

2234
03:50:47.820 --> 03:50:51.690
melissadiner: that's what it that's what we just concluded Are we moving on yep.

2235
03:50:52.440 --> 03:50:54.000
So.

2236
03:50:55.200 --> 03:50:56.460
james murez: The next one.

2237
03:50:57.990 --> 03:50:58.860
james murez: def go ahead.

2238
03:50:59.670 --> 03:51:01.230
james murez: Okay, oh by.

2239
03:51:01.560 --> 03:51:05.070
Daffodil Tyminski: This is Adam 12 I amendment to standing rule number 14.

2240
03:51:07.620 --> 03:51:16.830
Daffodil Tyminski: The existing rule number 14 is laid out on the screen for everyone to read the proposal and the motion is to amend that rule to read as follows.

2241
03:51:18.240 --> 03:51:28.440
Daffodil Tyminski: The Board shall approve the following addition to standing rule number 14 as follows the consent calendar items or motions of standing committees consider to be routine by the administrative community.

2242
03:51:29.130 --> 03:51:37.890
Daffodil Tyminski: board approval of the consent calendar constitutes approval of all emotions contained there in there will be no separate discussion of consent calendar motions.

2243
03:51:38.520 --> 03:51:43.740
Daffodil Tyminski: Unless a board member or a member of the public request removal of an item from the consent calendar.

2244
03:51:44.280 --> 03:51:48.690
Daffodil Tyminski: In which case the Chair will place the item on the regular agenda with a chair deems appropriate.

2245
03:51:49.470 --> 03:52:04.170
Daffodil Tyminski: Anyone wishing to contest to consent calendar item on the board Agenda must appear in person at the board meeting and states the board good cause for the item to be removed from the consent calendar, the Chair shall have sole discretion to determine what constitutes good cause.

2246
03:52:06.240 --> 03:52:07.020
james murez: We have a second.

2247
03:52:07.830 --> 03:52:08.190
clark brown: Part of.

2248
03:52:09.120 --> 03:52:09.630
james murez: Who was a.

2249
03:52:09.990 --> 03:52:11.790
james murez: Mark Thank you Clark.

2250
03:52:13.050 --> 03:52:15.030
james murez: goblets have a public comment now.

2251
03:52:15.690 --> 03:52:16.560
Daffodil Tyminski: All right.

2252
03:52:17.700 --> 03:52:18.270
Mike Bravo: Real quick.

2253
03:52:18.510 --> 03:52:25.410
Mike Bravo: can ask, is it possible to highlight the difference between the previous motion and the new proposal and.

2254
03:52:28.710 --> 03:52:31.440
james murez: I don't have a way of doing that they're both on the screen now.

2255
03:52:32.700 --> 03:52:33.930
james murez: i'll leave them both up, you can.

2256
03:52:34.170 --> 03:52:35.760
Daffodil Tyminski: Compare the day not red light.

2257
03:52:36.540 --> 03:52:38.370
james murez: yeah this wasn't a red line deal.

2258
03:52:45.060 --> 03:52:47.010
james murez: stuff was all disgusted committee so.

2259
03:52:48.060 --> 03:52:52.230
james murez: let's keep going we have Lisa reading them will be the last hand.

2260
03:52:53.370 --> 03:52:55.830
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, Nick go ahead, why don't you speak.

2261
03:52:57.390 --> 03:53:07.560
Nick Antonicello: yeah I was the know voting committee on this, and the reason why I was the no vote, because this is not a cleaning up in the bylaws this is showing up the standing room.

2262
03:53:08.850 --> 03:53:15.180
Nick Antonicello: You have to remember when you change the bylaws in the two thirds vote you don't need a two thirds vote on standing world.

2263
03:53:15.600 --> 03:53:26.670
Nick Antonicello: So what we're really doing here, this is the last raid you're not cleaning up the bylaws this making it easier by doing it through a standing wheelchair earns the committee security vote no.

2264
03:53:28.380 --> 03:53:28.800
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you.

2265
03:53:32.160 --> 03:53:33.030
Daffodil Tyminski: Margaret God.

2266
03:53:35.250 --> 03:53:47.940
Margaret Molloy: So you seem to have changed the last line from explain to the board, the reason the items contested to the Chair will have the sole discretion to determine what constitutes good cause.

2267
03:53:48.480 --> 03:54:04.650
Margaret Molloy: I know Clark is a former lawyer, but I believe retired and Clark I don't think that stands you know that's not legal language it's way too vague, can you help them because it's a terrible motion and it's so subjective it's ridiculous, so please help don't vote on this.

2268
03:54:05.670 --> 03:54:05.850
Margaret Molloy: or.

2269
03:54:05.970 --> 03:54:07.170
clark brown: Can I comment on no.

2270
03:54:11.760 --> 03:54:13.290
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm Helen foul go ahead.

2271
03:54:17.430 --> 03:54:24.780
Helen Fallon: yeah the major change here is the Chair having sole discretion and that's just a really bad policy.

2272
03:54:26.940 --> 03:54:35.280
Helen Fallon: It just becomes very subjective there were, I went to the meeting at which this was discussed, I then claim that this was a special.

2273
03:54:35.580 --> 03:54:46.770
Helen Fallon: Rule that he got with from the city, I went and looked up all the council's that are part of rack and there's a variety of ways people treat treat consent calendar items.

2274
03:54:47.100 --> 03:54:48.750
james murez: One of them is a lot of people.

2275
03:54:48.750 --> 03:54:55.320
Helen Fallon: Just default to robert's rules what says consent calendar items can be removed by the voting members of a group.

2276
03:54:55.620 --> 03:55:04.620
Helen Fallon: which will be the board members, so you don't have a public issue, so you would take public comment before people saying, this should be pulled off because I got 20 people here.

2277
03:55:04.860 --> 03:55:16.680
Helen Fallon: Who are upset about this and want to address it, and the board one would hope would be responsive this just makes the so complicated and it's just the weirdest thing, and there is not a single.

2278
03:55:17.190 --> 03:55:27.990
Helen Fallon: Council on the West side that has any language about having a chair having the sole discretion to determine what constitutes cause like I said, most of them default or Roberts.

2279
03:55:27.990 --> 03:55:29.130
rake you Helen.

2280
03:55:30.450 --> 03:55:32.130
Daffodil Tyminski: i'm holly Tilson go ahead.

2281
03:55:35.010 --> 03:55:46.140
Holly Tilson: hi I also don't like the last sentence, I would request a board member to make a motion to remove that last sentence, I would also.

2282
03:55:46.830 --> 03:56:03.930
Holly Tilson: request a board member to remove the Chair will place the item on the regular agenda where the Chair deems appropriate it should go at the beginning of the regular calendar, since these were consent items considered non controversial.

2283
03:56:05.130 --> 03:56:05.640
Holly Tilson: Thank you.

2284
03:56:06.420 --> 03:56:06.960
Daffodil Tyminski: Thank you.

2285
03:56:09.090 --> 03:56:12.870
Daffodil Tyminski: And last but not least, Lisa go ahead.

2286
03:56:14.580 --> 03:56:22.110
Lisa Redmond: Thank you um I am also very much against that subjective last line and for my argument.

2287
03:56:22.500 --> 03:56:31.830
Lisa Redmond: i'm going to read to you from a little something called the government code 54950 in the state of California, which happens to be the Ralph and brown at.

2288
03:56:32.340 --> 03:56:40.860
Lisa Redmond: quote the people of the State do not yield their sovereignty to agencies with serve them, the people in delegating authority.

2289
03:56:41.130 --> 03:56:48.840
Lisa Redmond: Do not give their public servants, the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know.

2290
03:56:49.260 --> 03:57:00.120
Lisa Redmond: That people insist on remaining informed, so they may retain control over the instruments they have created this also applies to public comment but for this case.

2291
03:57:01.740 --> 03:57:05.490
Lisa Redmond: You do not have control over what we get to know is right in that right.

2292
03:57:08.130 --> 03:57:12.210
Daffodil Tyminski: Okay, thanks so much, and with that we are closing public comment.

2293
03:57:12.810 --> 03:57:13.200
james murez: Thank you.

2294
03:57:14.040 --> 03:57:17.670
Daffodil Tyminski: you're welcome we've got a few board folks that want to talk.

2295
03:57:17.820 --> 03:57:21.150
james murez: yeah let's let's you can stop the clock i'm.

2296
03:57:22.290 --> 03:57:23.400
james murez: ELISE go ahead, please.

2297
03:57:25.050 --> 03:57:25.740
james murez: Give your hand up.

2298
03:57:27.690 --> 03:57:36.330
Alix: Sorry um so a couple things I agree with a lot of the comments and the subjects, the subjectivity for sure needs to be removed.

2299
03:57:36.780 --> 03:57:42.810
Alix: I mean, I can tell you contractually when when I did contracts back in the day and i'm not a lawyer i'm sure there are lawyers that can speak to this.

2300
03:57:43.230 --> 03:57:52.380
Alix: And you know, we would have sort of morals clauses and we'd always have to tighten up the the language, because it would be so subjective oh if you're accused of a.

2301
03:57:52.680 --> 03:58:05.940
Alix: You know, after moral turpitude it would have to get changed to you know if you're convicted or indicted same thing here, you know you you don't you don't give someone discretion on this, I also agree with next comment.

2302
03:58:06.780 --> 03:58:21.000
Alix: That we should get this into our bylaws and I know that's a more complicated way of dealing with things, but it seems like if we're cleaning up our bylaws and we have this opportunity to clean up our bylaws, why not get the consent calendar right get it on to our bylaws so.

2303
03:58:21.600 --> 03:58:28.320
Alix: You know I hope we can we can send this back to committee to get a better stronger less subjective version.

2304
03:58:30.120 --> 03:58:31.980
james murez: Thank you, a leak cj go ahead, please.

2305
03:58:32.760 --> 03:58:33.420
um.

2306
03:58:34.740 --> 03:58:43.650
CJ Cole: I think i'm unmuted my concern, and this is what I stated early on, is that this the way it's written.

2307
03:58:44.220 --> 03:59:02.340
CJ Cole: does not work with the new concept of having public comment at the beginning of our meeting, because what this does is opens up if something is pulled off the consent calendar is opening up public comment in the middle of our.

2308
03:59:04.710 --> 03:59:15.690
CJ Cole: of our meeting you know so it's just not consistent is all i'm saying with you know the thought that we're going to do all public comment up front and i'm getting laryngitis here.

2309
03:59:18.150 --> 03:59:19.290
Daffodil Tyminski: So, building on that.

2310
03:59:20.790 --> 03:59:21.180
james murez: and

2311
03:59:21.270 --> 03:59:21.990
CJ Cole: that's it yeah.

2312
03:59:22.170 --> 03:59:23.310
james murez: Mike go ahead, please.

2313
03:59:24.600 --> 03:59:25.800
Mike Bravo: yeah um.

2314
03:59:26.850 --> 03:59:35.550
Mike Bravo: It just seems like an unnecessary motion I didn't see what was wrong before i'm not filling understand some of them, you know tighten things up and trying to you know do.

2315
03:59:36.000 --> 03:59:48.510
Mike Bravo: housekeeping and encourage you know more efficiency and stuff but It just seems loved the sentiment simple controlling which i'm not really feeling and I don't even know if that's even legal honestly but um yeah.

2316
03:59:50.070 --> 03:59:51.390
james murez: Thank you Clark go ahead, please.

2317
03:59:51.660 --> 03:59:57.450
clark brown: I think there's a good motion, and the reason I like the motion is that I think it will expedite.

2318
03:59:58.110 --> 04:00:07.200
clark brown: board meetings by moving certain matters on the consent calendar last sentence doesn't bother me you're not giving the.

2319
04:00:07.740 --> 04:00:26.670
clark brown: President broad discretion to decide all the issues that are confronting the world, you were only given him discretion to determine what is good cause for an item to be moved from the consent calendar it's its discretion, regarding a tiny procedural issue, not a substantive issue.

2320
04:00:30.450 --> 04:00:32.220
james murez: Thank you Clark Robert go ahead, please.

2321
04:00:34.920 --> 04:00:38.220
robertthibodeau: I agree with Clark, is, I think this.

2322
04:00:39.390 --> 04:00:48.540
robertthibodeau: we've all sat through the meetings where you get kind of vindictive person who pulls everything off of consent, they don't have any idea of what they're doing.

2323
04:00:50.190 --> 04:00:55.860
robertthibodeau: I know there are a lot of people for consent items for legitimate reasons, and I have no problem sitting here.

2324
04:00:56.400 --> 04:01:00.960
robertthibodeau: And and hearing that those items, so I think that's all legitimate.

2325
04:01:01.440 --> 04:01:07.890
robertthibodeau: But when someone comes up to it and, and then they pull every single item off of consent and then they're not even around at the end of the meeting.

2326
04:01:08.340 --> 04:01:16.560
robertthibodeau: To hear the thing and it makes the 18 of US or 20 of us, you know kind of weed through stuff for another 45 minutes at the end.

2327
04:01:17.010 --> 04:01:25.440
robertthibodeau: I don't think that's part of the process, I think that that the you know somebody whether it's Jim or somebody else should have the discretion.

2328
04:01:25.890 --> 04:01:37.350
robertthibodeau: To go look this this was bs and let's all move on and you know they had their little temper tantrum but it shouldn't it shouldn't penalize everybody because because you got some nut out there.

2329
04:01:39.690 --> 04:01:41.910
james murez: Thank you, Robert Melissa go ahead, please.

2330
04:01:42.720 --> 04:01:57.690
melissadiner: yeah I just I mean last meeting that was ridiculous i'm so glad we didn't revisit you know his just cause for whatever reason, he was whoever that person was that can't even say who he is and made no sense.

2331
04:01:58.230 --> 04:02:09.630
melissadiner: You know that that's not okay yeah I definitely like to robert's point if someone wants to pull it off for any legitimate reason, regardless of whether I agree with them oh absolutely I have no problem with that.

2332
04:02:10.020 --> 04:02:26.070
melissadiner: But the President already has that discretion in the last sentence, so I don't know why that's an issue right he already has to make that judgment call, as our President, so I hope you guys will support this, so we can make our meetings as efficient as possible.

2333
04:02:27.540 --> 04:02:29.070
james murez: Thank you, definite no go ahead, please.

2334
04:02:29.790 --> 04:02:39.330
Daffodil Tyminski: um two things quickly one remember like the emotions that come to the board typically go through committee So these are things that are vetted they didn't come out of nowhere, and when we have a committee.

2335
04:02:39.990 --> 04:02:54.630
Daffodil Tyminski: That is really strong on one way, usually down, it was voted it goes to consent right so that that's something that we've always respected, and I feel like is important that that we continue with I would support this.

2336
04:02:56.040 --> 04:03:08.760
Daffodil Tyminski: I someone's gonna have to decide at some level whether something's good cause or not, and not everything can go to some of you to get a body to figure that out in the middle of a meeting, so it makes sense that if anyone's going to do that it's the Chair.

2337
04:03:10.980 --> 04:03:20.970
Daffodil Tyminski: So I would support this, I think I think it's also you know unfair sometimes the applicants when they come into a meeting thinking something's on consent and then all of a sudden.

2338
04:03:22.020 --> 04:03:37.200
Daffodil Tyminski: You know they they get out of consent and maybe get stuck at the end of the meeting and they're sitting for four hours waiting really because they got thrown off of consent on as someone mentioned a personal basis or petty basis or something like that, so I would vote for this.

2339
04:03:37.620 --> 04:03:39.630
james murez: Thank you i'm Sally go ahead.

2340
04:03:39.960 --> 04:03:42.150
Alley Bean: I don't know if I am I allowed to ask a question.

2341
04:03:43.380 --> 04:03:53.670
Alley Bean: Good my question would be or is just who in i'm sorry that I don't know the answer to this, but who previously a determined just caught good cause.

2342
04:03:55.590 --> 04:03:56.010
Alley Bean: So, like.

2343
04:03:57.060 --> 04:03:57.360
Alley Bean: Is this.

2344
04:03:58.590 --> 04:03:59.250
melissadiner: The President.

2345
04:03:59.610 --> 04:04:04.050
Alley Bean: So that was always the case, which has never been in writing is that what we're saying.

2346
04:04:04.590 --> 04:04:09.900
Alley Bean: Right i'm up but can someone else answer that is Is that true.

2347
04:04:10.770 --> 04:04:13.860
Daffodil Tyminski: Can I just jump in I forgot one thing and i'm sorry i'm just a little tired.

2348
04:04:14.790 --> 04:04:21.180
Daffodil Tyminski: One I don't think this was part of the standard before but to Jim correct me if i'm wrong but i'm pretty sure we vetted this with the city.

2349
04:04:22.050 --> 04:04:28.800
Daffodil Tyminski: We didn't just make this up for people who are saying this doesn't exist anywhere, no one doesn't like this i'm pretty sure the city weighed in on this language.

2350
04:04:29.070 --> 04:04:30.870
james murez: We believed our parliamentarian.

2351
04:04:32.730 --> 04:04:34.320
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah, but I believe they.

2352
04:04:34.530 --> 04:04:35.310
james murez: He taught he.

2353
04:04:35.610 --> 04:04:37.500
james murez: say he talked to pretty every.

2354
04:04:40.290 --> 04:04:49.500
james murez: But again, you know this, this was a I don't want to sound like a broken record here, but I send everybody a link to the video where this is she was discussed.

2355
04:04:50.550 --> 04:04:52.350
james murez: So i'm surprised that there are a lot of people that.

2356
04:04:53.820 --> 04:04:56.280
james murez: are familiar with what was discussed.

2357
04:04:56.310 --> 04:04:58.650
melissadiner: Okay, the President has always.

2358
04:04:58.740 --> 04:05:14.850
melissadiner: Yet, in the last 10 years i've been here has always been the one to say as soon as somebody said, for whatever reason guests, for taking that off he's always been the one to verify those items and read them back to me for note to pull them off of consent.

2359
04:05:15.930 --> 04:05:24.240
james murez: Family that's how I remember it as well, all the way back to DDB and President, which was before my new house, which was before Linda luxe which was before I but.

2360
04:05:24.360 --> 04:05:28.200
Alley Bean: Why are we, why are we making this a new rule if it already exists that's my only.

2361
04:05:28.200 --> 04:05:29.250
james murez: Question that's being worked.

2362
04:05:30.300 --> 04:05:30.570
Alley Bean: out.

2363
04:05:30.810 --> 04:05:38.310
james murez: we're not making a new rule we're just getting it in writing, I think that's what Mike asked the question, this is this is documenting it.

2364
04:05:38.880 --> 04:05:50.820
james murez: You know we're being challenged on a regular basis that we're not following the rules and and there are people that are out there, claiming that we're not allowed to do something, because it's not written well.

2365
04:05:50.940 --> 04:05:52.200
Alley Bean: This is robert's rules.

2366
04:05:52.530 --> 04:05:58.290
james murez: This is not robert's rules there's a pecking order Nick has alluded to this now twice tonight.

2367
04:05:58.650 --> 04:06:07.020
james murez: That we're modifying the standing roles and we're not adjusting the bylaws for the bylaws our our highest level of governing rules.

2368
04:06:07.410 --> 04:06:19.170
james murez: After that comes our standing rules and after that we default to robert's rules that to change the bylaws it's a lengthy process of approval.

2369
04:06:19.710 --> 04:06:26.940
james murez: And, and this is where done reviews what we're doing the Board has to approve it on a two thirds vote.

2370
04:06:27.330 --> 04:06:40.860
james murez: And and at some point in time after we submit it to done they're going to send it back to us with their additions or deletions as they see fit and and that's happened several times to us.

2371
04:06:42.300 --> 04:06:46.530
james murez: So, by putting it into the standing rule, now we get ready to update.

2372
04:06:46.800 --> 04:06:56.160
james murez: The bylaws will be able to move things into the bylaws that have already been adopted and people will be able to see gee they're working and then we can vote on them.

2373
04:06:56.460 --> 04:07:05.940
james murez: Moving them from standing rolls into the bylaws, so this is my feeling is this is just the first step in a longer process and that process is going to happen over the next two years.

2374
04:07:10.740 --> 04:07:11.820
james murez: Well let's let's take about.

2375
04:07:13.530 --> 04:07:16.110
james murez: That fidelity excuse me devotees your hands so up intentional.

2376
04:07:16.830 --> 04:07:18.210
Daffodil Tyminski: I know I apologize.

2377
04:07:18.360 --> 04:07:18.810
james murez: Thank you.

2378
04:07:19.380 --> 04:07:21.420
james murez: So let's take a boat oh yes.

2379
04:07:23.160 --> 04:07:23.880
Daffodil Tyminski: Oh yes.

2380
04:07:24.030 --> 04:07:25.440
melissadiner: I have so leaks.

2381
04:07:26.850 --> 04:07:27.510
Alix: No.

2382
04:07:29.730 --> 04:07:30.270
melissadiner: vicki.

2383
04:07:30.930 --> 04:07:31.350
Yes.

2384
04:07:33.120 --> 04:07:33.540
Sima Kostovetsky: Yes.

2385
04:07:40.830 --> 04:07:42.690
melissadiner: Yes, Mike bravo.

2386
04:07:49.620 --> 04:07:50.250
ElizabethClay: Yes.

2387
04:07:50.640 --> 04:07:52.050
clark brown: So, yes.

2388
04:07:52.620 --> 04:07:53.430
melissadiner: James rob.

2389
04:07:54.300 --> 04:07:54.600
Oh.

2390
04:08:00.270 --> 04:08:00.600
Nico Ruderman: No.

2391
04:08:01.710 --> 04:08:02.280
melissadiner: Clark.

2392
04:08:02.610 --> 04:08:04.140
melissadiner: Yes, Barber.

2393
04:08:05.010 --> 04:08:05.730
robertthibodeau: Yes.

2394
04:08:06.150 --> 04:08:07.560
Bruno Hernandez: For now, no.

2395
04:08:14.790 --> 04:08:15.210
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes.

2396
04:08:15.840 --> 04:08:16.500
cj.

2397
04:08:20.070 --> 04:08:20.760
melissadiner: cj.

2398
04:08:22.890 --> 04:08:23.910
CJ Cole: Sorry, no.

2399
04:08:28.830 --> 04:08:30.750
Chie Lunn: Can I change my vote to a now.

2400
04:08:31.800 --> 04:08:32.310
james murez: Who is that.

2401
04:08:33.030 --> 04:08:33.750
island.

2402
04:08:36.150 --> 04:08:40.470
melissadiner: Are we doing that I did that once before tonight, Denmark, can you change your vote.

2403
04:08:40.770 --> 04:08:41.880
james murez: yeah you can absolutely.

2404
04:08:50.940 --> 04:08:51.240
melissadiner: yeah.

2405
04:08:57.990 --> 04:08:59.370
melissadiner: Eight motion passes.

2406
04:09:01.710 --> 04:09:03.120
james murez: Thank you let's move along.

2407
04:09:06.480 --> 04:09:10.560
Daffodil Tyminski: um can we get someone else to read this one i'm really losing my voice.

2408
04:09:10.680 --> 04:09:13.140
Alix: I want me to it's a lakes.

2409
04:09:13.230 --> 04:09:13.740
james murez: Okay.

2410
04:09:13.800 --> 04:09:16.200
james murez: Thank you, on to 12 J.

2411
04:09:16.920 --> 04:09:18.030
Daffodil Tyminski: yo okay.

2412
04:09:19.050 --> 04:09:28.830
Alix: The dnc board shall create an ad hoc public safety and health committee with the following mission statement as approved by the administrative committee on October 11 2021.

2413
04:09:29.100 --> 04:09:36.840
Alix: The committee will terminate after one year mission, the Venice neighborhood Councils, public health and safety committee pH St.

2414
04:09:37.110 --> 04:09:49.260
Alix: mission is to increase all aspects of the personal safety and health Venice residents and visitors in concert with public officials, the Los Angeles city police and fire departments and all Los Angeles city departments.

2415
04:09:49.710 --> 04:09:55.650
Alix: With a similar mission, such as building and safety, sanitation and animal services, the pH.

2416
04:09:56.130 --> 04:10:11.790
Alix: D will recommend ways for the dnc to advise government agencies on measures to effectively improve stakeholder safety while promoting a direct department departmental to stakeholder collaborative approach encouraging Community based solutions to address local challenges.

2417
04:10:12.870 --> 04:10:14.790
james murez: Thank you do I hear a second.

2418
04:10:15.780 --> 04:10:16.140
clark brown: Okay, one.

2419
04:10:17.580 --> 04:10:18.180
james murez: Second.

2420
04:10:19.470 --> 04:10:32.790
Daffodil Tyminski: um so I wish i'd realized, we were on hold Jay when I said I wouldn't read it, but i've actually had a lot of outreach this week from folks that think that this is really way too broad, of a mission statement which was brought up in committee and.

2421
04:10:34.050 --> 04:10:41.490
Daffodil Tyminski: So I think it's something that may be at COM should work on more that, like to make a motion to send it back to add come.

2422
04:10:41.880 --> 04:10:43.740
james murez: So, are you making that motion.

2423
04:10:44.160 --> 04:10:46.170
james murez: Yes, okay second in it.

2424
04:10:46.440 --> 04:10:48.780
james murez: Jim Jim rob seconded it.

2425
04:10:50.700 --> 04:10:57.240
james murez: OK, so the motion on the floor is to send the.

2426
04:10:59.100 --> 04:11:00.810
melissadiner: mission it back to Africa.

2427
04:11:00.990 --> 04:11:02.850
james murez: To send the mission statement.

2428
04:11:03.030 --> 04:11:09.390
james murez: Back to add um did you want to include there that it was to blog is that part of it.

2429
04:11:09.510 --> 04:11:16.530
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah so I mean that that's the comment that I got quite a bit of outreach on and, obviously, you know we like the Committee but.

2430
04:11:16.800 --> 04:11:18.360
james murez: i'm just trying to get the motion word I.

2431
04:11:18.360 --> 04:11:21.930
melissadiner: got it send the mission statement back to add calm because it's too broad.

2432
04:11:22.440 --> 04:11:23.040
james murez: Thank you.

2433
04:11:23.310 --> 04:11:27.090
Soledad Ursua: That was the same mission statement, as the previous one, just so you guys know.

2434
04:11:27.180 --> 04:11:27.600
james murez: I do.

2435
04:11:28.740 --> 04:11:30.150
Soledad Ursua: But that's the same one that was.

2436
04:11:31.020 --> 04:11:43.110
james murez: yeah we understand you spell it out, I think, I think that that was That was the point that was meant okay let's let's take public comment um I will go ahead and read these capital, if you can just run the clock.

2437
04:11:43.440 --> 04:11:44.010
Daffodil Tyminski: I go.

2438
04:11:45.630 --> 04:11:45.870
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah.

2439
04:11:47.670 --> 04:11:49.290
james murez: So I have.

2440
04:11:50.400 --> 04:11:51.270
james murez: A.

2441
04:11:53.100 --> 04:11:59.310
james murez: Ending with Erica more starting with mark ridley puppet mark ridley puppet you're allowed to speak go ahead, you have.

2442
04:11:59.310 --> 04:12:01.080
Mark Ridley-Puppet: One again.

2443
04:12:02.550 --> 04:12:13.740
Mark Ridley-Puppet: In honor of the indicted one congratulations wherever you are so that's right, we were going to try to do this tonight, but you picked up on it, they did.

2444
04:12:14.220 --> 04:12:21.210
james murez: Yes, this was obviously Excuse me, Mr puppet you just speak to the topic okay you're not going to speak.

2445
04:12:21.420 --> 04:12:21.480
You.

2446
04:12:23.010 --> 04:12:29.340
Mark Ridley-Puppet: know the chair the chairs in an asshole mood tonight i'm very surprised on a custom night.

2447
04:12:30.390 --> 04:12:40.290
Mark Ridley-Puppet: So we were trying to get a committee to monitor the mark ridley Thomas Jose ways are indictments or calling in a public safety committee yes that's.

2448
04:12:40.650 --> 04:12:55.710
Mark Ridley-Puppet: What we do so, God puppet moves to amend the motion to have the bonus neighborhood Council federal indictment ad hoc committee to expire may 1 2023 by that time.

2449
04:12:56.880 --> 04:13:03.150
Mark Ridley-Puppet: Council members might be in prison where they always wanted to go it's.

2450
04:13:03.210 --> 04:13:04.350
james murez: A blue yeah.

2451
04:13:04.500 --> 04:13:06.270
Mark Ridley-Puppet: that's right it's been there Jerry.

2452
04:13:06.660 --> 04:13:07.740
james murez: Thank you very much.

2453
04:13:08.070 --> 04:13:08.310
well.

2454
04:13:09.960 --> 04:13:11.220
Mark Ridley-Puppet: Thank you, Sir, thank you.

2455
04:13:12.330 --> 04:13:16.110
james murez: Okay don't unmute yourself after i've cut you off or I might have to remove you.

2456
04:13:21.330 --> 04:13:22.800
james murez: Sean go ahead, please.

2457
04:13:31.470 --> 04:13:33.090
james murez: Sean you're allowed to speak go ahead.

2458
04:13:34.770 --> 04:13:38.910
Sean obrien: Okay, just popped up oh yeah great committee um.

2459
04:13:39.960 --> 04:13:48.690
Sean obrien: I hope you guys pass it tonight I love solid dad's work on it um my biggest thing with that committee is, we had the police, for an hour.

2460
04:13:49.140 --> 04:13:58.770
Sean obrien: And we have them for five minutes on this meeting so i'd love for you guys to pass this committee and then get the police back on there and then solid dad or somebody else can.

2461
04:13:59.640 --> 04:14:10.770
Sean obrien: recap, with the police said because we had them for an hour, and now we don't have anything we just get we just get a five minute thing but yeah I support the Safety Committee, thank you.

2462
04:14:12.030 --> 04:14:12.870
james murez: Thank you Sean.

2463
04:14:15.570 --> 04:14:17.790
james murez: Margaret malloy go ahead and place.

2464
04:14:19.440 --> 04:14:31.440
Margaret Molloy: So i'm glad you're sending back and so say I think that alcohol of saturation, especially in proximity to schools is an issue of public safety that soda has specifically spoken.

2465
04:14:32.070 --> 04:14:38.910
Margaret Molloy: In reaction to and said that that's monitored by the ABC well it's not if somebody crashed his car and killed somebody.

2466
04:14:39.570 --> 04:14:57.030
Margaret Molloy: The establishment, the served alcohol doesn't lose their license that's such a cop out, so please have a little broader perspective and include public safety that includes visibility of sidewalks now that we have all this encroachment into the street, you know how are things being monitored.

2467
04:14:57.270 --> 04:15:08.280
Margaret Molloy: And why are you approving endless CBS right beside schools like swimming saturating school kids with you know CBS.

2468
04:15:09.690 --> 04:15:10.170
Margaret Molloy: Thank you.

2469
04:15:10.440 --> 04:15:11.160
james murez: Thank you, Margaret.

2470
04:15:11.370 --> 04:15:18.360
Soledad Ursua: I just want to point out i've never stated a position on what Margaret malloy Sam so that's I would miss that.

2471
04:15:18.840 --> 04:15:21.030
james murez: Thank you were in public comment solid.

2472
04:15:22.200 --> 04:15:22.800
james murez: i'm.

2473
04:15:27.300 --> 04:15:29.640
james murez: Lisa redmen go ahead, please.

2474
04:15:30.150 --> 04:15:43.620
Lisa Redmond: yeah I threw up my hands before daffodil made her motion because I absolutely agree it's too broad have spoken on that before, so I guess, I agree with the motion to send it back to committee and tighten it up, thank you.

2475
04:15:44.700 --> 04:15:45.510
james murez: Thank you.

2476
04:15:49.530 --> 04:15:51.330
james murez: Helen fallon go ahead, please.

2477
04:15:53.280 --> 04:16:02.310
Helen Fallon: Well it's only true bra if you're a part of a homeless industrial complex, and I feel that no one can talk about homelessness as a public safety issue.

2478
04:16:02.790 --> 04:16:22.170
Helen Fallon: that's the objections here to not having a broadly based public health and safety committee that that that mission statement reflects exactly what is covered under public health and safety at the city level, and our committee should be looking at their corresponding City Council committees.

2479
04:16:23.430 --> 04:16:33.480
Helen Fallon: The pigeonholing of homelessness as if it is lives in its own little box and doesn't impact, public health and safety, the rats the trash or garbage etc.

2480
04:16:33.870 --> 04:16:41.040
Helen Fallon: is the only reason why people want to make a very narrow edition definition of what a public health and safety should represent.

2481
04:16:41.520 --> 04:16:57.210
Helen Fallon: So I say pass it I don't see why it should go back to add calm is will have to be resubmitted probably rewritten by me and I don't see the point I mean we don't need to pretend that homelessness is not impacting our health here, thank you.

2482
04:16:57.540 --> 04:16:58.200
Thank you.

2483
04:16:59.910 --> 04:17:00.540
james murez: i'm.

2484
04:17:03.360 --> 04:17:05.010
james murez: Elizabeth right go ahead, please.

2485
04:17:06.810 --> 04:17:11.610
Elizabeth Wright: I hardly agree that the mission statement is to broaden it go back.

2486
04:17:13.890 --> 04:17:14.370
Thank you.

2487
04:17:17.070 --> 04:17:18.480
james murez: Erica more or less speaker.

2488
04:17:20.940 --> 04:17:36.180
Erica Moore: hi I think in some respects, having a little broader is a positive thing, because then it's under an umbrella, which can cover things that we might not think about right now that come up, I hope you do pass it and I hope that we can find a way to.

2489
04:17:37.500 --> 04:17:50.070
Erica Moore: To get this going right away, because this is such an important committee and they did so many positive things solid and I really commend you for your hard efforts and i'm really excited to see what you can do for for our city and hector Thank you.

2490
04:17:52.170 --> 04:17:52.710
james murez: Thank you.

2491
04:17:54.120 --> 04:17:56.910
james murez: Okay, that was the last public comment.

2492
04:17:59.460 --> 04:18:04.080
james murez: um let's go to the panel, while we go ahead, please.

2493
04:18:04.800 --> 04:18:18.810
Alix: And, well, I still happen to support the mission statement is this i'm fine with a broad mission statement it worked in the past, but to address the issue of CVs those are through Lou path, not at the public health and safety.

2494
04:18:19.950 --> 04:18:27.210
Alix: committee and I don't think solid out has ever expressed a pov on that that review of all the land use issues and.

2495
04:18:28.920 --> 04:18:37.110
Alix: And we hear every CB that's come out on the city early notification reports so that would be the place to have those conversations and.

2496
04:18:38.640 --> 04:18:48.720
Alix: I look at the mess crazies on our streets and the fentanyl overdoses and I hardly think CBS or the issue for for our public health and safety so.

2497
04:18:49.770 --> 04:18:50.250
james murez: Thank you.

2498
04:18:50.310 --> 04:18:51.900
james murez: i'm sure.

2499
04:18:52.170 --> 04:18:53.400
james murez: Go ahead, please um.

2500
04:18:53.430 --> 04:18:58.740
Soledad Ursua: yeah I just want to reiterate that we've never taken on anything like that that's definitely not within this jurisdiction.

2501
04:18:59.520 --> 04:19:11.550
Soledad Ursua: With regard to it being brought I think that's there for a reason like when we had done some work for the storm drains that was such a complex issue we're talking about dealing with the county and then you know.

2502
04:19:12.240 --> 04:19:19.830
Soledad Ursua: there's just so many facets and everybody agreed that working on stuff for the storm drains was you know really great thing for the Community, but looking.

2503
04:19:20.490 --> 04:19:22.500
Soledad Ursua: crazy organizations that had to be.

2504
04:19:22.500 --> 04:19:29.580
Soledad Ursua: involved to do anything so there's some problems that we it's it's so hard to get anything done.

2505
04:19:30.180 --> 04:19:34.530
Soledad Ursua: That sometimes having a broad group with any basically any department that has.

2506
04:19:34.920 --> 04:19:43.470
Soledad Ursua: A safety aspect is sometimes you have to talk to all of them, and I was not the one that put in to renew this, but this is the same mission statement that we use last year.

2507
04:19:43.950 --> 04:19:57.630
Soledad Ursua: Last year ice, I saw input from so many different people to get this and I think it really worked well, so if you want to if you guys, want to have another public health and safety committee it was great to have all of these departments.

2508
04:19:59.190 --> 04:20:01.680
james murez: Thank you so dad Clark go ahead, please.

2509
04:20:01.920 --> 04:20:07.710
clark brown: So did I understand you correctly, that this is the exact same mission statement that you operated under last year.

2510
04:20:08.220 --> 04:20:10.320
Soledad Ursua: yeah and I hadn't gotten a lot of help.

2511
04:20:10.350 --> 04:20:14.820
Soledad Ursua: To you, so good, yes it actually worked really well last time.

2512
04:20:14.970 --> 04:20:18.600
clark brown: Last year was there any problem with the scope of the mission statement.

2513
04:20:19.920 --> 04:20:22.500
Soledad Ursua: No and see we didn't take on any kind of alcohol.

2514
04:20:23.040 --> 04:20:34.050
Soledad Ursua: related stuff though that's definitely lupus stuff so we really stuck to because, and also a coven we it was really helpful to have you know la county because they're the ones that were doing a lot of the covert outreach.

2515
04:20:34.620 --> 04:20:48.240
Soledad Ursua: So, really, you know even even with like building and safety there's just any department, where they had a similar mission to protect public health and safety of how it really works well, because sometimes you need to talk to so many different departments.

2516
04:20:48.840 --> 04:20:54.960
clark brown: So, so, in practice, the committee carried out a narrower function.

2517
04:20:56.250 --> 04:20:57.510
clark brown: mission statement allowed.

2518
04:20:58.530 --> 04:21:08.520
Soledad Ursua: um no it's just what happens is all these different departments end up giving you a run around and they say, well, you have to go talk to them, or you have to go to talk to them or that's the county or that's the state.

2519
04:21:08.910 --> 04:21:20.790
Soledad Ursua: And so that's the real hard part for residents so as long as if it's just tailored to something with similar missions, it should be broad enough because everybody passes the buck when it comes to accountability.

2520
04:21:21.960 --> 04:21:24.960
james murez: Okay let's Park, do you get your question answered.

2521
04:21:25.080 --> 04:21:25.530
clark brown: Yes, I did.

2522
04:21:25.560 --> 04:21:30.030
james murez: Thank you good Thank you Al you have a question go ahead yeah your comment you wanted to make.

2523
04:21:30.840 --> 04:21:31.650
Alley Bean: yeah it's.

2524
04:21:31.980 --> 04:21:34.620
Alley Bean: more of a comment I guess um and I just like.

2525
04:21:34.860 --> 04:21:44.760
Alley Bean: What I don't understand is is if the mission statements exactly the same, and I think everyone pretty much agrees that that committee was very robust and got a lot of.

2526
04:21:45.180 --> 04:21:58.500
Alley Bean: motions past and a lot of lot of participation on the part of stakeholders and I just feel like there's no point in sending it back to add calm, because it was already approved last time and it's a very crucial.

2527
04:21:59.460 --> 04:22:10.440
Alley Bean: You know I think both the homeless Committee, you know and that got approved and I, and I think this needs to get approved and I just think that we need to be addressing all of these issues, you know ASAP that's just my my two cents.

2528
04:22:10.770 --> 04:22:14.040
Alley Bean: And since I was already approved last time I don't know why would go back.

2529
04:22:14.490 --> 04:22:17.610
james murez: Thank you ellie NICO did you have your hand up, it was there for a minute.

2530
04:22:18.960 --> 04:22:20.490
Nico Ruderman: No, it was an accident sorry.

2531
04:22:21.150 --> 04:22:23.910
james murez: um anybody else had their hand up.

2532
04:22:25.080 --> 04:22:26.190
james murez: daffodil go ahead yeah.

2533
04:22:26.640 --> 04:22:37.080
Daffodil Tyminski: yeah um So this is the exact same mission statement that was passed in the last board and that mission statement does reflect what the city believes is public safety.

2534
04:22:37.530 --> 04:22:42.630
Daffodil Tyminski: And I think that was very persuasive and we were an ad come to passing this mission statement, as is.

2535
04:22:43.170 --> 04:22:52.680
Daffodil Tyminski: At least it was to me, and I think others as well, but i've gotten a lot of outreach over the last week, I think there are a lot of people that feel that the last committee.

2536
04:22:53.190 --> 04:23:05.550
Daffodil Tyminski: was just all over the place, and doing all kinds of things and it's not homeless stuff it's it's a lot of different things, a lot of that may have been the pandemic and some committees weren't functioning or maybe doing as much but.

2537
04:23:06.750 --> 04:23:21.300
Daffodil Tyminski: You know, conceivably I don't believe Helen is going to share it I don't believe soledad wants to do it, no one actually has stepped up to share it as far as I know, at this point, and so, in light of the various concerns about what that committee was doing.

2538
04:23:22.530 --> 04:23:25.410
Daffodil Tyminski: That, I think we're not voice at the icon meeting.

2539
04:23:26.610 --> 04:23:29.670
Daffodil Tyminski: that's why I thought it made sense to at least bring it back and discuss it.

2540
04:23:31.860 --> 04:23:37.560
Daffodil Tyminski: I was, by the way, in full disclosure I think in like 2008 or nine the originator of the public safety committee.

2541
04:23:38.970 --> 04:23:48.030
Daffodil Tyminski: back when I was on the board before, so I love the idea of it, I love the committee I think it's very important but I, you know hearing a lot of concerns about.

2542
04:23:48.600 --> 04:23:56.280
Daffodil Tyminski: it's the the breath of its mission and and whether or not you know we need that in light, we have committees that say, for example, they don't have in the rest of the state.

2543
04:23:59.100 --> 04:24:00.390
james murez: Okay um.

2544
04:24:02.610 --> 04:24:05.040
james murez: guess my only comment that I would throw in just to.

2545
04:24:06.240 --> 04:24:08.940
james murez: say something um you know.

2546
04:24:10.830 --> 04:24:15.330
james murez: There was Why am I getting an echo in the last term, there was a.

2547
04:24:16.560 --> 04:24:27.480
james murez: conflict between the this committee and and the homeless committee and I think that part of the discussion was also, how can we prevent that from happening, we don't want to have conflicts between committees.

2548
04:24:28.980 --> 04:24:39.870
james murez: I personally believe that a lot of the stuff that's being talked to it was talked about in the committee when Sola dad was leading it could have been handled through the neighborhood committed.

2549
04:24:40.440 --> 04:24:48.840
james murez: that a lot of those issues are really neighborhood issues and and we just didn't have a neighborhood committee in the last term so.

2550
04:24:50.610 --> 04:24:52.710
james murez: Okay let's let's uh.

2551
04:24:52.950 --> 04:24:54.090
CJ Cole: I have my hand down.

2552
04:24:54.180 --> 04:24:56.040
james murez: yeah you just put it up okay go ahead.

2553
04:24:56.340 --> 04:24:59.460
CJ Cole: Okay, the only thing I can say is that you know if.

2554
04:25:00.540 --> 04:25:13.410
CJ Cole: I have to say, the last year about the only Committee, other than a little peck that I went to and I go to a lot of them real regularly, it was the only one that ever gotten anything accomplished.

2555
04:25:13.770 --> 04:25:20.730
CJ Cole: I enjoyed listening to the least I enjoyed listening to the fire department, you know it's.

2556
04:25:21.360 --> 04:25:32.130
CJ Cole: You can sit and you know I think right now that we're getting into personalities, and the reason why this one doesn't want to go right now, but I think we should just vote it and get it going.

2557
04:25:33.120 --> 04:25:47.100
CJ Cole: And you know so far, the homeless committee hasn't even met so I don't think we're worried about whether this is going to step on the homeless committee um so I just think we should go ahead and vote, it can be done with it.

2558
04:25:47.250 --> 04:25:49.230
james murez: Today, are you volunteering to charity.

2559
04:25:51.330 --> 04:25:54.750
CJ Cole: Well, I guess, if I don't have to use zoom.

2560
04:25:55.380 --> 04:25:58.230
james murez: know you have to do zoom you have to follow all the rules to.

2561
04:26:00.270 --> 04:26:02.190
Soledad Ursua: Your Committee, if you want.

2562
04:26:03.930 --> 04:26:04.740
CJ Cole: To help me.

2563
04:26:04.770 --> 04:26:05.310
Soledad Ursua: See yeah.

2564
04:26:06.300 --> 04:26:09.480
Alley Bean: I thought Helen fallon offered to chair, it is that not happening i'm.

2565
04:26:09.510 --> 04:26:11.700
james murez: confused yeah actually denied Jerry.

2566
04:26:12.270 --> 04:26:13.530
Soledad Ursua: i'm gonna work.

2567
04:26:14.220 --> 04:26:16.380
james murez: hmm so see my you want to go ahead.

2568
04:26:17.460 --> 04:26:24.630
Sima Kostovetsky: I just I just want to ask like who wants to chair this because I think that's you know, important.

2569
04:26:25.560 --> 04:26:29.760
james murez: All right, any other comment oh Chai, you have the judge you have your hand up go ahead.

2570
04:26:30.330 --> 04:26:34.080
Chie Lunn: Yes, if cj leads the Committee i'll definitely join as well.

2571
04:26:34.650 --> 04:26:35.070
james murez: Okay.

2572
04:26:35.370 --> 04:26:36.180
james murez: But you don't want to leave.

2573
04:26:36.510 --> 04:26:38.820
CJ Cole: me a call share two chairs.

2574
04:26:39.540 --> 04:26:39.810
I.

2575
04:26:41.820 --> 04:26:44.700
Alley Bean: think she denied it either, so I think she'd co chair it, I mean.

2576
04:26:45.000 --> 04:26:46.380
CJ Cole: yeah yeah I.

2577
04:26:47.940 --> 04:26:53.730
james murez: asked him out everybody I got an email from her that she's not interested in sharing, so you know.

2578
04:26:54.210 --> 04:26:54.510
I.

2579
04:26:55.920 --> 04:26:58.770
james murez: chose not to Melissa you have your hand up.

2580
04:27:00.000 --> 04:27:11.550
melissadiner: yeah I mean you covered it, I was just gonna say if we vote on it we're voting on something that no one can go to meetings, because no one's sharing it so what, why not just delay until people figure out who.

2581
04:27:11.550 --> 04:27:13.470
melissadiner: can share it but for.

2582
04:27:13.530 --> 04:27:14.130
melissadiner: How you wish.

2583
04:27:14.610 --> 04:27:31.050
james murez: I mean let's be let's be clear about this, we can vote this committee in that's very broad and has a lot of responsibility and a lot of things that have been done in the past by somebody who was very aggressive and very instrumental in making it happen.

2584
04:27:32.970 --> 04:27:51.240
james murez: And we can have make that we can make that vote happen and and and approve the committee as its described, but I don't have anybody to appoint remember the President appoints who the Chair is I don't have anybody that I can appoint it's going to be the point person to take that responsibility.

2585
04:27:52.320 --> 04:27:52.740
james murez: Okay.

2586
04:27:53.370 --> 04:27:54.900
Alley Bean: AJ just said that they would.

2587
04:27:58.410 --> 04:27:59.310
Alley Bean: guide in you.

2588
04:28:02.400 --> 04:28:06.000
Alley Bean: Sorry didn't you just say that you do it with cj if she did it.

2589
04:28:07.050 --> 04:28:11.400
Chie Lunn: If she took the lead, yes and sold, that would help us out yes.

2590
04:28:11.490 --> 04:28:17.550
Alley Bean: And Helen fallon apparently never said that he's I mean she's here, you should ask her.

2591
04:28:18.510 --> 04:28:21.210
james murez: I have an email from a rally i'm not going to dispute it.

2592
04:28:23.190 --> 04:28:23.850
Alley Bean: Well she's.

2593
04:28:23.880 --> 04:28:26.910
james murez: Just the two of you do the two of you want to co chair.

2594
04:28:29.040 --> 04:28:29.700
james murez: cj.

2595
04:28:30.150 --> 04:28:30.810
james murez: Or you want to go.

2596
04:28:30.840 --> 04:28:32.010
CJ Cole: Here, with somebody.

2597
04:28:32.310 --> 04:28:33.240
CJ Cole: God I just.

2598
04:28:33.390 --> 04:28:34.950
CJ Cole: I just can't do everything.

2599
04:28:35.220 --> 04:28:36.720
james murez: I understand you don't want to.

2600
04:28:37.200 --> 04:28:43.920
CJ Cole: Do was still put my effort into the standing rules and whatever because we're getting nowhere there.

2601
04:28:45.090 --> 04:28:45.570
james murez: Okay.

2602
04:28:47.070 --> 04:28:55.260
Daffodil Tyminski: I mean Clearly this is not well thought out right that's the whole point here is the mission statement who's going to take responsibility.

2603
04:28:56.220 --> 04:29:04.440
Daffodil Tyminski: You know if people want to step up and volunteer and, by the way, there's a lot of committee members, a lot of board members that are not really volunteering, please let me know.

2604
04:29:05.910 --> 04:29:07.800
Alley Bean: nolan this thing that she volunteered.

2605
04:29:07.980 --> 04:29:12.930
james murez: And we have to do there's enough to do this, one one, at a time one, at a time one, at a time.

2606
04:29:15.390 --> 04:29:18.390
james murez: We have three hands up for hands up.

2607
04:29:19.500 --> 04:29:22.110
james murez: Melissa your hand is up go ahead, please.

2608
04:29:22.410 --> 04:29:24.690
melissadiner: I know I don't need to talk okay.

2609
04:29:24.750 --> 04:29:25.830
james murez: i'm a lower your hand.

2610
04:29:26.460 --> 04:29:27.900
james murez: see my your hand is up.

2611
04:29:33.840 --> 04:29:34.380
Sima Kostovetsky: order.

2612
04:29:34.590 --> 04:29:48.720
Sima Kostovetsky: um, is it possible that we bring this back next meeting when we have the Chair situation figured out with that be amenable is that something that just in question.

2613
04:29:48.870 --> 04:29:52.440
james murez: We can vote it up today and create the committee.

2614
04:29:53.940 --> 04:29:58.050
james murez: And not appoint the Chair until we have a chair, I mean i'm not going to appoint somebody that's not going to do it.

2615
04:29:58.410 --> 04:30:00.750
Sima Kostovetsky: But there seems to be two issues right there's the.

2616
04:30:02.520 --> 04:30:03.990
Sima Kostovetsky: scope of the committee so.

2617
04:30:04.440 --> 04:30:13.680
james murez: The appointment is completely on me if we create the broad scope, then we have to have somebody that's going to be willing to take on the responsibility of the broad scope.

2618
04:30:14.940 --> 04:30:18.450
james murez: If we narrow the scope that we maybe we can find somebody.

2619
04:30:18.450 --> 04:30:18.930
james murez: it's mostly.

2620
04:30:19.290 --> 04:30:21.180
CJ Cole: A chair least a culture.

2621
04:30:24.120 --> 04:30:25.320
james murez: Okay Andre.

2622
04:30:25.680 --> 04:30:35.370
CJ Cole: yeah I am on the phone now quote I never told him I did not want it to chair, unquote.

2623
04:30:37.200 --> 04:30:37.650
james murez: Okay.

2624
04:30:38.580 --> 04:30:39.090
Thank you.

2625
04:30:41.400 --> 04:30:41.790
james murez: Andre.

2626
04:30:42.210 --> 04:30:47.580
Andrea Boccaletti: yeah my hand was just to be the that I would definitely definitely love to serve on this committee as well.

2627
04:30:48.060 --> 04:30:59.190
james murez: Okay, thank you let's stick to let's stick to the issue on the table, which is whether or not we're going to vote to send this thing back or not and that's really all we're talking about.

2628
04:31:00.450 --> 04:31:00.930
She.

2629
04:31:02.010 --> 04:31:02.400
james murez: Go ahead.

2630
04:31:03.180 --> 04:31:13.920
Alley Bean: No, I mean i'm just saying we've got like all these people wanting to do this, I think it's the you know, was the one committee that really got a lot accomplished and we're in great need of.

2631
04:31:14.550 --> 04:31:28.800
Alley Bean: You know, God knows, safety in tennis right now, so I don't see any reason not to have this go forward and apparently Helen wants to do at cj wants to do it guy wants to do it, Andrea I would say, definitely let's vote it up.

2632
04:31:29.700 --> 04:31:30.360
james murez: Okay, thank you.

2633
04:31:30.870 --> 04:31:31.980
james murez: holly go ahead, please.

2634
04:31:33.990 --> 04:31:36.240
Alix: Sorry, our comments were addressed.

2635
04:31:39.300 --> 04:31:40.860
james murez: daffodil go ahead, please.

2636
04:31:41.460 --> 04:31:45.210
Daffodil Tyminski: I just wanted to comment I don't think there's any dispute about having the committee.

2637
04:31:45.900 --> 04:31:53.730
Daffodil Tyminski: For all of these folks that are stepping up to say something now, I wish you had said something before but really that's immaterial the issue on the floor is the breath of the committee.

2638
04:31:54.390 --> 04:32:05.430
Daffodil Tyminski: And I merely raise the issue because there's a lot of people out here the think it's way too broad and we really have to have a fully robust functioning of all the committee's.

2639
04:32:06.630 --> 04:32:13.860
Daffodil Tyminski: Not just this one, and I think add calm had a different perspective that was presented to us when we had the outcome meeting.

2640
04:32:15.330 --> 04:32:17.490
james murez: Thank you Danielle Melissa let's take a vote.

2641
04:32:20.790 --> 04:32:23.670
Alix: can clarify we're voting on the amendment correct.

2642
04:32:23.730 --> 04:32:24.030
james murez: that's right.

2643
04:32:24.090 --> 04:32:27.060
james murez: The minute The amendment is to send it back to committee.

2644
04:32:29.670 --> 04:32:31.320
Daffodil Tyminski: to refine the mission statement.

2645
04:32:31.920 --> 04:32:33.930
james murez: Correct Thank you know.

2646
04:32:35.310 --> 04:32:36.000
melissadiner: Jim.

2647
04:32:36.390 --> 04:32:37.950
melissadiner: Yes, that's it oh.

2648
04:32:38.490 --> 04:32:40.830
melissadiner: Yes, yes, the leaks.

2649
04:32:42.180 --> 04:32:42.600
Alix: No.

2650
04:32:44.820 --> 04:32:45.240
melissadiner: Yes.

2651
04:32:45.960 --> 04:32:48.030
Sima Kostovetsky: Sema abstain.

2652
04:32:57.390 --> 04:32:58.140
Alley Bean: No.

2653
04:33:04.470 --> 04:33:05.040
Back to me.

2654
04:33:08.280 --> 04:33:08.640
Mike Bravo: Though.

2655
04:33:13.080 --> 04:33:13.530
ElizabethClay: No.

2656
04:33:17.670 --> 04:33:18.120
Soledad Ursua: No.

2657
04:33:20.970 --> 04:33:22.590
melissadiner: i'm James rob.

2658
04:33:26.340 --> 04:33:26.940
melissadiner: rob.

2659
04:33:28.800 --> 04:33:30.180
james murez: don't see him anymore.

2660
04:33:30.630 --> 04:33:33.570
melissadiner: Okay 1030.

2661
04:33:33.930 --> 04:33:35.160
james murez: let's see if he's in the.

2662
04:33:35.430 --> 04:33:36.330
CP fellows.

2663
04:33:39.360 --> 04:33:39.660
Nico Ruderman: know.

2664
04:33:40.590 --> 04:33:44.850
clark brown: Clark there when you say send it back to committee, you mean send it back to add calm.

2665
04:33:45.210 --> 04:33:46.830
clark brown: yeah no.

2666
04:33:51.090 --> 04:33:51.540
robertthibodeau: No.

2667
04:33:53.760 --> 04:33:54.330
melissadiner: For now.

2668
04:33:54.780 --> 04:33:55.230
Now.

2669
04:33:57.540 --> 04:33:57.930
Andrea Boccaletti: No.

2670
04:33:58.530 --> 04:34:00.330
CJ Cole: cj no.

2671
04:34:03.600 --> 04:34:04.110
melissadiner: hi.

2672
04:34:33.720 --> 04:34:36.420
melissadiner: Wine because James drop is not here, thank you.

2673
04:34:36.750 --> 04:34:40.050
james murez: Okay motion Wales, now the motion.

2674
04:34:41.820 --> 04:34:44.160
james murez: To approve the committee spec on the floor.

2675
04:34:47.880 --> 04:34:49.470
james murez: let's take public comment on that.

2676
04:34:52.770 --> 04:34:57.720
james murez: Anybody have their hand up speak now it's getting late, we need to be done here in a few minutes.

2677
04:35:00.360 --> 04:35:03.930
james murez: Seven people want to speak on this side of my goodness.

2678
04:35:06.180 --> 04:35:10.050
james murez: Okay i'm closing public comment after Elizabeth right.

2679
04:35:11.460 --> 04:35:12.750
james murez: Lisa redmond.

2680
04:35:13.890 --> 04:35:14.700
james murez: Go ahead, please.

2681
04:35:15.660 --> 04:35:19.830
Lisa Redmond: I am against this mission statement because it is too broad.

2682
04:35:25.980 --> 04:35:26.400
james murez: i'm.

2683
04:35:28.050 --> 04:35:31.350
james murez: Mark ridley puppet go ahead, please.

2684
04:35:33.180 --> 04:35:48.060
Mark Ridley-Puppet: Well done, yes, and thank you to my confederates, then we will know, take the world's a ways are and work readily no name indictments into this brand new committee and examine the documents more carefully.

2685
04:35:48.630 --> 04:36:02.910
Mark Ridley-Puppet: Well, how many police officers for agents FBI agents state attorney general's and also da investigators, who cannot really unsafely come to your committee, under the guise of public safety.

2686
04:36:03.360 --> 04:36:18.120
Mark Ridley-Puppet: and help with the snatching Thank you to everybody, I appoint my co chair of the committee and don't buffer secret chair is up until a secretary do I have a second.

2687
04:36:19.350 --> 04:36:19.770
james murez: and gives.

2688
04:36:20.010 --> 04:36:21.090
james murez: Do Thank you.

2689
04:36:22.950 --> 04:36:23.790
james murez: Mr puppet.

2690
04:36:28.290 --> 04:36:33.840
james murez: i'm next speaker character more go ahead, please.

2691
04:36:35.280 --> 04:36:46.560
Erica Moore: hi, as I said earlier, I don't think it's actually a good thing to be broad I also think, in saying that I also think it doesn't mean that they have to take on 10,000 different issues.

2692
04:36:46.830 --> 04:36:51.300
Erica Moore: I just think having that autonomy to be able to do that is a good idea, because again.

2693
04:36:51.690 --> 04:37:00.480
Erica Moore: You don't know what kind of safety issues could present themselves, but we don't even know about right now I mean you know some weird things happen that you don't expect so.

2694
04:37:00.900 --> 04:37:12.570
Erica Moore: I think, having that freedom is a big thing I think we need to get the show on the road you got Helen he wants to do it, you got tj wants to do other people that are ready to step up and be honest committee let's go Thank you.

2695
04:37:14.130 --> 04:37:19.710
james murez: Thank you Sean Oh, Brian go ahead, please oh.

2696
04:37:20.730 --> 04:37:22.890
james murez: We there go ahead.

2697
04:37:24.330 --> 04:37:28.530
Sean obrien: Oh yeah all the support the motion support the committee let's do it tonight, thank you.

2698
04:37:33.060 --> 04:37:36.330
james murez: Thank you Sean herrick more go ahead, please.

2699
04:37:39.420 --> 04:37:40.290
CJ Cole: don't smoke.

2700
04:37:41.670 --> 04:37:43.020
james murez: Oh, she did yeah.

2701
04:37:43.830 --> 04:37:44.220
Erica Moore: I just.

2702
04:37:45.210 --> 04:37:50.250
james murez: spoke i'm sorry they're moving around i'm sorry i'm.

2703
04:37:52.140 --> 04:37:53.700
james murez: Nick go ahead place.

2704
04:37:54.990 --> 04:38:05.520
Nick Antonicello: yeah it's not a broad it's a question of some committees are going to overlap that's just the way it is in parking almost is other committees have the tendency to overlap so.

2705
04:38:06.240 --> 04:38:15.510
Nick Antonicello: This is the best committee that the nc had in my 12 or 13 years be involved and you reward success, you know eliminate Thank you.

2706
04:38:18.330 --> 04:38:19.320
james murez: Thank you.

2707
04:38:21.210 --> 04:38:23.640
james murez: i'm Yolanda go ahead place.

2708
04:38:25.020 --> 04:38:37.560
Yolanda Gonzalez: Yes, I I think what we ought to do is, if you do send it back to committee, why don't we get an input of five issues that we really want on this committee.

2709
04:38:38.190 --> 04:38:52.500
Yolanda Gonzalez: We can go beyond so many things that need to be fixed, but if we get five things we really want to accomplish they will be accomplished, because if people want to work on this committee, we will get it done Thank you.

2710
04:38:53.700 --> 04:38:54.660
james murez: Thank you.

2711
04:38:57.360 --> 04:38:58.260
james murez: i'm.

2712
04:39:01.500 --> 04:39:02.580
james murez: Helen go ahead.

2713
04:39:04.230 --> 04:39:11.370
Helen Fallon: Just to clarify the record Jim I did not refuse the chair of this committee, the only email I had with you.

2714
04:39:11.730 --> 04:39:20.070
Helen Fallon: was when you said you to another point I suggested you check with board members and previous committee members, so I was ever asked to chair i'm.

2715
04:39:20.340 --> 04:39:27.000
Helen Fallon: would love to participate again on this committee, I think we did a lot of good work, I think the previous speakers comment about.

2716
04:39:27.300 --> 04:39:40.350
Helen Fallon: yeah, we need to have this Canadian place and we need to hear from the public what the safety issues they want to see addressed are and we tried to do that, as a committee that's why there was a lot of public participation, and again I don't appreciate you telling.

2717
04:39:41.430 --> 04:39:48.300
Helen Fallon: Completely misrepresenting me Jim That was really inappropriate and I think you all, be a public apology for that.

2718
04:39:49.800 --> 04:39:55.800
Helen Fallon: So please vote to pass this and move it on is obviously a great deal of interest by the Board and the stakeholder.

2719
04:39:59.610 --> 04:40:00.630
james murez: Thank you.

2720
04:40:01.830 --> 04:40:02.670
james murez: Elizabeth.

2721
04:40:04.740 --> 04:40:06.150
james murez: Elizabeth right go ahead place.

2722
04:40:08.730 --> 04:40:21.120
Elizabeth Wright: The fact that the committee voluntarily restricted or or narrowed its own scope doesn't mean that will happen in the future, it is still to broaden to go back to come.

2723
04:40:23.820 --> 04:40:33.990
james murez: Thank you Elizabeth and that closes public comment Margaret your hand was up but it came up after I already had announced to the last speaker was going to be.

2724
04:40:36.240 --> 04:40:41.490
james murez: So, having said that let's turn it over to the panel.

2725
04:40:42.510 --> 04:40:55.620
james murez: We can now debate the item, I will say that, in the message that I sent to hell and I read the message as she was not interested, I asked her who should share it and she wrote back.

2726
04:40:56.130 --> 04:41:08.130
james murez: As she said it, she commented I should ask one of the people on the board that wants to do it so she wasn't volunteering for it, I gave her the opportunity to volunteer for it and I certainly wasn't going to impose it on her.

2727
04:41:10.200 --> 04:41:17.880
james murez: Having said that, let us have anybody on the committee that wants to speak on this before we take a vote raise your hand now.

2728
04:41:19.650 --> 04:41:23.250
james murez: Seeing no hands let's take a vote, Melissa take a roll call, please.

2729
04:41:24.630 --> 04:41:29.610
Vicki Halliday: explain this is to have the committee or not, or what.

2730
04:41:29.790 --> 04:41:33.300
james murez: To have the committee as proposed here, I can put the mission.

2731
04:41:33.300 --> 04:41:34.500
james murez: Statement okay that's fine.

2732
04:41:34.740 --> 04:41:36.960
Vicki Halliday: it's it's the mission statement right.

2733
04:41:36.990 --> 04:41:42.780
james murez: You were approving the committee the mission statement was already approved in add COM.

2734
04:41:42.930 --> 04:41:49.110
james murez: Okay, all we're doing is approving to have the create the creation of the committee.

2735
04:41:49.590 --> 04:41:51.270
melissadiner: Okay, can I take a roll call.

2736
04:41:51.540 --> 04:41:54.720
melissadiner: Please Jim yes Africa.

2737
04:41:55.170 --> 04:41:56.910
melissadiner: Yes, yes leaks.

2738
04:41:57.060 --> 04:41:58.320
Alix: Yes, vicki.

2739
04:41:58.650 --> 04:42:00.060
melissadiner: No Sema.

2740
04:42:04.530 --> 04:42:04.980
Sima Kostovetsky: Yes.

2741
04:42:06.270 --> 04:42:06.870
Alley Bean: Yes.

2742
04:42:07.020 --> 04:42:08.340
Chie Lunn: hi yes.

2743
04:42:08.760 --> 04:42:10.230
Mike Bravo: Mike yes.

2744
04:42:12.090 --> 04:42:12.630
ElizabethClay: Yes.

2745
04:42:13.680 --> 04:42:14.220
Soledad Ursua: Yes.

2746
04:42:14.310 --> 04:42:15.000
The mob.

2747
04:42:18.210 --> 04:42:18.570
melissadiner: sneak.

2748
04:42:21.030 --> 04:42:21.510
Nico Ruderman: Yes.

2749
04:42:23.610 --> 04:42:24.240
melissadiner: Clark.

2750
04:42:25.170 --> 04:42:25.710
Yes.

2751
04:42:26.940 --> 04:42:27.450
robertthibodeau: Yes.

2752
04:42:28.440 --> 04:42:28.980
Yes.

2753
04:42:30.810 --> 04:42:31.230
Andrea Boccaletti: Yes.

2754
04:42:31.440 --> 04:42:33.060
CJ Cole: cj yes.

2755
04:42:37.980 --> 04:42:47.490
melissadiner: 16.

2756
04:42:49.590 --> 04:42:50.700
melissadiner: One zero.

2757
04:42:52.950 --> 04:42:59.580
james murez: Further 1716 one zero yeah that sounds right that makes 17 good job i'm.

2758
04:43:01.020 --> 04:43:02.010
james murez: Like think.

2759
04:43:03.900 --> 04:43:06.000
CJ Cole: I thought two people voted against it.

2760
04:43:08.490 --> 04:43:11.820
Soledad Ursua: I love to be a committee Member if anybody wants to chair.

2761
04:43:12.060 --> 04:43:14.490
james murez: Okay we're on to Item number.

2762
04:43:16.590 --> 04:43:26.550
james murez: board member announcements on subject matters within the dnc jurisdiction solid had go right ahead, this is this is your opportunity to speak about whatever it is you wanted to say.

2763
04:43:27.090 --> 04:43:28.890
Soledad Ursua: Oh, and i've just done it.

2764
04:43:28.980 --> 04:43:30.600
Soledad Ursua: Whoever the Chair is I love to.

2765
04:43:30.600 --> 04:43:33.390
Soledad Ursua: serve on the committee that's really it that's all I am.

2766
04:43:34.230 --> 04:43:34.920
Okay.

2767
04:43:37.530 --> 04:43:39.990
james murez: Do we have any Let me turn off the screen sharing.

2768
04:43:41.250 --> 04:43:50.820
james murez: You know we're going to make it out before 11, I guess, my question to all of you is is what did you think about starting at six o'clock instead of seven o'clock so we can get to sleep at a normal our.

2769
04:43:52.740 --> 04:43:57.450
james murez: ICC jays hand is up loses his hand is up and everybody's hands are up okay great.

2770
04:43:57.540 --> 04:43:58.980
Alix: The winter bad in the summer.

2771
04:44:00.810 --> 04:44:06.870
james murez: we'll figure that out when the time comes, okay um daffodil you have your hand up go ahead.

2772
04:44:07.530 --> 04:44:17.250
Daffodil Tyminski: um yeah I like to 6pm start time but really if anyone has items, they would like on the agenda of the neighborhood Committee, please email me at VP.

2773
04:44:17.850 --> 04:44:34.050
Daffodil Tyminski: At Venice nc.org we can't guarantee everything will get on right away, but we have some requests and a lot of good ideas, so I just want to make sure that as we get going we're addressing the concerns that everyone is so again is VP at Venice nc dot work.

2774
04:44:35.460 --> 04:44:38.070
james murez: Thank you down i'm Mike go ahead.

2775
04:44:39.360 --> 04:44:56.280
Mike Bravo: yeah for those who missed it last month late September September 29 the first Baptist church of Venice was granted historic designation and it's what they call the supporters of help the Community oakland community and vast history in general, so thank you.

2776
04:44:58.500 --> 04:45:00.480
james murez: Thank you Mike Andre go ahead.

2777
04:45:01.530 --> 04:45:07.680
Andrea Boccaletti: yeah just got a couple concerns and some things that people in my neighborhood are really concerned about and I don't know.

2778
04:45:08.280 --> 04:45:19.260
Andrea Boccaletti: Who to address this with and what committees, but at the end of my street i've got a building that was zoned for to individual properties now it's turned into a hostile.

2779
04:45:19.920 --> 04:45:32.100
Andrea Boccaletti: it's actually called the Venice hostile, you can go online, you can book a room tonight, they got pods in there it's unbelievable and the other issue is just how.

2780
04:45:33.480 --> 04:45:42.630
Andrea Boccaletti: street lighting, I mean they didn't start three street lights outside my frickin window on pema avenue just all in the last two and a half weeks.

2781
04:45:43.080 --> 04:45:49.650
Andrea Boccaletti: So now, I can see five streetlights from my front window here and I don't understand what the hell is going on, like who's.

2782
04:45:50.100 --> 04:46:01.740
Andrea Boccaletti: Call bones office, no one gets back to you, and nothing happens I don't know what committees to just it's just like we're losing we're losing our Community here in a big big big way.

2783
04:46:03.690 --> 04:46:05.160
Thanks, thank you.

2784
04:46:09.600 --> 04:46:10.440
james murez: NICO go ahead.

2785
04:46:12.750 --> 04:46:20.880
Nico Ruderman: yeah i'm not going to speak very long, I just want to offer a public apology of projects, all the board members for my behavior last week but.

2786
04:46:21.420 --> 04:46:31.290
Nico Ruderman: You know a lot of things are going on that we're out of my control, but I was very emotional and yeah but my behavior regardless was unacceptable and I apologize.

2787
04:46:32.580 --> 04:46:34.800
james murez: Thank you, Nicole um.

2788
04:46:36.240 --> 04:46:38.340
james murez: let's see any more hands go ahead.

2789
04:46:38.790 --> 04:46:47.760
Alley Bean: i'm daffodil I probably missed the email but i'm because i'm sorry Jim whatever email, it was that I missed that you were talking about to I try to read it read all those Venice neighbors.

2790
04:46:48.630 --> 04:46:53.880
Alley Bean: But um have you announced to the neighborhood like who's in what neighborhood who the people are.

2791
04:46:54.480 --> 04:47:06.300
Alley Bean: The REPS and then also should we go through them is that how the committee will work that if we have a neighborhood concern should everybody find out like who our neighborhood person is on your committee and go to them.

2792
04:47:07.050 --> 04:47:10.320
Alley Bean: Is that kind of how that committee is going to work that's my only question.

2793
04:47:14.640 --> 04:47:15.480
james murez: Do you want to answer them.

2794
04:47:17.010 --> 04:47:17.700
james murez: Where to go.

2795
04:47:17.910 --> 04:47:18.900
Alley Bean: Maybe she didn't hear me.

2796
04:47:18.990 --> 04:47:19.320
she'll.

2797
04:47:21.660 --> 04:47:22.590
Alley Bean: Think she's frozen.

2798
04:47:24.000 --> 04:47:27.600
Alley Bean: Well i'll ask her separately nevermind I just thought, maybe everybody would want to hear that.

2799
04:47:29.100 --> 04:47:36.720
Alley Bean: And then I didn't know if the silver triangle it become a neighborhood or not, but I can ask her separate I just thought Maybe she could tell everybody at one time.

2800
04:47:40.410 --> 04:47:41.790
james murez: yeah hang on let's find out.

2801
04:47:43.980 --> 04:47:47.070
screen froze and she dropped out see if she can come back yet.

2802
04:48:02.430 --> 04:48:04.260
james murez: daffodil if you're out there, raise your hand.

2803
04:48:06.000 --> 04:48:08.550
james murez: I don't see you yeah I don't have an answer for you.

2804
04:48:08.820 --> 04:48:11.880
james murez: Okay, you have something you wanted to say your hand was up.

2805
04:48:12.750 --> 04:48:19.050
Alix: yeah just Andrea reach out to me about your question and an issue and i'll and i'll get into it and see what we can do.

2806
04:48:20.280 --> 04:48:20.670
Andrea Boccaletti: Thank you.

2807
04:48:22.680 --> 04:48:24.480
james murez: yeah I was also going to comment that.

2808
04:48:24.480 --> 04:48:27.690
james murez: streetlights is something you might be able to take the parking and transportation.

2809
04:48:29.070 --> 04:48:35.370
james murez: Because the the city's not supposed to have lights to chime into your eyes into your in your windows of your House.

2810
04:48:37.320 --> 04:48:38.640
james murez: The suppose only be on the street.

2811
04:48:41.550 --> 04:48:48.390
james murez: Okay well anybody else have any comments they want to make the leak your hand is still up, I assume that that was by accident now it's down.

2812
04:48:50.760 --> 04:48:52.020
james murez: Nothing else.

2813
04:48:53.880 --> 04:48:57.990
james murez: So I think the only thing left, we have to do is adjourn.

2814
04:49:00.570 --> 04:49:02.040
Wait i'm getting a text.

2815
04:49:06.420 --> 04:49:07.290
From daffodil.

2816
04:49:08.970 --> 04:49:10.050
james murez: Okay well.

2817
04:49:11.490 --> 04:49:12.300
james murez: we're a journey.

2818
04:49:13.140 --> 04:49:14.640
james murez: We finished 15 minutes early.

2819
04:49:15.300 --> 04:49:16.230
Alix: Thank you all.

2820
04:49:16.380 --> 04:49:18.600
Sima Kostovetsky: Thank you good night everybody, thank you.

2821
04:49:18.780 --> 04:49:20.040
Andrea Boccaletti: Thank you, great meeting.

2822
04:49:20.490 --> 04:49:21.330
Sima Kostovetsky: goodnight everybody.

2823
04:49:24.210 --> 04:49:24.960
Alley Bean: dreams.